The prequels were a cautionary tale

George Lucas was always a borderline radical leftist in his politics. He based the OT on the Vietnam War, straight up saying the Rebels (i.e. the good guys) were inspired by the Viet Cong and the Empire on a combination of the US military and Nazi Germany (the Imp uniforms had a clear resemblance to SS ones). He also donated his personal wealth to things like constructing the MLK Jr. Memorial in Washington, DC.

It's really clear to me that the whole point of the prequels was George trying to communicate, "This is how authoritarian governments rise." On some level, I do think he was also trying to communicate, "This is also why young men are vulnerable to being radicalized into extremism" through the character of Anakin Skywalker.

When I see the rise of the global far right, I do see how much of it is driven by young men with grievances and radicalized into extremism with promises of, "I could give you what you always wanted (e.g., money, friends, the hot girl's love, etc.) which 'they' (whoever 'they' may be) were too stupid/shallow/woke/whatever to give you!" And then how many of these same young men end up losing everything like their money, their friends and family, and maybe even their lives because they were suckered into helping the far right.

Anakin Skywalker was promised the power to save everyone he loved (or rather, had an unhealthy possessiveness over) and to finally put the Separatists back in their place. Instead, he lost everyone that loved him and most of his own body because he was a sucker for Palpatine. At no point was Anakin actually rewarded for embracing fascism.

reddit.com
u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 1 month ago
▲ 60 r/prequelappreciation+1 crossposts

Anakin Skywalker is the villain of the prequel trilogy and you're NOT supposed to root for him

The whole point of the prequel trilogy was being the origin story of Darth Vader, the biggest monster the galaxy had ever known second probably only to Palpatine.

The Phantom Menace was the only time Anakin Skywalker approached being heroic. Even then, the good things he did, he did either by accident (blowing up the droid control ship) or with the specific intention of impressing Padme (winning the pod race).

Then, by the time we catch up with him in Attack of the Clones, he already possesses all the classic traits of a school shooter: an unhealthy obsession with a woman, extreme delusions of grandeur, and yes, the capacity to commit mass murder in a fit of rage. And at no point did he do anything remotely heroic. Even when it came to rescuing Obi-Wan and sending for the Jedi and clone reinforcements, Anakin was pushed into it by Padme.

And then finally, we come to Revenge of the Sith. Not only was that when Anakin officially became Darth Vader, but the movie's plot was completely centered around his possessiveness over Padme. Basically, "If I can't have her, then I'm gonna go apeshit and kill everyone." And to top it all off, we see Anakin was also a domestic abuser who was ready to Force choke his pregnant wife to death in a fit of rage. And no, I don't buy that "Anakin didn't choke Padme, that was Vader" BS. Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader were always the same person.

Anakin spends the whole trilogy blaming everyone else for his problems, including the Jedi and Obi-Wan. The thing is other Star Wars characters (Luke Skywalker, Leia Organa, and Yoda, to name a few) suffered far greater personal tragedies than, "I'm worried about my wife's pregnancy and I was denied a promotion at work", and they didn't plunge the galaxy into darkness the way Anakin did. It's exactly the same lesson that was taught in The Killing Joke: Anakin Skywalker becoming the biggest monster the galaxy had ever known was completely Anakin's own fault.

Some of the greatest movies of all time (namely Citizen Kane and The Godfather) had anti-heroes as their main characters. And Revenge of the Sith made it clear that Anakin, much like Charles Foster Kane and Michael Corleone, lost everything that was near and dear to him because he got as drunk with power as he did. At no point was the point of the trilogy, "The galaxy got what it deserves for misunderstanding Anakin and not giving him what he wanted."

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 1 month ago
▲ 919 r/OkBuddySnyderCult+1 crossposts

What was your first reaction when you watched Zack Snyder’s Justice League?

I remember staying up late into the night, basically pulling an all-nighter just to watch it. It was epic. 🍿 I really miss the excitement of that event.

What about you? What do you remember about your first time watching it?

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 1 month ago
▲ 2.6k r/aislop

What OOP is really saying is, "I could only get married if a man forced her daughter to marry me"

Incels love AI slop because they're jealous of real artists, who are usually emotionally intelligent enough to have something going on romantically.

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 2 months ago
▲ 674 r/prequelappreciation+1 crossposts

Revenge of the Sith Should Have Kept the Founding of the Rebellion Subplot

I think Revenge of the Sith's story really hurt Padme's character in the long run.

In The Phantom Menace, she basically fought the Trade Federation off on her own with minimal help from the Jedi. In Attack of the Clones, she more than held her own during the Battle of Geonosis.

Granted, Padme was pregnant in Revenge of the Sith, but she had the deleted subplot in which she laid down the foundation for the Rebellion along with Bail Organa and Mon Mothma. This subplot could have shown that despite being just about ready to birth Luke and Leia, Padme still had agency, stuck to her ideals, and, most importantly, was willing to defy Anakin when it came down to it. It would've been cool for Padme to have been the mother of the Rebel Alliance in addition to the mother of Luke and Leia.

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 1 month ago

Thank goodness America isn't run by religious fanatics who are all about restricting the rights of women, racial/religious minorities, and LGBTs, sexually abusing underage girls, radicalizing young men using social media, and literally blowing up opposing voices. Oh wait...

I've lived in Deep Red parts of America, and I currently live in Mamdani's New York.

Guess where I saw more of an appetite for the "benefits" of Sharia Law. Hint: not in Mamdani's New York.

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 2 months ago

We Haven't Seen The Last of Rose

uj/ I never watched the Lego Star Wars shows because I have precisely 0 interest in them. But I'm happy that Kelly Marie Tran got to return to the character of Rose in some shape or form.

Source: Kelly Marie Tran's Wikipedia article.

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 2 months ago

MAGAs don't care about our military

I'm old enough to remember 9/11 and how the in-vogue thing was conservatives, specifically the overweight middle aged variety who would never dream of putting on a uniform and putting themselves in danger, sticking yellow "Support Our Troops" stickers on the backs of their SUVs. I'm also old enough to how criticism of the Iraq War was met with, "Anyone who disagrees with this war is an anti-American sympathizer with Islamic terrorists and hates our military."

I also remember how conservatives, specifically the kind who would never dream of connecting a veteran with a job or affordable housing, donating to a veterans' charity, or volunteering at a VA hospital, reliably said, "What about our veterans?" whenever they saw a liberal politician propose something that benefits someone they don't like. Basically, "Why are we helping <insert marginalized group here> when we have homeless veterans?"

And oh look: Cadet Bonespurs and SecDef Kegsbreath decided to start a completely unplanned war with Iran just to get the media to stop talking about the Epstein files. And MAGAs did an about face from "Support Our Troops" to "lol look how wimpy our troops are! How dare they not answer to Dear Leader Trump's beck and call?" And the bots and overseas troll farms came up with the narrative of, "lol but these are wimps who enlisted under Biden! No wonder our military is so weak!"

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 2 months ago
▲ 481 r/aislop

Chad Traditional Artist: It was an honor to provide the training data for the future of art so some incel tech bro can use my art without paying or crediting me

Reddit pushes the r/DefendingAIArt sub to me. The whole sub is just AI slop that's cringey memes defending AI slop.

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 2 months ago

If New York is such a hell hole, then pray tell why isn't Fox News moving out of their midtown HQ in favor of the supposed conservative paradise that is Florida?

Though I've been to Miami a number of times.

Far from being the conservative paradise that's an alternative to New York, I found that traffic is actually worse in the Miami area, apartment rents even deep in the Miami suburbs are frequently more than what they are in New York, and the crime rate in Miami on a good day is actually double New York's. Anyone who's ever seen Scarface knows that Miami is a key point for the Latin American drug trade.

But seriously: Fox News moving out would actually be welcomed by most New Yorkers.

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 2 months ago

Why do Anakin stans make Padme something she isn't?

I wanted to share a bit of AI slop that I found on Instagram, but I won't out of sub rules.

When Gen AI became a thing, some of the most common AI slop I've been seeing depicts what happens following the "What If?" ending of the Revenge of the Sith video game in which Anakin has defeated Obi-Wan on Mustafar, overthrows Palpatine, and rules the Empire himself.

The common things I see in this fanfiction is Anakin ruling the Empire still as a fascist dictatorship, Luke and Leia growing up as Anakin's Sith disciples, and Padme...just submissively going along with it.

To me, it's obvious that Padme was always supposed to be the good that counterbalanced the evil in Anakin/Vader. Within the movie, Padme straight up says, "You're going down a path I can't follow." Nowhere in Padme's characterization is there any indication that she would've just submissively followed Vader in the Empire had she survived.

So I ask: Why do so many fans read Padme not as the genuine strong woman who basically fought off the Trade Federation herself and laid down the foundation for the Rebellion, but just as Anakin's submissive prize? There's absolutely no timeline where Padme survives and doesn't align herself with the Rebellion.

reddit.com
u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 2 months ago

Still waiting for a Republican to define communism

And no, communism isn't just, "Someone who's a member of a group I don't like now has something nice."

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 2 months ago

Why does The Fandumb Menace make Padme something she isn't?

I wanted to share a bit of AI slop that I found on Instagram, but I won't out of respect for Rule 7 of this sub.

When Gen AI became a thing, some of the most common AI slop I've been seeing depicts what happens following the "What If?" ending of the Revenge of the Sith video game in which Anakin has defeated Obi-Wan on Mustafar, overthrows Palpatine, and rules the Empire himself.

The common things I see in this fanfiction is Anakin ruling the Empire still as a fascist dictatorship, Luke and Leia growing up as Anakin's Sith disciples, and Padme...just submissively going along with it.

To me, it's obvious that Padme was always supposed to be the good that counterbalanced the evil in Anakin/Vader. Within the movie, Padme straight up says, "You're going down a path I can't follow." Nowhere in Padme's characterization is there any indication that she would've just submissively followed Vader in the Empire had she survived.

So I ask: Why do so many fans read Padme not as the genuine strong woman who basically fought off the Trade Federation herself and laid down the foundation for the Rebellion, but just as Anakin's submissive prize?

reddit.com
u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 2 months ago

Yes, but what about the Epstein files?

Oh, and thank you for reminding us that Fox News readers voted for a pedophile because they are too racist and misogynistic for a dark-skinned woman president.

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 3 months ago

Maybe Elon should spend more time actually running his business and less time crusading against wokeness?

I remember when the Tesla board considered replacing Elon as CEO because being CEO is supposed to be a full time job. In addition to (allegedly) being CEO of other companies, he was obviously distracted with buying an election for Donald Trump and revving up his online cult of racist incels. Elon only got to keep his CEO position and win an inflated comp package because his brother had outsized voting rights on the board.

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 3 months ago

Hot Waffles Shilling for Disney in 2005

Don't they know the prequels were Star Wars at its best? Only wokies and Disney shills disagree.

"FROM MY POINT OF VIEW, THE JEDI ARE EVIL!" is peak writing because Anakin is literally me, bro.

u/Fine-Essay-3295 — 3 months ago