If returning is the rep, why do I keep trying to stay?
They tell me the rep is losing and returning attention. Attention drifts, you notice, you return. That's the unit. That's what counts.
So what is the staying for?
If returning is the rep, then returning is the point. More returns, more reps. A mind that stayed on the breath would earn nothing.
I return well. I do not stay well. Half a breath, sometimes less, before I am gone. Three full breaths in a row is a rare animal. I see it maybe once a sitting, if that.
Some days it isn't even a departure. It's a flicker: breath-thought-breath-thought. So fast it stops feeling like taking turns. It feels like both at once. The exhale and the other thing, side by side, sharing the same second.
It's disorienting and makes me angry at myself, which is its own kind of noise.
So how do you train the staying. Not the noticing. Not the return. The staying itself. Is it a separate muscle, or does it just show up, uninvited, after enough reps of return.