Sonic X-treme ideas
Just to preface, this isn’t a post about should it have been released etc, we all already know the issues around that. Although I would like to hear people’s thoughts on the game, I think it obviously wouldn’t be able to compete with Mario 64 and crash but it still could’ve been a good game if finished. Anyway back to the main point.
Every now and then I get the urge to check if any of the x-treme fan games have made any progress (usually they haven’t but you never know). But one thing that bothers me about them is how short the levels look. It takes a couple of minutes per level but that’s when they’re collecting everything and most people wouldn’t do that, so I imagine you’d blitz through them if heading straight for the goal, (I’m not saying it should be a 5-10 hour game or anything but I imagine something like 2 hours would be fine). So I was thinking of ways to lengthen them a bit and thought I’d put it here on the off chance someone making a fan game sees it.
- have it like sonic 8 bit where the chaos emeralds (or games equivalent) are hidden in the levels to entice exploration. This might negate the need for special stages but I imagine you could also introduce another collectable for them
or even just hide the special stages entrance like 3d blast (that would probably be best).
- in the trailers you see these bridges with loops that send sonic to another point on the map, so maybe you could make them activate by a switch that’s hidden somewhere else and make the bridge progress you to another area that’s otherwise blocked off. Not the next act but more like a little puzzle to be able to progress to the goal, again this would entice exploration more.
- either make it so you have to destroy every enemy (like sonic 3D blast) or give an incentive to do so, I was thinking something like odd world (or the opposite I guess) where getting everyone leads to the good ending, I know the emeralds usually do this but I think it could still work and you could still use the emeralds to unlock the final boss or level or something (or have it the other way round), or this could just be something extra to do on top of that that would lead to an even better ending. You could even do it like banjo where doing everything makes the final boss easier, just something to incentivise it.
That’s some ideas that I just wanted to get off my chest lol, I’d be interested to hear anyone else’s as well, like what do you think would’ve made it a better game?