I think I finally understand “pretty privilege” a little, and why it can mess with your head
I’m a guy approaching 40, and I think I’ve only recently understood one part of “pretty privilege.”
I was married for about 10 years and had basically no adult dating experience. I never thought of myself as especially attractive, and got almost zero romantic attention as a teenager.
After my divorce I spent about a year focusing on myself, career, gym, clothes, grooming, skincare, hair/beard, etc. Basically a late-30s glow-up.
Then I got on Hinge.
In my first few months I went on seven dates and six wanted to keep seeing me seriously. After a later two-year relationship ended, I went back to dating and the same thing happened again, but even more intensely.
Lots of matches, women initiating sex quickly, buying me concert tickets, inviting me on trips, wanting relationships, etc. At one point I somehow had four overlapping situationships, and most knew I was dating other women.
What surprised me was how much some women would tolerate.
Women I thought would say “absolutely not, sort your shit out” sometimes stayed involved. Some kept coming back after I ended things. Some accepted situations they previously said they wouldn’t.
That changed how I think attraction works.
I used to think looks mostly got you through the door, then personality and behaviour determined what happened.
Now I think strong attraction can actually change the rules.
People tolerate more, attach faster, become sexual faster, forgive more and rationalise red flags they probably wouldn’t accept from someone they were less attracted to.
Ironically, the woman I fell hardest for was probably the least conventionally attractive of the women I dated. I found her very attractive personally, but it was mostly her personality and our connection.
She also had the strongest boundaries.
Her assessment was basically, you’re smart, fun and fundamentally decent, but you’re insecure and using attention from women to feed your ego, and I don’t want to be part of the mess.
She was probably right.
Going from very little romantic validation for most of my life to suddenly getting a lot of it did weird things to my brain.
And I finally understood something attractive women often say:
Having lots of people want you isn’t necessarily the same as knowing why someone wants you.
Do they actually like your personality? Are you unusually compatible? Or are they overlooking things because they’re extremely attracted to you?
The biggest lesson for me has been this:
If people keep rewarding you even when you behave badly, you need stronger internal boundaries because the outside world stops enforcing them for you.
I occasionally mistook “she still really wants me” for evidence that my behaviour couldn’t be that bad.
Obviously, that was wrong. I am fucking around with several women, in love with one who doesn't really want me right now, talking to multiple exes and lying to some.
I still don’t think I’m exceptionally handsome. I suspect it’s more the combination of looks, fitness, grooming, career, confidence and personality.
But my dating experience changed enough after improving my appearance that I no longer believe looks simply get your foot in the door.
Do highly attractive men genuinely experience a different set of behavioural rules from women, or am I over-attributing this to looks?