I (16M) feel like my best friend (16F) might be homophobic because of the kind of guys she’s attracted to. [Discussion] [Family/Friends]
I know the title sounds weird, and I don’t really know how to explain this without making it sound worse than it is, but this has been bothering me for a while.
I’m a 16 yo gay guy, and my best friend is a 16 yo girl. I’ll call her Audrey.
Audrey is genuinely the best friend I’ve ever had. We’ve only been close for about a year and a half, but she’s already done more for me than any other friend I’ve ever had. She’s always there when I need someone, she’s supportive, and she has never directly treated me badly because of my sexuality.
That’s why this situation is so confusing.
As far as I know, Audrey has always considered herself supportive of LGBTQ+ people. Before we became friends, her best friend was also gay. She’s never made homophobic jokes, never used slurs around me, and has never said anything that made me think she secretly disliked gay people.
The problem isn’t what she says.
It’s the guys she likes.
Her type is basically the stereotypical Spanish “street” guy. If you’re not familiar with that culture, imagine the kind of teenage guys who act extremely macho, think being gay is something to mock, get drunk and high at a young age, and make their entire personality about looking tough. Obviously not every guy like that is the same, but where I live, a HUGE (If not all of them) percentage of the ones she’s interested in are openly homophobic.
Some of them are the kind of people who harass gay people in public. Sometimes they’re even the type you later see in local news after attacking someone.
And somehow those are exactly the guys she keeps falling for.
Every single guy she’s liked since I’ve known her has openly had beliefs that go directly against who I am.
She’s never dated any of them seriously, so I’ve never actually met one in person. But I’ve seen enough.
A few of these guys have seen pictures of me on her Instagram or Snapchat and immediately started making really disgusting comments about me being gay. Not teasing, not edgy jokes but actual homophobic comments.
As far as I know, she didn’t join in or insult me herself, but she also never completely cut those guys off because of it. She would eventually move on from them, but usually because they weren’t interested in her or things didn’t work out, not because they were homophobic.
A while ago, this topic actually came up in my friend group.
We were talking about people dating racists, homophobes, etcetera, and I said something like:
“I think if your boyfriend is openly homophobic, racist, or believes horrible things, and you’re perfectly okay with that, then you probably share those beliefs to some extent, or at least you don’t think they’re a dealbreaker.”
Audrey never joined in.
Another thing that might be relevant is that Audrey has really bad luck with relationships.
I don’t want this post to sound like I’m judging her for that because I’m genuinely not, I also don't have good luck.
But realistically, she develops a crush on a new guy roughly every month and a half or every two months. We’ve been best friends since January 2025, so that’s about a year and a half. If you do the math, that’s at least nine different guys, and honestly I think it’s probably been more than that.
The weird part is that despite all those different crushes… the pattern never changes.
They’re almost always the same type of guy.
The same attitude, social circles and "being gay is disgusting" mentality.
At some point it stopped feeling like bad luck and started feeling like she was actively attracted to people with those beliefs.
That’s what’s bothering me.
Because if every single person you’re romantically interested in thinks people like me are disgusting, what does that say about you?
I don’t think Audrey secretly hates me.
If anything, her actions toward me suggest the opposite.
But I also struggle to understand how someone can genuinely support LGBTQ+ people while repeatedly being attracted to people who openly despise LGBTQ+ people.
I know attraction isn’t something you consciously choose.
But choosing to keep pursuing someone after you know they’re openly homophobic feels like a choice.
And that’s the part I can’t stop thinking about.
She’s my best friend, and I genuinely don’t want to lose her over something that I’m misunderstanding.
At the same time, one thing I know for sure is that I don’t really want to be close friends with someone whose values secretly align with the people who would happily make my life miserable just because I’m gay.
is this a reasonable thing to be concerned about?