u/No-Contribution2580

Join Manus now and claim free credits! https://manus.im/invitation/3GISNMZVJMIHA3H?utm\_source=invitation&utm\_medium=social&utm\_campaign=reddit

Since dumbledore knew harry had the cloak on him the whole time was he tempted to have the elder wand, the resurrection stone and the invisibility cloak in the same room as a way of having them all together in the same room afyer spending decades wanting them all together (he knew since he didnt own the cloak he knew it they where just in the same room and not acually united together and wouldnt make him the master of death), if so he was probably very tempted to unite them in the first lesson resulting in him removing it from the study shortly after, that would be a good explanation why the ring with the stone was gone in the lessons after the firsr one knowing he couldnt risk it again nor could he endager harry to his possible temptations to take the cloak from him, what do you all think,

I found it hard to be angry with snape when he wqs cruel in the books because of the voice

​

Also im not criticising the voice for snape in the audio full cast books i loved it

In the goblet of fire book when voldemort brings up his immortality in his speech to the death eaters he make it sound like he was telling them he invented his own way (like when he says "it would appear one or more of my experiments worked for i was not killed")

And while it's obvious he wanted to hide his horcruxes and there existence of them it also feels like hes making it sound like hes invemted his own way and to make it look like hes way more powerful and smart then he really is. He also probably would of found it embarrassing admitting he just stole another dark wizards (the one that invented hircruxes) idea and multiplied it by 7

While in the movie they had harrys on voldemort fight eachother all over hogwarts given how it made more sence to give the audience (mostly the ones that didnt read the books) the final battle they where looking forward to for so many years it was over done (but still felt like the right choice) the book version has harry tell voldemort about him being the master of the elder wand while being surrounded by hundreds of people, and eventhough they would never try yo kill harry theres a huge chance the conversation got out, harry pretty much put a large target on his head as hundreds of people would want to own the elder wand,

although after writing some fanfics i can get why jk Rowling over did it as she might of been so exited that she lost control of herself and slightly over did it lol, still it was the perfect final

Anyway this just my opinion, please let me know what you think in the comment section

While both the movies and books are perfect, I just feel like anyone who plans to get into harry potter for the first time heres some advice As someone whos seen the movies before reading the books I can tell you that you'll be able to enjoy the movies before realising how much is changed snd left out when reading the books,

after reading the books it was hard to enjoys some of the scenes in the movies given how much id altered and left oit (especially on the goblet of fire, they litterally rushed threw 10 chapters in the book in less then 20 minutes)

while I recommend watching the movies before reading the books please dont think less of the movies there still awsome, there are even scenes and characters in the movie that are way better then in the books

Anyway this all my opinion you dont have to agree with me

Also I apoligise for the title of the page, i just realised it makes it seem like im making it sound like im telling you what to do, im not im just giving my opinion, your all entitled to your opinions, if anyone knows how to edit the title please let me know so i can fix it

The affects of the depression posion voldemort used in the cave to defend the locket horcrux seems to both replicates and amplifie the affects of the depression felt by dementors when they are near