What Is The Tone of Dark Sun, To You?

Obviously WotC has a very specific vibe they're going for, if the reveal animation is anything to go by. I'm making this post after watching that but before any more reading on the upcoming release; but before I do that, I want to ask the board:

What, for you, is the tone 2e and 4e Dark Sun was aiming for?

If possible, please express this without referencing the 5e announcement. I want to see what people's thoughts are isolated from the new release if at all possible.

reddit.com
u/OisforOwesome — 21 days ago

Cadbury Velvet is just the old Dunedin Factory recipe, right?

Cadbury Velvet is Cadbury's latest effort to part us from our money, and when a bunch of dated stock went on clearance I finally checked it out.

The label promises 40% more cocoa and 25% more milk, which, great, you can actually taste the extra effort - but I gotta say, and I'm willing to put this down to my encroaching old age and the attendant "back in my day" nostalgia - doesn't this just taste like Cadbury used to taste before production in Dunedin was shut down?

It's better than the regular stuff. I don't think it's better than Whittakers and I think it's a bit rich be charging premium pricing for the thing we used to take as the baseline.

Anyway: Any other old fogeys feel the same, or am I going doolally?

reddit.com
u/OisforOwesome — 1 month ago

[LES] Kazuya from Rent-A-Girlfriend was always a cuck.

There are two things this series is known for:

  1. Its absolutely dogshit anti-sex-worker sexual politics

  2. The fan base going apeshit over a manga chapter where the MC gets an erection in a swimming pool imagining a love interest with another man.

But, like, within the first 2 minutes of the anime, Kazuya says he is aroused at the thought of his ex Mami having a new boyfriend. A lot of mileage is milked out of the jealousy he feels that his sex worker love interest has other clients or his embarrassment that he would feel if someone finds out about his sexual experience or lack thereof.

The cuckoldry is essential to the premise. The only reason anyone could miss it is if they have the media comprehension of the average weeb.

reddit.com
u/OisforOwesome — 1 month ago

Survey of Unorthox Methods of Warfare: The Tertium Campaign As Borderline Logistical Heresy

++++Thought of the Day: An Open Mind Is As A Fortress Unguarded++++

TITLE: Survey of Unorthodox Methods of Warfare: The Tertium Campaign As Borderline Logistical Heresy AUTHOR: [ >!REDACTED!< ], Logis Administratum, Adeptus Administratum DATE: 999.M41 - 012.M42 (Temporal Confidence Interval disputed)

The Tertium Campaign is an oddity within the context of wider Imperial military ventures. Not because of its leadership - Inquisitors are of course authorised to conduct planetary scale warfare should the threat to the Imperium require it, and have broad authority to requisition men and material to this end - but because of the internal organizing principle of the so-called "Rejects" Inquisitor Grendyll has forged into a lethal and disposable fighting force.

Recruited from the lower castes of Tertium (Tithe grades LXVI and below), the Rejects are a motley collection of disgraced Adeptus Militratum veterans, un- or barely-sanctioned psykers, fanatical crusaders answering the Inquisition's call to martyrdom, or outright Hive Ganger scum brought onto Grendyll's flagship, the Mourningstar, and dispatched in four-man commando teams to conduct asymmetrical guerilla warfare against the dark forces besieging Hive Tertium on Atoma Prime.

(Recent developments have seen members of the Mechanicum's military levies, the Skitarii, and Adeptus Arbites dispatched to accompany these Rejects).

Small, elite units within the Imperium are common enough, but tend to fall within two main logistical camps: Lone operators raised since birth or from a young age, equipped with specialized wargear and unique training to specialise in a given method of war as seen in the Departmento >!REDACTED!<, or highly regimented crack troops raised alongside or recruited from Adeptus Militarum regiments, as in the case of Tempestus Scions.

The Rejects programme, however, is to a large extent left to their own devices. A Scion is issued their armour, weapons, and rations by the Munitorium and resupply is handled by the Quartermaster Corp in accordance to doctrine and writ; a Reject, however, is free to choose their own armament and develop their training off their own initiative, and it is left to their judgement how best to prepare for a given task before them.

Indeed, individual Rejects may select when and even which missions they want to be deployed on (provided they meet minimum deployment thresholds)- a level of latitude unheard of in any other theatre of war.

Inquisitor Grendyll has established what could only be called a market for wargear. The Mourningstar, the ship Grendyll has established as the flagship for the Tertium campaign, has a deck devoted to this commerce. At any given moment dozens of Rejects can be found bartering with script issued by the Warband or materials scrounged during sorties, exchanging these tokens at 'Company stores' for weapons or for alterations to weapons they have already acquired.

Access to different kinds of weapons is governed by a "trust level," a metric which tracks how many missions a Reject has successfully completed. While loyalty metrics are commonplace in the Empire, and rightly so, for Loyalty to the Emperor is the foremost virtue to be cultivated and disloyalty the earliest indicator of heretical conduct, it is almost unheard of for the subjects of these metrics to be made aware of its existence and to be able to track the precise values of this metric.

Once a Reject has gathered enough script to equip themselves with reliable weapons, one might think that they would have no further use for the Ordo Dockets and other script issued to them in exchange for their services. Not so: In parallel to weapons of war the Rejects have access to accoutrements and fashions through the Commissary. The decks of the Mourningstar are as much a fashion show to rival the whims of the High Lords of Terra (Blessed by His Light). The only thing that does not appear to be for sale are rations, with crew and conscript alike fed and watered at the appropriate ration stations in accordance with regular Munitorium doctrine.

Advocates for this system will say that the combination of incentives in this market system encourages individual initiative and exemplary performance, as the Rejects compete with each other to maximise their individual rewards in both script and Trust Level points.

A literature review for similar methods of organisation finds similarities with the models of the Ordo Neoliberalis, a sect within the Administratum that argues for decentralized and financialized systems of production and distribution. For a full discussion on the case for and against the Ordo Neoliberalis, refer to appendix MCMXVIII of this report for thorough analysis.

It is however a contentious model. Its proponents will argue that setting Imperial Tithes centrally at Holy Terra many light years (and thanks to Warp temporal discrepancies, many actual years) distant from the tributary worlds is inefficient and risks over-burdening the economies of those tributaries; better to leave Planetary Governors to their own devices to maximise tithes in exchange for rewards and prestige for their contributions to the Imperium. Greed, they say, is not a temptation to fall into the arms of the Archenemy, but rather a powerful motivation that can be harnessed to the needs of Imperial Truth.

Critics however will point to the many, many, many examples of Planetary Governors shirking their responsibilities for personal enrichment and aggrandizement, even falling to treachery and heresy as a result, as evidence that this way is not only inefficient, but borderline heretical. Any productivity gains are illusory; a Throne may purchase a bullet or a ration, but cannot in itself slay a heretic or feed a martyr. What does it profit the Emperor, to have the wealth of worlds, but allow a traitor to live in luxury?

In the case of the Tertium campaign, we can see the shortcomings of the market-devolved model. Every day thousands of Reject strike teams are dispatched from the Mourningstar, and succeed or fail, any given strike team will slay hundreds of traitors and heretics in the name of the Emperor, with an acceptable margin of Martyrdom for their efforts.

However, in the words of Sergeant-Major Morrow: "Kill one heretic, nothing changes. Kill a thousand, raises a smile, but not much else." Despite years of effort, the battle for Tertium remains at a strategic stalemate. One Reject interviewed for this report put it succinctly: "I feel like I've done all this before."

Despite all the intelligence gathered, Moebian steel fabricated, and Heretical rituals foiled, Hive Tertium remains in the grip of servants of the Archenemy. Individual Rejects can boast the finest wargear and most splendid garb, can count scores of foes of the Empire slain on their efforts, and yet the war as a whole seems a quagmire. The slaughter of the enemies of Mankind is a reward in its own right, and yet every year spent on grueling endless war is a year not spent mustering Guard legions and sending Tithes for the defense of the wider Empire.

Whether Inquisitor Grendyll's experiment is a success or a failure we will only know in the fullness of time, and whether a more conventional campaign would see greater or lesser success is a counter-factual that this scribe lacks the holy datum to fabricate an informed conjecture. What is the case is that Atoma and Tertium represent a unique case for study, and as such this scribe wishes to petition for a Logis Administratum Clerk Cadet Corp to better document and evaluate this unique experiment.

May His Light Bring Justice And Purity To Humanity's Darkest Hour,

The Emperor Protects,

High Scribe >!REDACTED!<, Logis Administratum.

reddit.com
u/OisforOwesome — 1 month ago

All Of The Ways Masters of the Universe (2026) Disappointed Me (Spoilers)

See, I wanted this to be good.

I didn’t precisely have high expectations. I mean, Jared Leto is in this movie, and there’s pretty much a 1-to-1 correlation of “Jared Leto having a major role” and “the movie fucking sucking so much shit.”

But the film looks so fucking good. The visual design is impeccable. It’s lush, it’s technicolour, even the CGI - you can really see every hour the poor underpaid overworked digital effects team poured into this thing on the screen.

The issue, to my mind, is the script is simultaneously over- and under-egged. And in this rant I am going to spend far too much time explaining why.

There will be spoilers but don’t worry you probably don’t want to spend actual money on going to see this thing.

  1. You Do Not Need To Apologise For The Source Material

The movie starts with a five minute monologue that simultaneously lore dumps the entire setting premise and apologises for how goofy it is. When we meet Fisto, we are forced to sit through a whole routine about how Fisto sounds like a sex act. Adam’s who characterisation during the Earth sequence is about how he’s a dork with childish fantasies but no really they’re real you guys.

And it just kind of betrays the insecurity of the filmmakers. It undercuts the entire reason for this film to exist. Yes, MotU has goofy shit. Yes, it has a dude with a skull for a face. Yes, Ram Man is in fact a Man who Rams.

But that’s not something you apologise for or make quips about. That shit rules. That’s why I’m giving you two hours and twenty minutes of my life. Your job isn’t to be coy and twee, I can do that on my own time. Your job is to make Fisto the coolest shit I’m going to bear witness to this week, paled only in comparison to how cool Ram Man is.

Instead the film has decided that the code names are just young Adam’s childhood nicknames for the figures he’s been drawing his entire life from his half-recalled childhood memories of Eternia, and this is a source of an interminable amount of quips, and that’s tedious.

2. Joss Whedon And His Consequences Have Been An Unmitigated Disaster For The Human Race

Believe it or not there was once a time when Nerd Media and genre stories generally were not a hojillion dollar film business. Back in those dim dark days, you would be hard pressed to get normal people to care about an X Man unless you put them in black leather and made a few jokey-jokes to reassure them that this was Serious Business.

Then Avengers happened and Joss Whedon made Marvel a squintillion dollars and the lesson Hollywood took was “we need to be ironic and self-referential to sell genre stories. And maybe if the jokes in this movie were better I wouldn’t mind? Instead its dumb stuff like “Adam can’t drive a car properly so he starts the Sky Sled in reverse.” Or the dumb needle drop of “what’s going on” at a random inconsequential beat in the story.

(It’s a great song and yes it’s an all-time meme indelibly etched into the popular consciousness of this property but if you’re going to make that reference, make it mean something).

Likewise, the Queen “Princes of the Universe” needle drop works so much better if you don’t immediately undercut it with the characters choking on dust (and should by all rights have been immediately before a climactic fight scene not where it was).

Skeletor frying Moss Man and immediately quipping “Look, I made mulch!” - I appreciate you’re trying to sell Skeletor as this unhinged Jokerfied madman but guys, no. Nobody’s laughing.

3) Keep Your Politics Out Of My Toy Commercial Childhood NostalgiaSlop

So… this film has a very confused perspective on masculinity.

We need to pause here for a second and swerve into a brief discussion of the He-Man Filmation cartoon. Because that cartoon was hella gay. Unbelievably gay. There is no heterosexual explanation for this.

Every episode followed the same basic plot beats: Skeletor would get up to some bullshit, He-Man would throw something heavy at the problem, and before the credits He-Man would turn ot the camera and explain how this demonstrated some form of pro-social value.

And the thing is, He-Man was actually a very empathetic character. Always talking about the value of friendship. Whenever Cringer got scared he would reassure him and more often than not extending empathy and understanding was the solution to the scheme of the week.

He-Man 2026 however roots its conception of masculinity in opposition to empathy and understanding. Adam’s pussy Earth job for suckers is working in corporate Human Resources where he has to list his fucking pronouns on the nameplate on his desk. Before his big transformation scene his attempts to negotiate with Trap-Jaw using HR speak are played for laughs.

It’s hard not to read this in the context of the online right wing culture wars, where grifting content creators rely on outrage bait to activate aggrieved men whose only joy in life is sending death threats to women and minorities. There’s a whole right-wing freakout over “feminine” and “soy” email jobs like HR being fake made-up jobs for women so they can have unearned power over vigorously alive men.

This is confused however by young Adam in his boyhood failing at fight training and being lectured by his father and Man-At-Arms at how men needing to be big manly fight-men who fight like manly muscle men. King Randor beams with pride when He-Man finally busts some heads in front of him - only to apologise for bullying young Adam while dying in He-Man’s arms. Man-at-Arms’ whole arc is realising that actually yeah to be a good dad you do have to do the whole feelings thing and maybe staking your entire identity on your job risks an emotional collapse when circumstances outside your control mean you don’t don’t succeed at it. Adam even leans on his HR background to rally the troops as part of his inspirational speech.

So emotional vulnerability and emotional intelligence is at once cucked and soy and also necessary for victory and a mark of maturity. It’s presented as an end credits gag but I did actually like the “Bad Guys Monologue, Good Guys Dialogue” illustration during the credits; that feels like that’s a vestige of a version of this plotline that was more clearly delivered.

I feel like there may have been a stronger throughline of ‘patriarchal expectations of masculinity set men up for inevitable failure as these standards are inherently unreachable and its through developing emotional maturity and empathy we can become whole people” in earlier drafts that got muddled through re-writes or something?

If it is the case that the whole “bitch HR manager” angle was put in to appease the anti-woke grifters - my dudes, you cast Idris Elba as a character that was historically white. That was always going to piss these tourists off. You cannot win with these parasites. Just make a good film and they can cry about it.

4. I Kinda Hate It When Movies Like This Go To Earth

It was dumb when He-Man 1987 did it and I feel like He-Man 2026 - if it really truly desperately wanted to go to Earth for whatever reason - could have executed on this better.

The issue, I think, is that framing Adam as this doofus who really truly sincerely believes he is a long-lost space prince and will babble about this to an unsuspecting date at the drop of a hat, only to be vindicated when a space ship and a shaggy beast-man turn up… kind of leaves the other theme the movie wants to execute on - that is, that our childhood heroic daydreams are actually meaningful - in the lurch.

The opposition Adam faces to his childhood dreams of super-heroics takes the form of the two-faced HR lady firing him for googling too many swords on work time, his roommate kinda softly ribbing on him, and Skeletor mocking him for being a pussy through a series of flashbacks during their fight.

(I’m going to just mentally block out the sequence in the comic book store as some sub-par Big Bang Theory pastiche)

And that’s, like… not really enough to set up the conflict?

Script doctoring this, I’d be positioning things as: After fleeing to Earth as a five year old, Adam is taken into a foster system where he copes with the institutional indifference and cruelty towards orphaned children by telling anyone who will listen stories of Eternia and the heroes who stood up for the downtrodden and used their powers to help people. The System however - school, the orphanage staff, his workplace - all conspire to squeeze the sense of whimsy and hope and dream out of him so that he can fit into the mold society has created for men to fit into. Heck, he even gets made fun of for his pink shirt and kitten jersey.

And it’s when he’s been fired for working on his Eternia web novel on company time (ask me how I know this is a fireable offense) at his lowest ebb, that he finds the sword and instigates the events of the movie.

This frames the reality of Eternia as a childhood fixation that has no place in the adult world - and yet its a childhood fixation that he can draw strength and courage from. The stories of Eternia taught him values of kindness and courage, of what our strength is for - a hand to help those who need it, not a hand to hold someone else down. That its those stories that matter, not the toys, not the plastic crap Mattel wants to sell us over and over again.

IDK. Maybe I’m doing that thing where the fanfic you come up with is always going to be more compelling that what hits the screen just because I came up with it.

5. Please For The Love of God Stop Casting Jared Leto In Things

He’s just box office poison. I don’t think he’s even that bad in this film. He’s clearly trying for a Raul Julia As M. Bison level total-commitment-to-the-bit camp performance here and mmmmaybe if the script didn’t have Skeletor constantly undercutting his own hamminess with references and quips he could have pulled it off, but honestly, can we please just leave Leto to his creepy groupie cult and stop indulging his narcissistic need to have his name on movie theatre posters?

6. Dolph Lundgren

I actually was excited to see him but I feel like his character could have been better?

This is just me thinking I’m cleverer than the scriptwriter but I figure when Adam asks him for advice, a better line could have been: “Never skip leg day. When you’re lifting, you need a strong foundation. The ass, son - the ass is the most important muscle in the body. Without it, you can’t lift crap. Remember, no matter what you do - put your whole ass into it. Never half-ass anything.”

IDK. He was just kinda mean then dropped a vague workshopped piece of wisdom to be called back to later in the film then ghosted. I guess the meanness is meant to tie into the masculinity plotline but I felt like a loveable goofball Dolph for Adam to aspire to be like would have been a better use of the time and actor.

Conclusion:

I wanted this to be good, and it almost, almost is. The script needed either one more or a few less passes to tighten up on some looseness in the themes and drop at least half of the ironic self-referential quips. I don’t even hate any of the performances. The soundtrack is amazing and the Eternia theme song fucking slaps. The film’s production design is perfect, and I have to commend the director’s instincts whenever he’s playing things straight.

I just wish there was a better throughline and commitment to the themes, and I wish we didn’t have to apologise for space barbarians riding flying rocket sleds punching skeletons and having emotional intelligence. That shit rocks and this movie almost, almost showed the world that this shit rocks.

I suppose my misgivings can be summed up like this:

What I wanted, was the feeling one gets when watching the Teen Titans Go! B.E.R synthwave episodes, like this video.

And what I got was maybe 70, 75% of that feeling.

Never half-ass anything, kids. Always put your whole ass into it.

u/OisforOwesome — 2 months ago

The Way We Talk About Franchise Films Is Just Sportsball For Nerds And I Fucking Hate It

You know who you are. You track box office numbers like other guys track baseball stats. You spend hours arguing over whether the Snyderverse or the Phase 1 & 2 MCU were better, and you feel personally attacked when your favourite IP doesn't get any Oscar noms. You don't necessarily power scale, but you do have very firm opinions on producer power-scaling; you are convinced that Producer A is poison to everything they touch (even though you only have a vague idea what producers actually do per se).

Above all, you are very invested in the revenue earned by one picture or another, and you use this as a direct metric for the quality of the film. You believe this is an objective measure, way better than critic scores, what do those eggheads know about what really makes a film good anyway?

Film-making for you is a question of which brand is doing better in ticket sales, and you talk about your favourite intellectual properties doing well or not more or less entirely in sales terms.

When Sony flirted with the idea of withholding Spider-Man from MCU films in exchange for a higher cut of the proceeds, you took Marvel's side reflexively arguing passionately that because Marvel had earned more money with Homecoming than the last ASM films that meant they deserved the character.

In short, you treat corporate intellectual property revenue farming as a sport and make the relative fortunes of billion dollar companies a core part of your personal identity.

This has to stop. It needs to stop. I don't care about Kathleen Kennedy or Bob Iger or David Zazlov. They certainly don't care about you. They don't even care about the characters and films under their management.

What you should care about is art, and artists. You should care about whether a film brings you joy or makes you feel something. You should care that the people who make the films, at all levels and in every role, are treated with dignity and paid for their labour.

I really don't care if Superhero Movie X has a poor box office; I care if the movie is good. The box office question only really matters in terms of The Money deciding whether or not the people who really matter - the artists who make the movie - get to make another one. Beyond that, dick-riding for corporations is deeply embarrassing and anyone who does so needs to feel bad for it.

reddit.com
u/OisforOwesome — 2 months ago

He's out of line, but he's got a point.

(/uj no he doesn't because he's a redfash huckster larping as a revolutionary for streaming revenue and he sucks)

u/OisforOwesome — 2 months ago

Do I need to care about Amazing Digital Circus

Its not just this sub. It seems like every fandom related subreddit is going through a wave of Digital Circus Posting and I have no idea what the fuck it is or why its popular, at least 55% of posters seem to actually hate the show, and the art style is deliberately designed to hurt my eyeballs.

So... is there a *there* there that I'm not seeing? Or can I safely file it in the "things I'm too middle aged to get" / "baby's first edgy media" drawer and ignore it?

reddit.com
u/OisforOwesome — 2 months ago

US justice department charges five men over alleged plot to attack White House UFC event

This made the 6pm news here in New Zealand but I'm not exactly seeing it blowing up in political chatter. Are we just so numb to the idea that yes of course people want to assassinate Trump and billionaires duh that its not really worth reporting?

&#x200B;

Also, the group was reported here as "heavily armed TikTokers" which is an amazing turn of phrase.

theguardian.com
u/OisforOwesome — 2 months ago