When to play Attack Peni
Disclaimer: I am a GM2 Peak Peni and this may be incorrect but feel free to comment. I am writing down these notes for the sake of discussion.
We've all seen it before. Someone runs attack Peni on one team and it's a tossup whether she runs the lobby or is completely useless. Attack Peni is extremely situational and it's taken me any hours to wrap my head around the macro situations at play.
Here are some scenarios that I came up with that can affect how I play attack Peni, or whether I play attack Peni at all:
Your team is running a brawl/dive comp against a poke comp. In this situation, the enemy team will get pushed back in an attempt to kite your frontline. If that's the case back to front attack Peni works wonderfully here. You can web off key choke points behind the enemy and they will walk into it like clockwork.
Your team is running poke against a brawl/dive comp. This is the inverse situation where your team gets forced back, so the space in the enemy backline that you mine off is essentially useless. In that case, switch to the reverse and play the nest in your backline to let the divers eat the mines.
Your team is running poke vs poke. This is one of the most suboptimal situations. You can't really run dive Peni here because Peni is hard as a solo diver, you can melt in seconds. Your team will inevitably get pushed back because Peni sucks as a frontline tank. Flank Peni is ineffective because the enemy has much more space to ignore you (this is assuming the enemy team is competent and the mk doesn't chase you alone into the nest for example)
I'm sure, though it's suboptimal, there are ways to get to make it work. You can play a hybrid frontline/flank playstyle where you take an off angle and harass positions the dps want to stand in. Or, you can time your dive/flank exactly when the enemy is making a play. This is much less consistent though.
- Your other tank isn't doing well. This is Attack Peni's biggest crutch I feel. Plenty of tanks don't know how to play with their Peni and will overextend far away from your nest, mistime their push with your flank, expect a second shield tank but then die because Peni isn't a shield tank. In a perfect world, both teams skill level can be equal so we can predict plays perfectly, but if you notice your other tank is always dying in seconds, then it may be time to swap off or adjust your playstyle.