Question about two characters and their interactions

So, I have read the Scadriel books through Alloy of Law. And, at the end, Marsh tells Marasi he isn't as good at soothing as Breeze was. I assume this was to let audiences who may not have put two and two together that this is a character from Era 1. But then I got to thinking about this line, maybe more than Sanderson intended us to think about it.

Maybe I am forgetting a scene in the Era 1 trilogy, but did Marsh and Breeze have any scenes together? I didn't think they did. The closest I can think of is when Marsh turns on the Steel Inquisitors and the whole crew is there, but I didn't think Marsh knew Breeze enough to comment on his soothing, especially a few centuries later.

Since I don't think Marsh was on good enough terms with Kelsier to have had any interactions with Breeze before the events of Final Empire, I am trying to figure out if Marsh had some adventures with what was left of Kelsier's crew after The Hero of Ages, and what those interactions would have looked like.

I could be an idiot and am misremembering some huge moment between these two, and if I am, please be gentle with me.

reddit.com
u/TheComixkid2099 — 3 days ago

Fixing the Roger Moore Bond films by more closely tying them in with the Connery/Lazenby era

All of the James Bond films from Dr. No to Diamonds are Forever involve the global terrorist organization SPECTRE, with the exception of Goldfinger. With Ernst Stavro Blofeld seemingly dying in Diamonds are Forever, (though, I am convinced the Blofeld we see in Diamonds isn't the real deal, as we later see a Bald neckbrace-wearing man in For Your Eyes Only, consistent with the injury Blofeld received in On Her Majesty's Secret Service), the threat of SPECTRE is seemingly no longer a concern for James Bond.

This is because of a complicated lawsuit between Ian Fleming, Kevin McClory and Jack Whittingham, as McClory and Whittingham created Blofeld and SPECTRE in an unmade attempt at a Bond film before Dr. No. This is why McClory was later able to remake Thunderball as Never Say Never Again. Apparently, this is why Blofeld and SPECTRE disappear from the Eon-produced Bond films. But, I am still a little fuzzy on the timeline, as the lawsuit was settled out of court in 1963, and Blofeld's last official appearance in the Eon films was Diamonds are Forever, in 1971. After the lawsuit, Blofeld appeared in three official films before being retired, so I am not 100 percent convinced the lawsuit is what kept him out of the movies for so long, but that seems to be the official story, so let's stick with that.

In any case, Blofeld (and SPECTRE's) absence is a problem, at least for Roger Moore's first two outings as Bond, Live and Let Die, and The Man with the Golden Gun. Both movies seem to depend on the conceit that everyone in the world knows and recognizes James, even though I would think that flies in the face of him being, you know, a secret agent. Almost everyone James runs into in Live and Let Die recognizes him and tries to kill him, which legitimizes Kananga's menace, but...how did all these people know who Bond is? I suppose you could say it's Solitaire's psychic abilities, but, personally, I would be okay with the occult not being overtly plausible. Have James be skeptical Solitaire is the real deal, anything she predicts can be chalked up to coincidence, whatever. The second explanation is that CIA Agent Carver, secretly working with Kananga, provided her employer with all the information she got from working with Felix Leiter before James came to America. In fact, that is my head-canon for the movie we got.

OR, what if we leapfrog off the events of the (apparent) death of Blofeld and tie that in with Kananga and his plot in Live and Let Die? Say Kananga was one of Blofeld's lieutenants, promoted after the death of one of the the many underlings during the Connery era. Either that, or, with the power vacuum caused by the lack of SPECTRE, Kananga is making his move, now, where he was afraid to move against SPECTRE, before. Either way, he somehow obtains SPECTRE's files on James, and that is why and how he is targeting Bond, because he fears Bond will take him out, just like he did Blofeld. (allegedly). This allows the plot to basically be the same, but, in my opinion, it now makes a little more sense.

The Man with the Golden Gun suffers a similar problem, as James is dragged into the plot when he thinks a famous assassin, Francisco Scaramanga, is gunning for him. It turns out, it was Scaramanga's mistress who sent Bond the bullet, hoping he could eliminate Scaramanga. But, again, how does this woman know who James Bond is? The easiest solution, here, is to say Scaramanga had previously done jobs for SPECTRE, and through his association with them, knew of Bond, and, Andrea Anders, through her association with Scaramanga, knew of Bond. This, again, more or less allows us to keep the plot the same, as it would only require a sentence or two to explain how these people know who Bond is. Just because everyone in our world knows who James Bond is, doesn't mean everyone in his world should know.

This isn't an expansive fix for the entire Moore era, but I think these basic ideas fix what are, in my opinion, pretty glaring problems. What do you all think? Am I wrong? Maybe. I didn't see the light of the Moore films until I was already a man. By then, it was nothing to me but blinding.

reddit.com
u/TheComixkid2099 — 7 days ago

My Sword and Sorcery haul from this weekend.

I have never read any non-Conan De Camp or Carter, so we will see how these are. I am looking forward to Lieber (and I think I only lack one of the Fafhrd and Gray Mouser books to complete the set)

u/TheComixkid2099 — 10 days ago

Your B-Tier S&S authors?

So, I am pretty sure if you polled everyone here, there would be a general consensus on the top 5ish S&S authors (Howard, Moorcock, Lieber, Moore and Wagner are the ones it seems to me get floated around as recommendations the most often).

But who would you recommend after those authors? Authors who are good, but maybe not quite good enough to be counted among the A-team? Hopefully, someone whose work isn't insanely out of print and requires getting another mortgage to pay for a copy, if possible.

I am somewhere between being a noob and being an expert on the genre, as I've just about exhausted Howard, Moorcock and Moore, while Wagner's Kane is proving a tad cost-prohibitive. And I do own quite a few of Lieber's stories, I just haven't gotten around to them, yet. (Well, I did read a Sci-Fi book he wrote, The Big Time, but, unfortunately, I didn't think much of that one).

So, I am essentially looking to broaden my horizons a little as I dive further into this genre. And, maybe others will catch some recommendations for their own entertainment, too.

reddit.com
u/TheComixkid2099 — 15 days ago

Question/Theory about Chet from Cytonic

Okay, not really any published spoilers, but spoiler tag just in case. A while back, I think during an Intentionally Blank, Mister Sanderson was asked a question, I don't remember the exact wording, but he said initial beta readers HATED Chet from Cytonic, and he rewrote the whole thing to fix the problems. But he didn't go into specifics on what people hated about Chet.

So, my question is, what does everyone think original Chet was like? I have absolutely nothing to base this off of, but my theory is Chet was originally closer to Spensa's age, and it was going to kind of sort of be a love triangle, with Spensa toying with staying in the Nowhere going hand in hand with her kind of liking Chet. And fans may have hated Chet because they were attached to Jorgen and Spensa.

But, what does everyone else think? Or has Sanderson gone into this in greater detail, elsewhere?

reddit.com
u/TheComixkid2099 — 17 days ago

Retelling the Marvel Cinematic Universe as an Epic Fantasy Series: The Incredible Orc

Picking up from my post where I remade the first Iron Man movie as an epic fantasy story, today, I do the same with the Incredible Hulk.

Abdias Stane stoking the flames of war in my Iron Man remake wasn't terribly difficult for him, because many people in this lose confederation of kingdoms still greatly mistrust the people across the sea thanks to the war from a couple of generations ago. (A lot of the details of the war, such as the Hydra and their capabilities, are thought to be hyperbole by the general populace, but the war itself and the foul taste it conjures in memories is real enough.)

As such, a few years ago, Thaddaeus, a high ranking commander in the King's Army, sought ways to fight the enemy, should the need arise. Maybe recreating the legends of a warrior who fought for the kingdoms in the war. He enlisted the help of a master from the Alchemist's Guilds, Hrodebert, whose family once bore the banner for the King's army, generations past.

Hrodebert fell in love with Thaddaeus' daughter, Elisheva, but it didn't work out, thanks to an accident with the chemicals Hrodebert was working with. Somehow, the accident transformed Hdorebert into an Orc, much like the ones allegedly ensorcelled by the Hydra generations ago (some of the legends of the war really are just legends). Unlike the Orcs of legend, though, this Orc has rudimentary understanding of human speech and emotions, but it is easily enraged, which happens frequently, as most humans' gut-instinct when they see a 12-foot monstrosity like this is to attack it.

Hrodebert went into hiding, as much because he feared what he had become, and didn't want to cause harm to others, especially Elisheva, but also because Thaddaeus wants to use Hrodebert in his Orc form, especially after the fallout from our Iron Man movie. Antonius and his friends tried their best to make it clear Abdias was acting out of self-interest in trying to start up a war, and that there was no need for the people on this side of the sea to worry themselves. But Thaddaeus is hardly known for his even temper. If there's no need for war at the moment, there likely will be, soon. As far as he's concerned, Hrodebert's experiment was a rousing success, and Hrodebert may very well be a traitor who refuses to aid his kingdom as he was hired to do.

Hrodebert went underground, trying to reverse the experiment. He took pity on an abused stable hand named Samouēl, and enlisted him as an assistant who would pick up supplies for him. Though Samouēl is ridiculed elsewhere for his low wit, he is smarter than he seems, and soon figures out Hrodebert is a fugitive, and why he is on the run. Seeking some retribution against those who have mocked him his entire life, Samouēl attempts to recreate Hrodebert's initial experiment, though it has a different effect on him, greatly increasing his intellect, instead of his strength.

But his vengeance can still be wrought, though on a much grander scale than he had intended when he was slow-witted Samouēl. Thaddaeus receives an anonymous tip (from Samouēl) on the whereabouts of Hrodebert, sending Hrodebert into one of his Orc-rages that he had managed to suppress for so long. Samouēl then surrenders himself to Thaddaeus, claiming Hrodebert's mind has become unhinged from his transformations, and he threatened to kill Samouēl and his family unless Samouēl aided him. But, good news for Thaddaeus, Samouēl knows the secret to Hrodebert's experiment.

Before Samouēl betrayed Hrodebert, he got in touch with a pit fighter named Aemilius, whose grandfather was from one of the nations across the sea. On Samouēl's instructions, Aemilius offers his assistance to Thaddaeus, probably saying his family was killed in the Orc's recent rampage, and he wants revenge. Thaddaeus fast-tracks Aemilius to the front of the line to become one of his Orcs who work for the crown, and, with Samouēl's increased intellect, it works, even better than Hrodebert's original experiment, as Aemilius retains all of his intelligence, as opposed to Hrodebert.

Meanwhile, Hrodebert, with no other options, sought out Elisheva, who abandoned her father after Hrodebert's experiment, to work in an orphanage or some fantasy-world equivalent. He has always known where she was, but didn't want to seek her out until he could rid himself of the Orc. But he is desperate, and comes to her to help hide him. But the hiding doesn't last long, as Aemilius, no longer following Thaddaeus' orders, begins rampaging. He wants to be the strongest one there is, and Samouēl wants everyone in the world to suffer, in payment for his suffering. So, everyone is happy.

Hrodebert reluctantly comes out of hiding to stop Aemilius' rampage, but, thanks to a slow-to-act chemical Samouēl dosed him with before his last rampage, Hrodebert is unable to summon his Orc-self. That is, until Elisheva deliberately puts herself in danger, gambling that this will enrage Hrodebert enough to instigate the transformation. Aemilus taunts Hrodebert that, with his brains and brawn, he is the more powerful adversary, but eventually, Hrodebert out-rages Aemilius, defeating him, and leaving Thaddaeus with egg on his face in the process. Samouēl has managed to disappear in all the confusion, leaving Thaddaeus looking even more the fool when he tries to pin the blame on the former stable hand.

While the day is saved, Hrodebert still doesn't trust himself in the heart of the city, and reluctantly leaves Elisheva, knowing it is unlikely they will ever be reunited. Thaddaeus faces possible punishment for his part in the birth of the abomination that rampaged in the outer rim of the kingdom. He is visited by Niklaus, the Fury of the Crown, who gently encourages him to call off his hunt for Hrodebert. Hrodebert has saved the kingdom, and deserves a rest, or, if he does prove to be the threat Thaddaeus wanted to turn him into, Thaddaeus will need more than weapons to go against the Orc. He will need...a Shield.

That's it. I hope you all enjoyed this, and I may just come back next week for more in this series.

u/TheComixkid2099 — 26 days ago

An unexpected cameo in Red Sonja

The guy from Fire and Ice kills Sonja in an alternate reality where she is comically evil?

This is from a story where Sonja is forced to reflect on choices she has made in life. Then we get this issue, quite possibly one of the most sickeningly violent comics I have read. I think I have seen Garth Ennis exercise more restraint than this issue. Plus, if the point is for Sonja to think about what she has actually done, why show her a What If of what she never actually did?

Anyway, enjoy this panel with what I thought was a fun, unexpected cameo.

u/TheComixkid2099 — 1 month ago

Retelling the Marvel Cinematic Universe as an Epic Fantasy Series: The Man of Iron

Antonius of House Stark is a minor noble, a Duke or a Baron, whose family made their fortune a hundred times over with their ownership of the mines, and heavy involvement with the Smith's Guilds. While Antonius appears vapid and carries little responsibilities, he does have a good head for numbers, and his good-business sense has propelled his family's fortunes even higher since his parents died under mysterious circumstances seventeen years ago.

Helping Antonius run the business arrangements of House Stark is Ginevra, an adept of the Merchant's Guild. She is secretly in love with the lord of the house she has sworn fealty to, but knows it's not a good idea to get involved, with his casual philandering. Not to mention, it might not look good for the Lord of the House to be seen publicly fraternizing with someone of low birth, at least that's what she thinks.

Among Antonius' honored staff is Sir Ya'aqov of House Rhodes, a House that once rivaled House Stark in power, but fell out of favor generations ago. Sir Ya'aqov was fostered at the towers at Starkhold as a child, and is the closest thing Antonius has to a real friend. He is now Antonius' Captain of the Guard, though some may whisper that he hasn't earned his position.

And, there's Abdias Stane, brought into the Stark alliance before Antonius was born, when Antonius' father, Hávarðr, saved his life. Abdias does not come from a noble family, but was raised to his station by Hávarðr. He was trained in strategy and tactics and was a bonded servant of the Hydra, the eldritch cult of demonianists who warred with the loose confederation of kingdoms sixty-three years ago. Maybe Hávarðr was in a mercurial mood when he arranged for Abdias to be spared his appointment with the gallows, or maybe he had some way of knowing of the mental prowess of those trained in the strategic arts by the Hydra, and wanted someone like that on his side. [Think how the Great houses in the Dune universe have Mentats working for them.] Either way, for decades, Abdias served the same role Ginevra now serves, aiding Hávarðr and then Antonius with various deals to line the pockets of House Stark.

While Antonius shirks many of his responsibilities, one he does take serious is developing relationships with potential new clientele, which could make him and his all the wealthier. Ginevra and Ya'aqov both discourage Antonius from going to meet with representatives from The Institution of the Rings, a little-known guild across the sea. Spurious rumors suggest this alliance of merchants might have even dealt with the remnants of the Hydra, though Antonius doesn't take this seriously. As far as he's concerned, the Hydra is little more than a myth, even though it was still active in his father's lifetime.

Antonius is betrayed during his expedition. He is felled by a volley of Alchemical Firepots, which badly burn him, making it difficult for him to even breathe. Across the sea, House Stark is in chaos. Normally, in any other noble house, even so far from the throne, the heir to the house would set about fairly quickly in securing an heir, in case something like this happens. But Antonius, again, frivolous, not interested in doing what others want him to do. He's also been busy making his house richer, and trying to find a bride who isn't part of a nest of vipers who would want to drain the family's coffers wasn't high on his list of priorities. It's finally discovered the next heir to the seat of power is none other than Abdias, who was named heir after the many times he aided Hávarðr, at least before Antonius was born. While he was pushed to second in line to the House Seat, Antonius never officially rescinded his father's decree, and so Abdias now rules House Stark.

Across the sea, a scholar and dabbler in the mystic arts, Yīn Shèn, saves Antonius, though Antonius is bitter and wishes the old man hadn't bothered. Yīn Shèn would see the Institution of the Rings destroyed for the crimes they have perpetrated across this region. While Antonius seems ambivalent about what they do in this part of the world, when Yīn Shèn tells him they plan to move their operations across the sea, near Antonius' homeland, Antonius agrees to do whatever he can to stop them.

Yīn Shèn performs an alchemical incantation that binds Antonius with heavy armor plating, made from the same weaponry his family profited from for generations. He is now the weapon he once sold. The various runes Yīn Shèn carved into the armor will allow Antonius to use his own knowledge from when he was slumming it with the Smith's guild to add new weapons to his new exoskeleton, depending on the need of the mission.

When Antonius targets some of the operations of the Institution of the Rings, their representatives quickly find him and Yīn Shèn, who we discover was once a strategist for the Institution of the Rings, in the same way Abdias was for House Stark. After a miscalculation on Yīn Shèn's part, his family were left in a dangerous region that was targeted by weapons supplied by House Stark. Yīn Shèn fled, hoping to use Antonius for his own revenge. The Rings weren't planning any immediate actions across the sea, though Antonius does find out they were informed of Antonius' own schemes against them before his business meeting, alerting Antonius someone back home betrayed him. Yīn Shèn is executed, and the Institution of the Rings want to use Antonius for their own schemes, and also as insurance against, you guessed it, Abdias, who wanted Antonius out of the way. They think they can secure House Stark as a permanent ally they can keep in control if they keep Antonius alive, and threaten to parade him around if Abdias doesn't do what they want.

But, Antonius escapes and makes it back home, just as Abdias is about to inflame a war overseas, which will make House Stark even wealthier, as they will supply the weapons, and it will keep the Institution of the Rings busy enough that they won't be hassling him. Antonius reveals himself to Ya'aqov and Ginevra, and Ya'aqov will have to subtly see which soldiers are aligned with what Abdias is doing, and which will still follow Antonius when he reveals himself. This will put to rest any doubts about Ya'aqov's skills when he's able to kick some butt and take some names when everything hits the fan. When Antonius confronts Abdias, we find out, even when Hávarðr was still alive, Abdias always hated Hávarðr and his family. He had been trained and molded his entire life for one single purpose that was taken from him. And just as he became comfortable in his new role Hávarðr had provided for him, Abdias begins to feel like a third wheel, with Antonius and Ginevra running House Stark's business even better than he ever did.

Antonius offers Abdias a chance to flee, if Antonius never sees him again, he will forget the betrayal Abdias has visited on the family that treated him as one of their own. But Abdias is familiar with the same ancient arts Yīn Shèn used to save Antonius, and he constructs an armor similar to what Antonius now wears, and a fight commences. But, thanks to some trial and error from when Antonius was fighting the agents of the Rings across the sea, Antonius is aware of a bad combination of the runes, and Abdias is hoisted by his own petard. All the while, Captain Ya'aqov was able to race out and convince the General leading the forces to withdraw, while Ginevra convinces the Banking Guild to freeze the accounts of House Stark, until an investigation could be performed on the legality of Abdias' fanning the flames of war.

Antonius swears things will change with House Stark's relationship with the rest of the kingdom, and how they operate. He wants to use his wealth to fund education and the arts, even though he knows this will earn him some enemies among the more hawkish members of the governing families. But his change of heart will earn him new allies, as Ya'aqov and Ginevra's contacts are both secret agents of Niklaus, the Fury of the Crown, who knew Hávarðr Stark, long ago. Niklaus says, if Antonius is serious about using his connections and wealth to help protect the kingdom, he will be in touch, but he may call on Antonius for more direct assistance in the future.

(That's all I've got. I don't know if this will be something I will pursue much further, but I thought this would be a fun, weird What If? type situation. Hope you all enjoyed this one.)

u/TheComixkid2099 — 1 month ago

Fixing the opening of Goldfinger

Not the cold open, it's fine, no changes. (Although I find it more likely Bond could see an incoming enemy in the reflection of glasses rather than the babe's naked eye, but whatever.)

After Bond blows up an opium den, James apparently thinks his bosses have paid for him to vacation in Miami. American CIA agent ​Felix Leiter finds him and tells him he has a mission from his superiors, Auric Goldfinger. He's clean, as far as the CIA is concerned, at least, so Felix says.

So...what? Why is a CIA Agent giving orders for MI6? When the CIA apparently doesn't have a dog in this fight? I propose a small change. Instead of Felix looking for Bond, Bond accidentally happens upon Felix in the middle of an operation where he is watching Goldfinger. Either as thanks for Felix's help in Doctor No, or because he is getting antsy and wants some action, James inserts himself into the mission, and will later secure permission from M to continue helping. Maybe Felix got injured and Bond feels he can do what Felix was originally going to do.

All this really does is remove Dink (the girl massaging James), and the humorous (if macabre) ​bit where James has moved on to another girl who dies, and Felix thinks James is talking about Dink. It is an extremely nitpicky problem, but one that makes very little sense and could easily have been fixed. They could have even removed the cold open and extended the Miami scene where James meets Felix, and show Felix's injury

reddit.com
u/TheComixkid2099 — 2 months ago

Now is our moment, bring back The Stranger

>!I'm only half-joking. If you did something that is Doctor Who in everything but name, with a super low budget that forced writers to focus on clever writing over spectacle, I suspect a fair number of people would be all over that.!<

u/TheComixkid2099 — 2 months ago
▲ 519 r/doctorwho+1 crossposts

I think Susan should've had both Rogue's cameo in "Wish World" and 13's cameo in "The Reality War"

I know Susan technically did have a blink-and-you'll-miss-it cameo in "Wish World" (even if it was just reused footage from "The Interstellar Song Contest), and was supposed to appear at the end of "The Reality War" that sets up Poppy being her mother before it was reshot, but in my opinion, they should've had Susan replace both Rogue and 13's cameos in the finale.

While having Rogue reappear in "Wish World" was a nice callback (if sudden), I thought it would've made more sense for Susan to be the one who told 15 about the tables "not doing that", since the prior episode established her trying to contact her grandfather, and wouldn't have felt out of place as Rogue's return was.

And while I loved 13's cameo in "The Reality War", I really think it would've been great if Susan was the one who helped 15 with shifting the timeline to save Poppy. For one, it finally would've showed 15 reunite with Susan after this era kept hinting at it, only to drop it due to the reshoots. 15 and Susan could've even had a nice moment where 15 promises to Susan that he'll find her after regenerating, and Susan says she'll be waiting, before they say their goodbyes. They could even still hint at Poppy still being Susan's mother if they wanted to (but I highly doubt it).

Either way, I really hope the 2026 Christmas special finally brings back Susan properly like this era was hinting at.

What do you think? Please try and be civil though.

u/ImWearingSandshoes — 3 months ago

Mr Tardis fixes Doctor Who Season 2 by making Belinda a single mother from the beginning, combining Conrad Clark and Alan Budd, and removing the Rani, (among many other things)

youtube.com
u/TheComixkid2099 — 3 months ago

I read Cult of the Obsidian Moon a few months ago, and I just started Songs of the Slain. What are everyone's opinions on the best from the recent releases from Titan Books? I guess this depends on what you want from a Conan story, more combat, or quiet thievery, or how overt you want the sorcery in the Sword & Sorcery to be.

reddit.com
u/TheComixkid2099 — 4 months ago