CMV: Asking Reddit for Relationship Advice is like drinking poison expecting it to hydrate you.
CMV: Reddit is one of the worst places to ask for relationship advice.
Not because people on Reddit are evil, unintelligent, or incapable of empathy. But because the structure of Reddit itself makes objective, balanced relationship advice almost impossible.
Most relationship posts are:
- written in moments of emotional intensity,
- heavily one-sided,
- missing years of context,
- and filtered through the poster’s own biases.
Then thousands of strangers project their own experiences, traumas, insecurities, values, and unresolved resentment onto the situation.
As a result, the advice often becomes:
- “break up,”
- “they’re manipulating you,”
- “this is abuse,”
- “they’re cheating,”
- “you deserve better,”
- or armchair diagnoses from people who know neither person involved.
And the scary part is: sometimes those comments are technically understandable from the information provided. But the information provided is almost never enough to make life-altering decisions with confidence.
I also think Reddit fundamentally misunderstands what long-term relationships actually look like.
If you read enough threads, you start to believe that:
- occasional boredom means the relationship is dead,
- attraction fluctuating means you’ve “fallen out of love,”
- conflict means incompatibility,
- doubts mean you should leave,
- routine means you’re settling,
- and emotional distance during stressful periods means the relationship is doomed.
But almost every long-term couple experiences some version of these things at some point.
Relationships are not static emotional highs. People change. Desire fluctuates. Stress affects intimacy. Resentment builds and can sometimes be repaired. Communication gets worse and then improves again. That’s normal.
Reddit often treats normal relational struggles and truly irreparable relationships as if they’re the same thing.
I think people are far better off:
- speaking to a therapist,
- talking to emotionally mature friends who have no stake in the outcome,
- or having difficult direct conversations with their partner.
And honestly, I’m even cautious about relying too heavily on parents or family for relationship advice, because they usually cannot be fully objective either. They love you first. If your partner hurts you, even temporarily, your family may carry that resentment long after you’ve moved on from it.
A therapist is not automatically “right,” either. But at least therapy is structured around nuance, patterns, accountability, communication, and context — not farming engagement through outrage and certainty.
To be clear: Reddit can absolutely help people recognize genuinely abusive situations, manipulation, coercion, chronic disrespect, or toxic dynamics they’ve normalized. It can also make people feel less alone.
But I think Reddit is much better at validating feelings than evaluating relationships.
CMV.