Trouble trusting new nanny’s judgment
I have a toddler and a newborn. We have had an exceptional Nanny for the past 2+ years. She is highly communicative, trustworthy, always on time, and takes incredible care of the kids. She genuinely cares about being helpful and making sure that the kids are happy. We love her. Unfortunately she is only willing to do about 15 hours per week for us, which was OK with just one kid, but now with a newborn, we need more help. I work for myself right now and intend to find a job that requires closer to full-time childcare starting this fall. For months I have been trying to find a second part-time nanny to supplement her, but I have not had any luck. We’ve hired a number of people who haven’t worked out or have bailed on us. I think the reduced number of hours made it difficult to find a quality fit.
After 6+ months of searching for a second part-time Nanny so we could keep our original Nanny, we decided to pivot and found someone who could do 30+ hours per week which is what we will need. We found someone who lives nearby and is in her low 60s. She checks all of our boxes and in theory is a perfect match, however she is either scatterbrained or has very different judgment than we do which is causing me to be doubtful and wonder whether she will be the right match for us. She’s been doing training with us a few days a week for the past three weeks.
Here are a few examples of what I mean:
- doesn’t reliably use turn signals (and will be responsible for driving my kids - I asked her to use them while she was driving them, but I obviously won’t be there to monitor whether or not this happens)
- is forgetful or not paying attention about basic things around the house. She will put two mattress protectors on top of my newborn‘s crib instead of one mattress protector and one sheet. She will empty the dishwasher and put two pots away in the right spot, and another pot in a completely different cabinet.
- she left my dog outside when she took my son to the playground. She did text me to let me know that the dog was outside, but she shouldn’t have left the dog outside alone to begin with…
So, I’m torn. She is always early, communicative, proactive, enjoyable to talk to, and seems good with the kids. While the little examples I gave are insignificant on their own, the inability to follow directions (or at least ask questions if she’s not sure about something) creates insecurity and a lack of confidence in her ability to do more important things correctly. Obviously it takes time to build trust with a new childcare provider but I’m struggling to understand whether or not the issues I’ve seen are just a lack of judgment, which could be a common issue with her, or if there’s just a bigger learning curve and maybe we can improve this over time. I hate to pay someone that I’ve done a few weeks of training with and don’t feel confident about. I could continue my search, but I do see hope in her. Anyone have any thoughts?