lowkey got serious issues with susie’s “character arc”
okay i’m aware that susie changed so drastically between chapters 1 and 2 because she “let go of the tough girl facade!!” but there is a HUGE difference between a character putting up a front for the sake of self preservation versus actively showing the audience that you kind of enjoy reaping the benefits of being an asshole to others — not saying these two can’t be intertwined or that susie doesn’t know when to NOT go too far — but what she does in chapter 1 is a little too over the top for her to be doing it purely for the sake of a facade:
and this isn’t BAD writing obviously — it’s not bad writing to have a character do morally wrong things — but holy shiiittttt the difference between ch1 susie and ch2 susie is so jarring that sometimes they feel like completely different characters to me. it’s like the story isn’t even trying to do straightforward character development either — it’s like it’s trying to convince you that susie “was actually a good person underneath the front!” (even though her behaviors in chapter 1 tell a slightly different story) and it almost kind of gaslights you into believing that ALL of the shitty stuff she did was purely for the sake of self preservation and that she was never a truly morally grey person in the first place?? like yes i know you aren’t actually evil and it was wrong to bully kris regardless but you literally boasted about making them do your half of the project like bitch you did NOT have to do all of that 😭😭😭
and even if this is purely a facade problem (disregarding the “how” and “why” aspects of her character) it is still super incredibly jarring! oh my god! like at least spread it out across like… 3 chapters. that would have been okay. she definitely developed in chapter 1 but noottttt in a reasonable enough timespan to get to where she apparently was in chapter 2.
also the way suselle is set up is incredibly melodramatic and stupid to me and doesn’t really make sense… there were not enough hints whatsoever before chapter 5 that susie was into her too and it feels a little far fetched to believe she’s into her to the EXTENT that she is in chapter 5 given previous events. like she plays guitar at her house and whatever, but the FIRRRST thing she says to kris after they get kicked out is “damn we didn’t get the shelter code!” when this happened i was like “wow i guess susie really isn’t into noelle then! she doesn’t gaf a lot about what just happened apparently…” idk it just feels out of nowhere given the way she acts around her entire chapter 5. okay. thank you for coming to my ted talk.