Pies vs stews, porridge, and bread
I'm coming up on my first winter in my first ever playthrough (yay!) and, while I think I should have enough food stocked up to last all the way through, I've started to wonder about the math behind satiety and the most effective way to use ingredients...
Some of the information is from my own testing and some is from the wiki pages on bread, pies, and cooking. If anything is inaccurate, please let me know and I'll come back later and edit the post to reflect the better information!
So, as far as I can tell, when it comes to grains, we have the following calculations:
- Raw rye grain: 60 satiety
- Cooked rye bread: 300 satiety
- One piece of rye in a rye porridge: 240 satiety (+1 minute of frozen hunger)
- One piece of rye in a pie crust: 240 satiety
When it comes to other ingredients, information is a lot more sparse:
- Most fruits and vegetables gain 1.5x satiety from being cooked in a stew or porridge compared to being eaten raw (and don't forget that, again, stews and porridges freeze your hunger bar for 30 seconds for every 100 satiety they provide)
- I could not find this on the wiki, but as far as I can tell, pies give the same exact 1.5x modifier to cooked fruits and veggies (but pies do not freeze the hunger bar)
- Meat seems to give the same amount of satiety (e.g., 420 for red meat) in stews and pies
What about shelf life then? And how much you can take on adventures?
- Cooked rye bread: 8-day shelf life, stacks to 32, for 9,600 satiety
- Burnt rye bread: 17-day shelf life, stacks to 48, for 10,080 satiety
- Cooked meat pie slices: 8-day shelf life, stacks to 32, for 26,880 satiety
- Charred meat pie slices: 12-day shelf life, stacks to 32, for 20,160 satiety
- Cooked meat pie (not sliced): 8-day shelf life, stacks to 32, for 107,520 satiety, but you also need to bring
a table anda knife, so35,84053,760 satiety per slot - Cooked meat pie (not sliced): 12-day shelf life, stacks to 32, for 80,640 satiety, but you also need to bring
a table anda knife, so26,88040,320 satiety per slot - Hefty meat stew in sealed crock: 50(?)-day shelf life, 4 servings, for 6,720 satiety, but you also need to bring a bowl, so 3,360 satiety per slot
- Hefty meat stew in cooking pot: 5(?)-day shelf life, 6 servings, for 10,080 satiety, but you also need to bring a bowl, so 5,040 satiety per slot
So I think that my conclusion is that stews and porridges are the best food to eat at home. You can seal them in crocks and they will easily last over a year, plus space at home is not limited. And for adventures, I think I'll mostly use bread. But maybe pies/burnt pies if I think I'll be running the whole time or otherwise burning through loads of food (or for multiplayer -- if you have more than one person to keep fed!).
Anyhow, what do you guys think -- is this correct?
Also, again, I'm very new to Vintage Story and the information I'm working with is a little limited, so please let me know if anything is inaccurate, and I'll update the post!
EDITS:
- You don't need to put pies on a table to cut them - just do it in the crafting area with a knife!
- The mechanic where hunger is stopped is complicated and may soon be getting a rework. It might be shorter (e.g., based only on the main ingredient, not the full meal). Take any considerations of it with a block of halite.