
How maps harden territorial claims. Dashed or not, the line has barely moved since.
On 20 July, eight days after the 10th anniversary of the arbitral award in the Philippines’ case against China, Philippine and Chinese personnel clashed near Second Thomas Shoal (Opens in new window) in the South China Sea. Manila said Chinese coast guard personnel struck a Filipino sailor near the grounded BRP Sierra Madre, which it considers a lawful outpost. Beijing said Philippine boats rammed its patrol craft and attacked Chinese personnel within Chinese territory.
A map can specify where the encounter took place, but it can cast one side as the lawful occupant and the other as the intruder.
Maps can appear to be neutral or objective reference material. Some maps mark overlapping claims or disputed territory. Others reproduce one government’s position without qualification. Borders, labels, and colours can make a government’s claim to authority look like a geographic fact. Each map reflects choices about what to include and how much uncertainty to display.
For much of history, governments exercised authority over towns, ports, and routes while their reach weakened across vast stretches of land and water. As governments sought to exercise authority such as by collecting revenue or building military fortifications, they needed clearer ways to show where their control ended and another government’s began. This need for administrative clarity encouraged more standardised ways of depicting space. Early modern maps increasingly supplied that picture (Opens in new window), representing political authority as bounded territory separated by lines. The image was cleaner than the reality: claims overlapped, frontiers remained porous, and physical control often faded well before the edge of the territory shown on paper.
>
That representation could also move ahead of conditions on the ground. Colonial governments drew boundaries around places where their presence remained thin or contested. A claim incomplete in practice could appear complete on paper, giving officials a territorial framework they could later seek to enforce.
Full Article: https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/how-maps-harden-territorial-claims