What would the wish for?
I've been thinking about it and here's what I think some people would wish for (feel free to add on different people or change what some may wish for)
Scott: to be either eternal in the theater somehow, or to live with legs' character.
Sausage: for his brother to be happy and safe.
Legs: just to be alive again
Shelby: not to have been struck by lightning
Nobody: to be reunited with his family or to hunt with Artemis
These are just a few ideas I had feel free to add on or give your own thoughts