Login

u/scoutlineuk

r/websitefeedback r/SideHustleGold r/sweatystartups r/EmailOutreach r/webdesign r/ukstartups r/alphaandbetausers r/SideProject r/betatests
▲ 2 r/EmailOutreach

UK PECR and “my software sent it automatically” — a warning for anyone using an autonomous outreach tool

There’s a category of tool going around that finds businesses without websites, builds them a site, publishes it, and emails the owner — the whole loop, unsupervised. The marketing line is usually some version of “you’ve spent zero hours doing any of it.”

If you’re in the UK, two things about that are worth knowing before you buy one.

1. You are the sender. PECR liability sits with the person on whose behalf the email goes out, not the vendor. Automation isn’t a defence, and “I didn’t know what it sent” is worse than useless as one — it means you can’t evidence compliance either. Corporate subscribers get somewhat lighter treatment than individual ones, but sole traders and unincorporated partnerships are treated as individual subscribers, and that’s most of the trades these tools target. Getting that wrong at volume is exactly the fact pattern the ICO looks at.

2. Where did the photos come from? Several of these build the site from images scraped off the business’s own listing or social page. Those photographs belong to someone. Republishing them on a page you then try to sell is a copyright exposure, and it’s yours, not the vendor’s.

Then there’s the failure mode nobody markets: a site built from scraped data with nothing stopping the model inventing will confidently state services, hours or credentials that business doesn’t have. You’ve now sent a stranger a page that’s wrong about their own business, and you’re the one who sent it.

None of this makes cold outreach to businesses illegal. It’s legal and it works. But identify yourself, give a real address, honour opt-outs immediately, keep a record, and read what goes out before it goes out. The unsupervised version isn’t a shortcut, it’s a transfer of liability to you.

ICO’s direct marketing guidance covers all of it and it’s more readable than you’d expect.

reddit.com
u/scoutlineuk — 6 days ago
▲ 5 r/websitefeedback+5 crossposts

I built a tool that finds local businesses with no website and builds them one. Two people have ever paid for it.

Posting this while it’s still small, because everything I read in this space is written after the fact by someone with a number to show off.

What it does: scans an area, scores every business on how likely they are to actually buy (review count, rating, whether they have a Facebook page or nothing at all), then generates a real one-page preview site for the ones worth pitching. The idea is that you send someone their site rather than asking whether they want one.

Where it actually is: two previews have ever been billed. No reviews, no case studies, no named customer. The lead scoring works and there’s a real scan behind it — 34 businesses in Dundee, 29 with no website — but I’m not going to pretend that’s traction.

The design decision I’d most like feedback on, because it’s the one costing me sales: it doesn’t send the emails. It drafts them and stops. There’s no send button anywhere in the product.

That’s deliberate. Under UK PECR the sender of a cold email is liable, and “my software sent it automatically” isn’t a defence. Products in this space that auto-send are handing that liability to their customer without saying so. Same reason it never uploads the business’s own photos to build the site — republishing someone’s photographs on a page you’re about to sell is a copyright problem you’d inherit.

Both refusals make it a harder sell than “fully automated, zero hours.” I still think they’re right. Open to being told I’m wrong.

The other constraint, which is the actual point of the thing: the generator can’t invent facts about a business. If it doesn’t know your opening hours, it flags a placeholder rather than making them up. Getting a model to consistently say “I don’t know” instead of writing something plausible was harder than the entire rest of the build.

There’s a free scan on the homepage if you want to see the finding half work on your own town — no account, no email. scoutline.uk

Genuinely more interested in whether the draft-only decision is defensible than in signups.

u/scoutlineuk — 4 hours ago