Posting a game and asking for feedback: a brief request l

If you are posting a game and asking for feedback, it needs to be playable.

It doesn't need to be fully finished. It doesn't need to be bug-free.

But there shouldn't be game breaking bugs within seconds of starting the game.

There shouldn't be missing collision in the starting area, causing the player to fall through the floor.

The player shouldn't lose immediately because an obstacle was placed right in front of their spawn.

Developers need to check their work before they post.

Seriously, some games come out so broken I wonder if the developer ever tried to play them before posting to every game development subreddit they can find.

reddit.com
u/senshisun — 7 days ago

They were annoyed I prepared for the job they posted...

The posting said a small career college was looking for a receptionist. They want an in-person interview. We arrange a time to meet. I do research on the company to prepare, as usual.

Then, at the interview, I'm told that they're actually hiring for a parent company, and I could be placed anywhere. I'm instructed to stop tailoring my answers to any type of company. The interviewer seemed annoyed she had to explain this.

I had no idea there was a parent company. There is nothing about this in previous communications. The parent company's name never appears on email signatures, on their website, or social media pages.

The parent company's name was on a banner in the office, but the college's name wasn't anywhere in the office. I thought I had the wrong address.

But I'm unprofessional for not preparing for a job I didn't know existed?

The job they offered is the exact same role, a receptionist. It would be full time during standard business hours.

Would this be a real job?

reddit.com
u/senshisun — 1 month ago

Those who MADE a game with a group of random people, what kept you motivated?

There are plenty of posts looking for people to help make a game. I'm curious, for those of you who made a game with a group of people, what kept you motivated through the process?

And if the game didn't ship, what happened?

reddit.com
u/senshisun — 1 month ago

I sent my novel to my dream publisher!

Ever since I was little I wanted to be published. Today, I put my final touch on my brand new totally original novel, John Spooker's House of Incredibly Haunted Dolls, and I sent it to my favourite publisher.

Ghosts Aren't Real Press is bound to love this! Sure, they mostly publish non-fiction. Their other works are academic. And they haven't published anything since 1980, but they'll publish my book immediately.

reddit.com
u/senshisun — 2 months ago

Searching for a team, but have no experience in making games? Read this, please.

One of the most common types of posts we get are from very enthusiastic people who have a game idea, and are searching for a full team to bring that game idea to reality. Many of those people don't have experience making games. Many of them are kids.

It is extremely difficult to make a game in this state.

First, somebody who doesn't know anything about game development won't know when they're being scammed or tricked.

Second, they're unlikely to know what's realistic or possible.

Third, people who want to work on projects need some degree of confidence that you know what you're doing.

If you've never made a game before, try making a simple one. A really simple one. Pick an engine that can handle the kinds of projects you want to make and follow tutorials. It doesn't need to go online. It doesn't need to be perfect. All it needs to do is function.

Then, make a couple more.

Can't code? Plenty of engines have no-coding options.

Can't do art? Make bad art, or use free resources such as itch.io

Can't do sound or music? Use free resources.

These exercises are meant for you to get experience with development. You'll also be able to describe what you need.

Some more general advice:

You won't be making an MMO. These require large teams, years of time, and heaps of money. It's not going to happen.

Professionals want to be paid for their work.

Game jams are great places to meet new people and create games as a group.

You've got this!

reddit.com
u/senshisun — 2 months ago

What's the best strategy for "porting" half of my existing code?

I want to expand a project I already published. My plan is to keep individual scene/level mechanics the same, but fully overhaul how moving between those scenes works. What's the most practical way to do that without breaking the code? Is it better to duplicate the whole game or export just the code I want to keep?

I'd appreciate any other scene management/large project management tips.

Thanks in advance!

reddit.com
u/senshisun — 2 months ago
▲ 52 r/magicthecirclejerking+1 crossposts

Which cards are these?

These cards are extracted from the corner of a photo of a play mat. The original image was at an angle, and correcting that warped the cards. I'm trying to verify if the cards are real, but I can't read the text.

Thanks for the help!

u/Kakariko_crackhouse — 2 months ago

Is this colouring book AI or a rushed human job? Colouring book has open-ended lines and repeated posing.

This colouring book is published by Scholastic, a large publisher of children's books. There's no artist name on the cover. They do credit a designer. The designer's portfolio doesn't show anything with this exact style or proportions. There are enough close ones that it seems like they could do it, though their portfolio quality is much higher.

These art pieces are the cover and interior preview pages.

Many have shapes that don't fully close, which feels off for a children's colouring book. Sometimes there are extra lines. Line weights vary widely, especially with the music notes on the Suzie page. The clarinet on the braid girl's page is missing a mouthpiece. Perspective goes wonky.

Why it might not be AI: Some art appears to be copied from page to page. The drawing of the singer with braids is reused three times. I don't think AI can clone like that. The individual character designs are consistent. A similar line weight issue might occur if these pieces were drawn on paper, scanned, and cleaned up improperly.

u/senshisun — 2 months ago

Second screen viewing for books?

Nobody has the time to read a whole book anymore. How else are we supposed to catch up on the hottest fruit family videos? I've got to make my book perfect for second screen viewing, but because I'm always looking at my screen while writing, I can't get into the mindset. How do I make my book more second screen?

reddit.com
u/senshisun — 2 months ago

How do puzzle game creators figure out difficulty scaling?

I've been noodling with a puzzle game project that uses many distinct puzzles, much like Professor Layton or those "brain teaser" mobile games. One of the things stopping me from committing is that I have no idea how to tell how difficult the puzzles are.

I know the answers because I'm putting them together. So I can't tell which ones are easier.

Any ideas?

reddit.com
u/senshisun — 2 months ago

Do these images have a yellow tint because they're AI or because they're inspired by the famously yellow Backrooms?

These are supposedly different versions of key art for the same game, which have been edited. They're both video thumbnails from third party streamers. They both have weird proportions, but it looks stylized. Can't count the teeth because we're dealing with the fey.

It seems like the game is human.

u/senshisun — 3 months ago

Are the other books in the Good Night, Our World series better?

I read Good Night, Canada (David J. Adams, Adam Gilbert) the other day. I didn't like it. The phrasing was clunky. There was no real sense of rhythm. Some sentences were much longer than others.

The subject matter choices felt unbalanced. Canada has ten provinces and three territories, so in a 26 page book, you could fit something from every part of the country. Instead, Toronto gets multiple mentions while the prairies get a page.

Are the other books in this series better?

u/senshisun — 3 months ago

Comics change between different predictable styles, and I swear I've seen these punchlines before

I don't know why someone would switch between stippling, lines, and no shading as seen here. The second one looks like it's drawn by a completely different person. Bushes and trees are overly detailed. Different fonts are also used.

I swear I have seen these punchlines before.

u/senshisun — 3 months ago

Somebody asked for homemade pic pong!

Please enjoy "Dish Cheating on Spoon with Fork" and "Happy Melting Popsicle"

I hope someone with actual art skills tries this.

u/senshisun — 3 months ago