Redeeming AA miles on Flagship transcon wasteful or reasonable?

I'm not sure if it's a skill issue or not, but I'm finding it increasingly harder and harder to redeem AA miles on partners, especially to Asia. JAL awards are transient and often phantom, BA awards are terrible given the surcharges, Qantas awards are increasingly rare now, CX J/F availability is blocked out, there's still sweet spots to be had, but a lot of the time, it's accessible with other partners too.

Ironically, my best AA flights have all come from Alaska redemptions like 45k Alaska miles from East Coast to LHR.

I know AA's Flagship offering isn't strictly the best, but I find reasonable availability on them for business as low as 35k, F around 50k. Sometimes 10kish or so higher, but still reasonable, given Flagship flights are priced around $1.5k to 2k each way, they seem like decent usages of them.

Given I fly transcon a lot, my burndown plan on AA is just to use most of my AA miles on JFK to LAX/SFO transcons whenever there's availability at a cheaper price, rather than hunting for JAL sweet spots and other stuff.

reddit.com
u/srekai — 15 hours ago

Looks like LAX and SFO to BOS are switching to all lie-flat 757s in October, seems like a great candidate for becoming a Polaris route with the new A321neo Coastliners?

I know they've done SFO to BOS in the past, but it wasn't very consistent, and wasn't always on all frequencies either. I'm not sure I've ever seen LAX to BOS on anything other than domestic F as well.

From what I can see now, it's on every single frequency, not just a few. And schedule-wise, it starts from October 25th and goes all the way to calendar open in May 2027. I wonder if United saw that a lot of people are booking away to JetBlue Mint on SFO to BOS because of the partnership, so they need to keep up with the hard product.

LAX to BOS also makes a lot of sense since it competes w/ Delta One, AA Flagship, and JetBlue Mint, so this will be much more competitive. Regardless, a really great sign since those transcon flights to BOS can be over 6 hours long.

I suspect these will be the next set of routes targeted for the Coastliners after EWR to SFO/LAX get them.

u/srekai — 3 days ago

AA Flagship comparison on JFK to SFO use a SWU vs AA miles

I'm comparing three options right now:

  • $200 economy flight + a SWU for confirmable Flagship Business space
  • 40k miles for Flagship Business
  • 52.5k miles for Flagship First

I'm gravitating towards the SWU because that expires, but they all seem like very reasonable prices to be honest.

reddit.com
u/srekai — 5 days ago

JFK to Tokyo: worth repo logistics for ANA F over Cathay J?

Comparing two itineraries, while I know F is clearly better than J, there are some reasons why I'm not immediately set yet

  • ANA itinerary
    • JFK to SFO for repo
      • $230 for economy (option to use SWU to upgrade to AA business)
      • $500 or 25k Hyatt points for overnight at SFO
    • SFO to NRT on ANA F for 110k Aeroplan miles
  • Cathay itinerary
    • JFK to HKG to HND for a total of 119k Asia miles

Overall, Cathay seems like slightly less friction of an itinerary, but ANA F is markedly better. Fwiw though, I've flown ANA F a lot, so the novelty factor is lower.

reddit.com
u/srekai — 6 days ago

Thoughts on JAL Mileage Bank for Air France awards?

42k to fly from East Coast to Paris in Business Class with $5.60 in taxes/fees. Seems like basically the lowest possible option out there, Etihad is 80k + $236 in fees, Delta/Flying Blue are dynamically priced right now. Virgin isn't seeing space for whatever reason.

Even though JAL miles are great for JAL awards, this seems hard to beat? Only concern is burning Bilt points for JAL miles, which are scarce.

reddit.com
u/srekai — 7 days ago

Anyone else move to NYC and get shocked by how it's literally a third world country?

u/srekai — 10 days ago

LHR to JFK comparison: VS on miles vs AA with SWU vs AA with paid upgrade

This is a weird one because I think they're all reasonable deals tbh.

Would you rather take VS on 35k miles+ $700ish in fees on A350-1000 in Upper Class.

AA for $698 cash then I have a confirmed SWU space with an extra $180 in taxes/fees or $712 cash upgrade on their new Flagship 789.

I also have OWE status for T3 lounges.

Honestly, I'm not sure all seem to be pretty comparable.

reddit.com
u/srekai — 12 days ago

What do people mean when they talk about "making it" in NYC?

I see this commented all the time or talked about in videos. But I have no idea what that actually means concretely

Like are people not just existing regularly day to day, doing their jobs, living their lives. Of course everyone is working hard, people have jobs and bills to pay. I know many people that live the exact same life, doing the exact same jobs before and after they move to or from NYC.

What is this abstract "making it" mean? As opposed to "not making it".

Are people talking about performing well in their careers, networking, and moving up the ladder? If so, how is that unique to NYC?

Are people just talking about surviving and saving money due to the extremely high cost of NYC?

reddit.com
u/srekai — 14 days ago

I'm going to miss flying Alaska, y'all really do have it good here on the West Coast

I've spent a good chunk of my adult life living here, while I wasn't ever the most frequent Alaska flyer (only ever hit Gold status), but I've pretty much only ever had great experiences with Alaska. It's been fun to see them do their transformation into becoming a global airline.

In my last bit of time here, I'm getting sentimental, it feels silly to be reminiscing about an airline, but Alaska has been great, truly.

I still remember my first flight ever with Alaska, which was ironically supposed to be a Delta flight, which got delayed to the point where I would miss my connection, so I ended up getting rebooked on Alaska to make it home for the holidays. That flight was where I had my first ever Alaska fruit and cheese plate.

I find that the travelers here, regardless of if it's in California, PNW, or wherever, are just that much more pleasant and polite. It generally makes for a calmer and more orderly travel experience altogether.

I know the airports here catch some heat, but whether it's SFO, LAX, SEA, or PDX, I still find them to be quite nice. With a shoutout to SEA, there's nothing as beautiful as seeing Rainier, when you're on an airplane.

Plus y'all have real trains that actually take you to the airport instead of requiring an additional transfer shuttle or bus. In general, I do not look forward to being back on the East Coast with all the chaos, delays, and worse infrastructure.

Unfortunately, the level of service back on the East Coast just isn't there, flights that are longer than SEA to SFO like LGA to ATL, don't even have proper meal services.

Alaska may not be the flashiest or sexiest airline out there, but I feel like they still embody the vestiges of how great the American flying experience used to be back in the day. If I ever find myself traveling back to the West Coast, I'll be sure to find a way to fly Alaska.

u/srekai — 20 days ago

Does anyone have experience with these UES apartments? (The Easton and One Carnegie Hill)

I was looking at the website for Related Rentals and they seem to have nice units in UES and appear to be rent-stabilized.

I’m considering apartments at One Carnegie Hill and The Easton on the Upper East Side, and I’d love to hear from current or former residents.

  • The Easton, 205 E 92nd Street
  • One Carnegie Hill, 215 E 96th Street

I'm unable to tour them in-person since I'm relocating from the other side of the country, but I saw some mixed online reviews and wanted to see if anyone had firsthand experience.

  • Building noise: I saw some reviews note that The Easton can have a lot of neighbor/upstairs/hallway noise, which is concerning to me
  • Elevators: I've read both of these buildings can have elevator reliability issues.
  • Neighborhood: For One Carnegie Hill, how does the area feel day-to-day around the high 90s, in particular 96th and 2nd Ave? I've read this is very close to East Harlem.

Any details, especially from people who have lived there recently, would be super helpful. Thanks!

u/srekai — 1 month ago

United CEO on buying JetBlue: "The last thing I'm gonna do is buy a route network that loses money."

u/srekai — 1 month ago

Looking for neighborhood feedback: 50s Hell’s Kitchen vs Chelsea/Penn edge vs far-east East Village

I’m deciding between three unit that are roughly similar in cost, across these neighborhoods and would love feedback from personal experience.

  • Hell's Kitchen
    • How does this area actually feel day-to-day? I hear very polarizing things about Hell's Kitchen.
    • It'd be in the 50s, closer to 9th Ave, so not as far from transit as the rest of the neighborhood, but I guess I'm worried if that creates more day to day chaos.
  • Chelsea/Penn Station edge
    • I know Chelsea is a very nice neighborhood and does cost more, and advertise the unit as "Chelsea", but it's in the high 20s, closer to 7th Ave, so feels closer to the edge of Penn/Koreatown, so not really the core Chelsea experience.
  • East Village/Alphabet City edge
    • Basically on E 14th, which is a nice street, but all the way over to Ave C, which is the edge.
    • I wonder if this might be too far/disconnected from the rest of the city?
reddit.com
u/srekai — 2 months ago

I really hope Alaska considers flying to CTS with today's United announcement

United just announced they're doing a seasonal flight from SFO to CTS.

I posited this idea when Air Canada did it a few months ago. There was definitely some pushback, but to me, this shows that the US-Japan market is stronger than ever, especially for winter ski season.

CTS seems like the marriage of two things that people in the PNW love which is Japan and skiing. If Alaska joins the JAL joint venture, this would be an excellent addition and prove why it's beneficial for consumers because it would enable more connectivity.

reddit.com
u/srekai — 2 months ago

What do you consider to be Alaska's flagship routes for each hub?

Since Alaska is going all out into longhaul expansion, I thought it would be an interesting to discuss what are considered Alaska's "premier" routes. Traditionally speaking, other airlines have flown these like the classic JFK-LHR or JFK-LAX routes, but since Alaska is very West Coast focused, I wondered what would be the flagship routes for each hub, it might look a bit different, so I thought it would be a fun exercise, this is my initial take, would love to hear thoughts and different opinions.

  • SEA
    • This hub has a few because it's Alaska's largest hub and deserves more mentions
    • SEA to DCA, for domestic, this is AS 1/2 for a reason, flights are very full and fares are high
    • SEA to LHR, for international, Alaska purposefully gave it the AS 100/101 to mark such an critical route
    • Honorable mention for SEA to NRT, which marks Alaska's very first international longhaul flight
  • SFO
    • SFO to JFK, it's one of Alaska's top routes by revenue, almost at the 100M per year level. This one is definitely the undisputed king for JFK. It's a flight that even the behemoth of SFO, United Airlines, cannot fly.
  • LAX
    • LAX to HNL, this is the top 5 busiest domestic routes for LAX, and Alaska flies multiple widebodies on this flight all year long.
  • HNL
    • This hub also gets a few because it has quite an interesting network
    • HNL to JFK, for domestic, this is one of the longest domestic flights in the world, and was the longest one in the US, until BOS to HNL happened
    • HNL to HND, for international, this is a route with a lot of history and importance due to the connection between Japan and Hawaii, and at one point HA flew this 3x daily.
  • PDX
    • This one was very tough for me to decide. PDX acts as a reliever hub for SEA, so everything it does feels overshadowed by SEA.
    • PDX to OGG, I chose this one over HNL as HNL feels generic, and the fact that PDX can support up to 2x daily frequencies to OGG and make it to the top 10 list of busiest domestic flights feels impressive for a city the size of Portland.
  • ANC
    • ANC to SEA, this is one of the most vital air routes in the US, and in fact is the busiest domestic route in the US during some months of summer. It's a critical connection that unlocks a whole world of connectivity for Alaskans. There are nonstop flights departing every hour during the day, I count almost 19x Alaska frequencies a day at the peak.
  • SAN
    • SAN to DCA, Alaska is very proud of its DCA presence and gives them all very low numbers, this is AS 14/15, and Alaska is the only airline to fly SAN to DCA
    • I think another case could be made for SAN to JFK, but compared to the other airlines, Alaska is weaker.
u/srekai — 2 months ago

I guess this is the official name of the Alaska/American joint venture.

Alaska honestly doing more for American than the other way around these days.

Source

u/srekai — 2 months ago