My thoughts on the changes
I will first of all acknowledge that the information I had from my source at corporate was wrong. I’m truly thankful it was, and I wasn’t intending to mislead anyone with it. That was part of why I hesitated to share the specifics I’d heard.
My general thought is that we dodged what could have been much worse. Fire commission being unchanged from AA05- and having the ability to get back to current AA05 comp levels on auto without IPS- makes this survivable for most agents.
There being a variable component for life app count is also nice for agents who aren’t in markets where writing giant permanent policies is common. The minimum premium numbers for life in the current SMVC system meant you needed multiple years of high production even to see a payout. I’m thankful that was addressed.
As for the negative… health insurance and AIPP hurts. For us specifically, we have a disabled child who needs specialists. Group insurance was part of what made me choose the SF opportunity over opening independent. There isn’t a marketplace PPO in our state, and it doesn’t look like there’s a EPO that has his doctors in-network. I can imagine lots of other agents will soon discover how bad having no group option will really be. It isn’t even a money issue- it creates access issues.
AIPP represents $500k+ in lifetime income reduction for the average agent. It also eliminates the illusion that we have a way to monetize our equity in the book like independents can. That’s a big pill to swallow.
I do worry that crossing the rubicon on changing existing contracts like this means nothing is permanent going forward. The new contract adds language that clearly states pay schedules can be adjusted at any time with 30 days notice. Yes they could do that before, but intentionally adding that wording is concerning.
My last thought is that I think corporate misunderstands how most agents operate. Yes, some bleed their agency dry. But most are taking home what they must and investing heavily back into the business with the rest. Reducing agent pay is going to change agency staff and marketing budgets more than it changes agent profits. That will hurt the enterprise as a whole.