Can we finally agree that giving up the city to Rhaenyra ended up being pointless for Alicent.

Can we finally agree that giving up the city to Rhaenyra ended up being pointless for Alicent.

I remember when i said on S2 that Alicent's offering was DUMB and pointless, and S3 prove it. Alicent did not receive from Rhaenyra a guaraante that she was going to keep her word, so she was fooled.

Imagine giving up the city to Rhaenyra and agree with her that your sons must die for you to be "free" just to look like a clown by giving up the city and being a whole prisioner.

And now, Rhaenyra tells her "you have no place to demands" and Alicent is just there betraying her side again and again without an actual hope of being free. Rhaenyra has gone mad with the news of Aegon and Sunfyre, so i doubt she will let "Aegon's mom" go unless of course she sends her to kill Aegon as well.

Alicent clearly has lost any political knowledge because she is a whole dissapointment on S3

u/thinkersfyre — 14 days ago

The hypocrisy of people being suprised some fans like Aegon but have no problem with Daemon being a fan favorite.

Daemon it's one of the most popular characters on this show and you dont see fans saying "Why you like Daemon?" "Have people forgot what Daemon did?" But someone says they like Aegon and they be like "have people forgot what Aegon did" "how can you like him?"

I mean both characters have done bad things but only one it's held into a different standard which turn the situation into a hypocrisy

u/thinkersfyre — 26 days ago

Alicent and Otto didn't care to try on S2.

Aegon was so easy to manipulate that if Alicent or Otto wanted they could have come and tell him "We understand you, we love you, we support you and this is what you should do" then Aegon would be on his knees following their instructions.

Alicent and Otto thinking that screaming and hitting a person, who lacks of love, was going to follow their orders was dumb.Even if they're not honest, making Aegon think that you believe in him would have change a lot of things.

You have Margaery Tyrell who knew how to manipulate Joffrey and Tommen in different ways and she succed.

Manipulating a person who craves for love isn't hard to do, Otto and Alicent didn't even try and the showrunners trying it to frame it as "Aegon doesn't listen" is dumb.

u/thinkersfyre — 27 days ago

This season prove it how irrelevant Alicent has become to the plot.

Take out Alicent's scenes this season and the plot remains the same. The writers refused to make Alicent a pivotal character in the greens side and with that they basically took any relevancy she could have, now we have to see her doing irrelevant things for the sake of giving her screentime.

There's peoole who still going againts Rhaenyra, Rhaenyra still facing difficulties despite having the city and bloodshed still happening.

What was the point of her trying to escape 3 times and failling each time? what was the point of having the same conversation with Rhaenyra over again? Why she tried to kill Aemond when we know he wasn't going to die by her hand? Why it doesn't bother Alicent that became a kinslayer when there's a whole taboo on it in Westeros?

This season just prove us that Alicent just cares about herself...because why would you let your own grandaughter with people she doesn't know?

At this point, they could throw Alicent at the cells on S4 and let the rest of characters do their thing and the plot would keep moving forward.

u/thinkersfyre — 1 month ago

Something positive it is said about the greens. Average TB stan:

I'm laughing. How they know the greens were a mess but then claim the books are written by a TG enthusiastic.

Where do they get the greens are a mess if it is not in the books? 💀

u/thinkersfyre — 1 month ago

"Yeah Rhaenyra might tried to kill me but she can keep the crown"

"Yeah Rhaenyra might tried to kill me but she can keep the crown even though that means i must die for that to happen"

"Me joining this war to fight for my brother's claim? Nah"

"Me being worried that my mother,sister and niece are Rhaenyra's hostages? Naaaah"

"I'm just here to remind the audience that the hightowers are the problem because i'm also manipulated by an evil hightower☝️ look just like my mother was, see the parallels?"

u/thinkersfyre — 1 month ago

Ignoring that this happened after Aegon killed Rhaenyra so he did avenge his children and Helaena.

And he saves the title of queens to his mother and sister

"Rhaenyra was never a queen," the king declared, insisting that henceforth, in all chronicles and court records, his half sister be referred to only as "princess," the title of queen being reserved only for his mother Alicent and his late wife and sister Helaena, the "true queens."

u/thinkersfyre — 1 month ago

Why do think Lyonel didn't do something when he find out Harwin was having children with Rhaenyra?

During those years, Lyonel was already hand. It's quiet obvious he knew Harwin was having an affair with Rhaenyra specially after Jace and Luke being born and he did nothing, only after the issue was SO OBVIOUS and because Harwin made a whole spectacle.

So why Lyonel didn't send Harwin away the moment Jace or Luke was born? Why he remained silence all those years allowing Harwin to have 3 children with Rhaenyra Do you think there was some self- interests there?

u/thinkersfyre — 1 month ago

TGC about the "I'm aliveee" meme, new TG fans, his frienship with Ewan and Alicent poisoning Aemond 👀

u/thinkersfyre — 2 months ago

This was such a bad idea

Gwayne, son of Otto Hightower who used to be HAND, really believed he could negotiate with Daemon. He just ended up handing Corlys, the greens' hostage, to Daemon.

Like, Gwayne knows, or suppose to know, how Daemon is, there's no way at this point they still wanting to negotiate something when they took Tumbleton.

Such a bad idea and for what? 😭 to humilliate him

u/thinkersfyre — 2 months ago
▲ 1.9k r/HouseOfTheDragon+1 crossposts

TGC taking about the "I'm aliveee" scene.

The slap was not in the script, again, thank you TGC 🫶 it made the scene better.

u/thinkersfyre — 2 months ago

Reducing women to their wombs.

Weird to me how fans reduce characters, who were vocally about not just wanting to be baby machines, to their wombs.

u/thinkersfyre — 2 months ago

The dance of dragons doesn't make so much sense.

The dance of dragons is based on The Anarchy.

Matilda is made heir after her brother dies, her cousin Stephen takes the throne and then war follows.

Matilda being heir and remaining as such,as the only child of the king, made sense. In the dance of dragons, the war happens between the eldest son and daughter of the king, and if you want it to be realistic as possible then it shouldnt be between siblings.

It should be between Rhaenyra and Laenor( a cousin) or Rhaenyra and Daemon( an uncle) or make Aegon and his siblings, cousins of Rhaenyra.

I dont know why GRRM decided to make it between siblings perhaps he wanted to give both valids claims but in a medieval setting Rhaenyra remaining heir with brothers wouldn't make sense.

reddit.com
u/thinkersfyre — 2 months ago

Did he forget that as long as he's a bastard he has no claim for Driftmark?

Sometimes it bothers me how little HOTD cares about the lore in ASOIAF because Alyn calling himself the future Lord of the Tides while he still a bastard it's quiet silly.

Yes, Corlys said he has wishes of making Alyn his heir BUT as long as Alyn remains a bastard he can't legally claim Driftmark. Alyn saying to Corlys' vassals that he's the heir will still being a bastard should realistically make those lords laugh.

But anyways... HOTD doesn't care about making this world be realistically coherent to it's lore.

u/thinkersfyre — 2 months ago