Party from a month ago asked for part of the tip back.
We had a large party a month ago. Blocked off part of the restaurant, food and liquor packages, a couple separate servers, etc. You know the drill. Parties include an auto-grat that's listed as a service fee. They left an additional tip when they signed the final bill at the end of the event. I was not present during that signing.
Today a party member said they didn't realize there was an auto-grat and asked management for the extra tip back. The restaurant presumably complied because management told me to acknowledge the portion of the extra tip I was paid would be taken out of my next check.
Have you ever encountered this? Does my restaurant have to reimburse taxes they initially charged me for that income?