r/CriticalThinkingIndia

The BJP nominated the Ram Mandir committee, filled with BJP-VHP leaders. Committee members hired their own relatives for jobs, from cash counting, security to SBI staff. Their MLAs sold land to Mandir Trust for 12 times the original price.

A state-appointed Special Investigation Team (SIT) is actively investigating a major embezzlement scandal involving cash, gold, and silver donations at the Ayodhya Ram Mandir. Authorities have arrested eight temple workers and contract employees, recovering approximately ₹80 lakh in cash.

The investigation and ongoing audit of the Shri Ram Janmabhoomi Teerth Kshetra Trust accounts have led to the following developments:

  • Modus Operandi: Police found that accused staff members siphoned off cash from the donation boxes by exploiting CCTV blind spots and avoiding monitoring in the designated counting rooms.
  • Trust Repercussions: The controversy has severely shaken devotees' trust and forced the resignation of the temple trust's general secretary, Champat Rai, and trustee Anil Mishra amid scrutiny over severe security lapses.
  • Political Row: Opposition figures have alleged that the true scale of the theft could exceed ₹200 crore, prompting the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP) to demand that the SIT question those leaders to verify the factual basis of their allegations.
  • Judicial Status: The Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court rejected a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) seeking a CBI probe, directing the matter through regular judicial channels.

Still people will believe Modi Government has done great job by building Ram Temple. It seems like they have fasten the process to do this donation theft.

u/SuperbHealth5023 — 1 hour ago
▲ 477 r/CriticalThinkingIndia+2 crossposts

Maharashtra: A major landslide occurred on the Missing Link section of the Mumbai–Pune Expressway near the Khandala Exit. Consequently, the Mumbai-bound lane has been completely closed.

Maharashtra: A major landslide occurred on the Missing Link section of the Mumbai–Pune Expressway near the Khandala Exit. Consequently, the Mumbai-bound lane has been completely closed.

According to preliminary information, no casualties have been reported. Efforts are underway to open the route.

₹6,695 crore Missing Link was promised to avoid landslide-prone Khandala ghat and it’s been barely 2months since inauguration and a landslide has already shut it. add to that pothole-like patches & stone-fall reports.

Heavy rain was expected, so was project designed as promised?

Sources:

https://x.com/ANI/status/2073952397957935140

This one is even more scary:

https://www.reddit.com/r/pune/comments/1uoo2e7/infrastructure_has_gone_to_the_dogs_in_india/

u/GroundbreakingBad183 — 8 hours ago

India has been ranked 125th out of 197 countries in the 2026 Global Passport Index (GPI), slipping one place from last year, according to the fifth edition of the report released by residency and citizenship advisory firm Global Citizen Solutions (GCS).

u/Krankenitrate — 6 hours ago
🔥 Hot ▲ 7.4k r/CriticalThinkingIndia+1 crossposts

One scam ends, another begins. Is this the new normal?

Every day seems to bring another story that raises uncomfortable questions about governance and accountability. This latest case is no different.

A 100 bed civil hospital in Indore reportedly existed on paper for six years, yet not a single brick was laid because of unresolved land acquisition issues(🤣).

Even more astonishing, 87 staff positions were filled and the employees were deployed to other healthcare facilities. While the government cites administrative hurdles, citizens deserve far more than explanations.

Public institutions cannot function on paperwork alone. Taxpayer money demands transparency, planning and responsibility.

Whether this reflects bureaucratic inefficiency, poor coordination, or administrative failure, a thorough and impartial investigation is essential.

Public trust is built through accountability, not excuses.

u/Oppyhead — 1 day ago

On the Topic of Reservation

Open to suggestions/questions/criticism(the constructive kind lol) on my approach to the system of reservation. Let's not make this a toxic post and encourage healthy discussion where people can pose their questions freely(Is sub pe critical thinking rarely dikhti and agenda peddling and insult slinging zyada so let's make it a worthwhile discussion).

For starters , **I am not against reservation** but I believe its **amount and nature(caste-based) forbids India from becoming a meritocratic nation and is directly sabotaging our nation's development**.Atleast, objective nature exams for jobs/college-entrance should have no caste-based reservations.

u/ThriveMidChaos — 20 hours ago
▲ 217 r/CriticalThinkingIndia+4 crossposts

Courage to Change

>Delivered during his 1929 trial, Bhagat Singh’s quote is a profound critique of human psychological conditioning. He noticed that people naturally crave comfort and routine, so they eventually get used to the way things are, even if the system is unfair or oppressive. The "established order" feels safer than the scary idea of the unknown. When he talks about a "lethargical spirit," he doesn't mean being physically lazy. He means being mentally asleep, just accepting a bad situation because you are afraid to disrupt what is familiar. To him, having a revolutionary spirit isn't about physical fighting. It is about having the mental courage to wake up, question a broken system, and push past the natural human fear of change.

u/pepoji — 22 hours ago

What heroic acts or substantial achievements does RSS have, that they’ve done for India?

[Serious]

Looking to know about their concrete achievements in RSS’ 100 years of existence.

What Wikipedia says:

During the colonial period, the RSS collaborated with the British Raj and played no role in the Indian independence movement.[9][21] After independence, it grew into an influential Hindu nationalist umbrella organisation, spawning several affiliated organisations that established numerous schools, charities, and clubs to spread its ideological beliefs.

But surely this can’t be all there is. There must be some concrete Achievements that helped India too right?

u/shubhamxtreme — 1 day ago

Asian countries move up the economic ladder..while India still stays put in the lower middle income category - WB.

The World Bank has moved Sri Lanka into the upper-middle-income category. Vietnam and the Philippines have also been upgraded, reflecting years of sustained economic expansion.

India is still in the lower middle income category, despite its high growth rate.

The distinction is less about the size of the economy and more about how income is distributed across a country's population.

In its latest income classification update, the World Bank described Sri Lanka as "a story of recovery."

Vietnam and the Philippines have also crossed the World Bank's threshold for upper-middle-income economies after years of steady growth. Vietnam's export-driven manufacturing sector has continued to attract global investment, while the Philippines has posted broad-based economic expansion across multiple industries.

With these upgrades, all five major Southeast Asian economies, including Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand, are now classified as upper-middle income or higher.

https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/india/sri-lanka-is-now-upper-middle-income-why-india-stays-put-despite-a-booming-economy-13965878.html

u/Debunk2025 — 1 day ago

The govt can’t keep both stories true: NITI Aayog warned against replacing E10, today E20 is supposedly fine ?? HOW ?

Source of doc: https://www.niti.gov.in/sites/default/files/2021-06/EthanolBlendingInIndia\\\_compressed.pdf

Government can’t stop lying.

Back in the 2021 NITI Aayog report on ethanol blending, SIAM (the Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers) explicitly warned that discontinuing E10 fuel would be a critical concern.

They wrote that using higher ethanol blends in existing E10 vehicles could lead to:
Material incompatibility, Fuel seepage/leakage, Safety issues, Poor drivability, Reduced fuel efficiency

They went as far as saying that E10 availability for existing vehicles/customers is a MUST and strongly recommended continuing to dispense E10 even after E20 rollout.

Fast forward to today, and we’re told that E20 is perfectly fine for older vehicles, including those built for E10, with nothing more than a slight drop in mileage.

So what changed?
Did years of engineering research overturn the concerns raised in the NITI Aayog report? If so, where is that evidence? Or was the original warning exaggerated?
Both positions cannot simultaneously be true without an explanation.

The least the government and the automobile industry owe vehicle owners is a transparent technical justification for why a blend once described as posing potential safety and material compatibility risks is now being presented as safe for the same class of vehicles.

u/IREDA1000 — 1 day ago
▲ 821 r/CriticalThinkingIndia+3 crossposts

A saffron-clad religious figure recently claimed that students who died by suicide following the paper leak did so because they "used to masturbate."

Whether one agrees with him on other issues or not, this particular statement deserves scrutiny.

When students are under immense academic pressure, facing repeated exam irregularities, uncertainty, and mental health struggles, reducing such tragedies to a claim like this shifts the conversation away from the actual issues.

Instead of asking:

  • Why do paper leaks keep happening?
  • Why is academic pressure so intense?
  • Why are mental health resources so inadequate?
  • What institutional failures contributed?

...the focus suddenly becomes moral policing and pseudoscientific claims.

Public figures have every right to express opinions, but with influence comes responsibility. Statements made without evidence, especially after a tragedy, can stigmatize mental health, discourage vulnerable students from seeking help, and divert attention from systemic problems.

Do you think public discourse in India is becoming increasingly driven by sensational claims instead of evidence-based discussions?

Video Source: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DaURUFCuKQW/?utm_source=ig_web_button_share_sheet

Link: https://www.news18.com/amp/viral/all-neet-students-used-to-masturbate-mans-shocking-remark-about-paper-leak-suicide-victims-sparks-huge-backlash-ws-l-10188477.html

u/GroundbreakingBad183 — 2 days ago

What does the happiest country in the world understand about cars better than India? My car is crying and I have to listen to it weep everyday. 🥹

Bhutan is the happiest country in the world. And to keep it's people happy, the King decided to reject E20. Officials say that there are multiple major reasons (I have posted AI summary, as the content was too long).

But the major reason that we have come to know of is the damage to cars, as E20 petrol can even absorb moisture from air to differentiate into separate phases, and the degradation of car's lifespan and power/mileage.

Is E20 really helpful today, when crude prices are much lower compared to before? And is E20 the reason why petrol prices are so high? After all, if E0 gets cheaper, why would people want to destroy their owned cars with a more expensive E20?

P.S. Most of the media outlets are only focusing on the lack of proper infrastructure instead of the damage to cars, because Bik Gayi hai Gormint. Ye saare milke humko paagal banaa rahe hai mc ke bacche.

u/Additional-Ad-3864 — 2 days ago

Is MP heading to be Another Bihar ??

Credit : Open Letter

Well by Bihar, I meant the condition of the political dispensation.......Nothing Otherwise...

This video provides a critical investigation into the state of Madhya Pradesh (MP), arguing that the region is suffering from severe systemic governance failures despite over two decades of consistent BJP rule. The narrator posits that these issues are not isolated incidents but reflect a deeper erosion of accountability.

Core Governance Failures

Public Health & Safety: The video outlines a series of preventable tragedies, including deaths caused by contaminated water in Indore, the death of newborns due to rat bites in a government ICU, and casualties linked to adulterated cough syrup.

Administrative Arrogance: A recurring theme is the dismissive and often hostile response from government officials toward public grievances, which the narrator interprets as a symptom of a power structure that has lost its connection to the electorate.

Corruption & Scams: The video details widespread systemic corruption, from blatant demands for bribes to exam recruitment scandals like the Patwari exam scam and illegal sand mining operations.

Leadership & Financial Priorities

Land Acquisition Allegations: The narrator cites Indian Express investigations alleging that Chief Minister Mohan Yadav's family and associated real estate entities acquired 168 acres of land, with 111 acres located near government-announced development projects.

Financial Strain: The state is facing a growing debt crisis, with the total debt reaching ₹4,64,000 crore. Despite this, the narrator criticizes the administration for prioritizing expensive projects like grand statues and the acquisition of VVIP jets over urgent public needs.

Political Landscape

Cycle of Freebies: The video suggests that the state government relies heavily on populist schemes like the Ladli Behna Yojana to secure electoral victories, effectively using these to maintain power while avoiding substantive reform.

Weak Opposition & Media: The narrator concludes that the collapse of the opposition (Congress) and the failure of the media to ask rigorous, difficult questions have created an environment where systemic mismanagement goes unchecked.

u/Boss_withCrown2 — 2 days ago
▲ 29 r/CriticalThinkingIndia+1 crossposts

What if the Real Challenge Wasn't E20, but the Transition in india ?

India accelerated its E20 rollout compared to the original roadmap. Engineers validated E20-compatible vehicles, but nationwide implementation also involved policy trade offs such as energy security, crude oil imports, farmer income, legacy vehicles, and consumer transition.

What if the bigger engineering challenge wasn't E20 itself, but the transition strategy?

Could a slower rollout, longer coexistence of lower blends, or more time for natural fleet replacement have reduced public resistance without sacrificing the long-term benefits?

I'm interested in hearing perspectives from engineers, policymakers, and vehicle owners. Which trade-offs would you have prioritized, and why?

Sources 👇🏼

1.)Ethanol Blending

https://www.venturasecurities.com/news/stocks/govt-mandates-20-ethanol-blended-petrol-from-april-1-2026-key-stocks-in-focus/

2.)E20 Benefits in india

https://www.suzukimotorcyclechembur.com/blogs/what-is-e20-petrol-benefits-impact-india

3.)Initiation of Ethanol Blending petrol

https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2113234&reg=48&lang=2

4.)Allegations on Nitin Gadkari for personal profit

https://www.deccanherald.com/india/conflict-of-interest-congress-alleges-gadkaris-sons-profited-from-ethanol-policy-demand-lokpal-probe-3712105

5.) Govt response on E20 Concerns

https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2155558&reg=48&lang=2

6.) Learnings from Brazil

https://vajiramandravi.com/current-affairs/indias-ethanol-push-beyond-e20/

u/Formula_explains — 2 days ago
🔥 Hot ▲ 11.9k r/CriticalThinkingIndia+3 crossposts

Another ethanol victim, Bihar’s biggest youtuber Manish Kashyap. Seems like Toyota refused warranty

u/IREDA1000 — 3 days ago

In the Modi era, human life has become cheaper than mobile data

People mention mobile data becoming cheaper often but it’s the human life that has become cheaper than mobile data.

Every few weeks, dozens/who knows even hundreds of people die somewhere in India. Sometimes it’s a stampede, sometimes a flood or cyclone which we come to know from Russia media condolences, sometimes a fire, sometimes a quarry collapse, sometimes a train station, sometimes a hospital or oxygen or water sometimes a rich kid driving a luxury car. The headlines disappear before most people even hear about them.

12 die in a quarry accident yesterday or day before.

Over 100 die in floods.

Morbi bridge collapse

The Hathras stampede kills over a hundred people, yet the man at the center of the event continues his online presence.

People die in crowd crushes during celebrations.

People die at railway stations.

People die at the Kumbh.

Over 290 in Odisha train collision

Over 100 unidentified bodies found floating in the Ganga in Unnao. Most people barely remember it today.

Children die in hospital fires or because basic public systems fail.

People died during demonetisation.

COVID came and went, and many still don’t believe we know the real human cost.

The list keeps listing some with citation, some getting called, threatened, some fabricated. Most of us can’t even remember half of these incidents because another tragedy replaces the previous one within days.

What feels different today isn’t that tragedies happen, they always have. It’s how quickly they disappear from public consciousness. Earlier, even relatively smaller incidents could trigger protests, road blockades, political outrage and sustained media attention. Today, mass casualty events often become just another news cycle before everyone moves on. Most of these are just a Google search away, but somehow too far from our collective memory.

The saddest part isn’t only the deaths. It’s the normalization of them.
It increasingly feels as though human life has become so cheap that unless you’re directly affected, another hundred deaths barely register.
Maybe that’s the most disturbing change of all.

reddit.com
u/IREDA1000 — 2 days ago

As an Indian born after the economic liberalisation and internet. Can some explain broadly how it was different from today?

I heard people talking about the difficulties before it. I have some understanding like how you required a referral to open a bank account. You need direct access to someone who knows someone for things to be done.

I remembered when many old relatives were discussing how they got the full amount of subsidy each time in the bank account. They still had to pay money for getting their names to be registered but they were more content with it. I had a different reaction to the situation.

I think for many it is an improvement that they see compared to the younger generation.

What do you think?

reddit.com
u/Redd1897 — 2 days ago
▲ 5 r/CriticalThinkingIndia+1 crossposts

Shan parasher and his confidence 🤡

GYAANDUS are a real problem ngl.The beef that india exports is strictly Carabeef or water buffalo meat not Cow meat as he is implying in the clip and it's an authorised industry so what does he want banned?

u/vincekinv — 1 day ago