1986 325e: M20 rebuild vs. M50 swap — what would you recommend?
Hello fellow enthusiasts,
I’ve finally decided to take care of an issue I’ve been avoiding with my 1986 325e. A few years ago, I was replacing the water pump, and when I installed the new one, I could never get it to seal properly. After trying three different water pumps, I eventually gave up. Since the block also looked pretty rusty on the inside, I decided that I would do an engine swap instead.
The biggest concern I have with my current engine isn’t just the rust I can see; it’s that I don’t really trust the overall integrity of the block and internals for the long term. I have no idea what kind of maintenance or work has been done to it over the years, especially when it comes to the pistons, piston rings, connecting rods, crankshaft, and other internal components. Since I want to keep this car for the rest of my life, I’d rather start with an engine that I can have confidence in and properly maintain from the beginning.
At one point, I was considering an M50 swap, but now I’m not sure if that’s the best route for what I want. If I went with an M50, I’d also be looking at either buying a rebuilt engine or finding one in good condition and rebuilding it myself.
I’m not trying to build a race car. My main goal is simply to have a more reliable car that I can enjoy. If I ever decide I want more power in the future, I’d probably turbo whichever engine I end up with.
That has led me to consider buying a rebuilt M20. However, I’m not sure whether it would be better to buy an M20 that has already been rebuilt or find one in better condition and rebuild it myself. I’m also wondering whether buying a rebuilt M20 from eBay is a good idea.
For those of you who have gone through something similar, what would you recommend? Would you stick with an M20, go with an M50, or take a different route altogether?