▲ 539 r/fuckcars

70% of Indians don't own a car. So why is every Indian city designed entirely for the 30% that do?

Stood at a signal near Hebbal last week. Counted vehicles for about 10 minutes out of pure boredom.

Bikes and scooters. Overwhelmingly. Then autos. Then BMTC buses packed so full people were hanging off the door. Cars were maybe 20-25% of what I saw. But the entire road, 6 lanes, two flyovers, a grade separator that took 4 years to build, existed almost entirely to move those cars slightly faster.

The bus stop was a painted line on the shoulder. No shade. No seating. Standing in exhaust fumes.

This isn't a Bangalore problem. Drive through any Indian city and the logic is the same. Road widening projects always eat into footpaths first. Flyovers go where car traffic is heavy. Parking bylaws require developers to build more car parking than actual homes in some zones. Signal timings are calibrated for vehicle throughput not pedestrian safety.

Meanwhile the guy on the BMTC gets 90 seconds to cross 6 lanes if he's lucky.

Census data is pretty clear on this. Less than 30% of Indian households own a car. But somewhere along the way city planning decided that car ownership was the default and everything else was a problem to manage around it.

The weird part is we have examples of it done differently right here. Pune's river promenade. Parts of Chandigarh. Connaught Place on a Sunday when they pedestrianise it. The moment you take cars out, people actually use the space. Families, walkers, vendors, everyone. Turns out people like cities that are built for people.

But those are exceptions and usually temporary ones.

I think the real problem is who sits in planning meetings. It's not the BMTC commuter. It's not the guy on the bike. It's people who drove to that meeting and will drive home after it.

What's it like in your city? Is there even one road that feels like it was designed for someone who doesn't own a car?

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 13 hours ago

Bangalore property gives you 2% rental yield. Fixed deposits give you 7%. Someone explain the logic to me.

Cousin bought a 2BHK in Marathahalli in 2021. Paid ₹75 lakhs all in. Rents it out for ₹22,000 a month.

That's a 3.5% gross yield. After maintenance, property tax, occasional repairs and the months it sits vacant between tenants, he's probably netting 2.8% annually.

SBI fixed deposit is sitting at 6.8%.

I'm not saying property is a bad investment. But can we stop pretending rental income is part of the thesis here? Because the numbers don't support it. At all.

The only real argument for Bangalore real estate right now is appreciation. Buy at ₹6,000 psf, sell at ₹9,500 psf in 5 years. That's the actual bet people are making. Rental yield is just something that covers part of the EMI while you wait.

Which is fine. But then be honest about it.

The problem is a lot of buyers I talk to genuinely believe rental income will cover their EMI. On a ₹75 lakh flat with a ₹60 lakh loan your EMI is somewhere around ₹52,000 to ₹55,000 at current rates. Rental income covers maybe half of that in most Bangalore micro-markets outside Indiranagar and Koramangala.

The locations with decent yields, Koramangala, HSR, parts of Indiranagar, are also the locations where entry price is already so high that the appreciation story gets harder to underwrite.

And the locations where the appreciation story is strongest, Devanahalli, Kogilu, North Bangalore periphery, rental demand is thin because the actual working population living there is still limited.

It's a genuine catch-22 that nobody selling you a flat wants to talk about.

Has anyone here actually run the numbers end to end on their Bangalore property investment? Curious what yields people are actually seeing on the ground.

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 22 hours ago

70% of Indians don't own a car. So why is every Indian city designed entirely for the 30% that do?

Stood at a signal near Hebbal last week. Counted vehicles for about 10 minutes out of pure boredom.

Bikes and scooters. Overwhelmingly. Then autos. Then BMTC buses packed so full people were hanging off the door. Cars were maybe 20-25% of what I saw. But the entire road, 6 lanes, two flyovers, a grade separator that took 4 years to build, existed almost entirely to move those cars slightly faster.

The bus stop was a painted line on the shoulder. No shade. No seating. Standing in exhaust fumes.

This isn't a Bangalore problem. Drive through any Indian city and the logic is the same. Road widening projects always eat into footpaths first. Flyovers go where car traffic is heavy. Parking bylaws require developers to build more car parking than actual homes in some zones. Signal timings are calibrated for vehicle throughput not pedestrian safety.

Meanwhile the guy on the BMTC gets 90 seconds to cross 6 lanes if he's lucky.

Census data is pretty clear on this. Less than 30% of Indian households own a car. But somewhere along the way city planning decided that car ownership was the default and everything else was a problem to manage around it.

The weird part is we have examples of it done differently right here. Pune's river promenade. Parts of Chandigarh. Connaught Place on a Sunday when they pedestrianise it. The moment you take cars out, people actually use the space. Families, walkers, vendors, everyone. Turns out people like cities that are built for people.

But those are exceptions and usually temporary ones.

I think the real problem is who sits in planning meetings. It's not the BMTC commuter. It's not the guy on the bike. It's people who drove to that meeting and will drive home after it.

What's it like in your city? Is there even one road that feels like it was designed for someone who doesn't own a car?

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 22 hours ago

Builders in Bangalore are selling you flats that legally don't exist yet. And everyone's okay with this somehow.

Friend of mine paid ₹5 lakh booking amount for a project near Devanahalli. Pre-launch price, big discount, "limited units" the usual stuff. Asked me to check it.

RERA number didn't exist. Project wasn't registered. Technically he paid ₹5 lakh for a floor plan PDF and a builder's promise.

This is happening everywhere right now. Sarjapur, Hennur, Kogilu, Devanahalli. Builders are collecting pre-launch money before RERA registration because once RERA comes in they have to freeze the price, commit to a timeline, and actually be accountable. So they do a "soft launch" before all that. Collect crores. Then register.

And buyers are lining up for it because the pre-launch price looks attractive. ₹500-700 psf cheaper than post-RERA launch. Feels like a deal.

What you're actually buying is credit risk. If the builder runs into approval issues, land disputes, funding problems, your money is stuck. No RERA, no recourse. Civil court only. Good luck with that timeline.

The thing is Karnataka RERA is actually one of the stricter ones in the country. But it only protects you after registration. That gap before registration is completely unregulated and builders know exactly what they're doing.

I'm not saying all pre-launches are scams. Some builders have clean track records and sort their RERA within weeks. But a lot of them are sitting on your money for 6-8 months before the project is even legally launchable.

If you're looking right now, just ask for the RERA number before paying anything. Even a token amount. If they say "it's coming in 2 weeks" walk away and come back in 2 weeks. The price will be the same. The unit will still be available. The discount was never real.

Has anyone here actually lost money in a pre-launch gone wrong? Curious how common this actually is.

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 3 days ago

We spent lakhs of crores on metro rails. Then made it impossible to actually reach the station.

My office is 4km from the nearest metro station. You'd think that's fine right. Just take the metro.

Except there's no direct bus to the station. Autos refuse below ₹80 for that stretch. The footpath to walk it doesn't exist for half the route. And the cycle track they announced two years ago is still a painted line on a road that floods every monsoon.

So I take my bike. Like everyone else.

This is the part that genuinely baffles me about how we plan metros in this country. The actual train is the easy part. Lay the track, buy the coaches, open the station. Done. But we somehow never think about what happens after someone gets off. Or how they get there in the first place.

Bangalore metro ridership is still way below targets after almost a decade. Delhi Metro is better but still struggling outside the core city zones. Hyderabad Metro had decent early numbers then kind of plateaued. And the reason is almost always the same thing. The last mile is broken.

Pune is building a metro right now. I genuinely hope someone in that planning room is thinking about feeder buses before the inauguration happens. Because if the pattern holds they'll build the stations, cut the ribbon, and figure out connectivity maybe 4-5 years later after ridership disappoints.

The frustrating part is this isn't complicated to solve. Ahmedabad BRTS worked because they planned buses and metro together as one system. Mumbai local works because the station exits drop you into markets, bus stops, and auto stands. It didn't happen by accident.

We just keep treating the metro as the project and everything around it as someone else's problem.

Anyone actually using metro daily here? Curious how you're solving the last mile personally because clearly the city isn't.

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 3 days ago

Why do Indian cities keep building footpaths that become unusable in 6 months

There's a stretch near my area. Got a brand new footpath sometime last year. Looked decent honestly. Wide enough, paved properly, little kerb stones and everything.

I walked on it exactly twice.

First time BESCOM dug it up for some cable work. Left it half open for like 3 weeks. Then filled it back but didn't level it properly so now there's this random hump in the middle. Then a chaat guy set up right at the corner. Then someone started parking their Activa on it every morning. Now there's a tempo that unloads vegetables on it between 7-9am daily and nobody says anything.

I just walk on the road now. Like everyone else.

The thing is this isn't a new problem or a surprise to anyone. Every city does this. Chennai, Lucknow, Pune, Hyderabad. Same story everywhere. Crores get spent, footpath looks nice in the inauguration photo, falls apart within a year.

And I think the actual reason nobody fixes it is that no single agency owns the footpath. PWD builds it. BESCOM digs it. BWSSB digs it again. Telecom guys come after that. Nobody has to fix what they break because there's no penalty and no one's tracking it. So the footpath just slowly gets destroyed by everyone and owned by no one.

BBMP spent something like ₹180 crore on footpaths between 2019-2023. I genuinely cannot tell where that went if I look at most roads in Bangalore.

Ahmedabad's BRTS corridor is the only place I've seen it work somewhat decently. Not perfect but at least the path stays a path. Probably because one agency controls that whole corridor end to end.

Anyway. Is this fixable or are we just going to keep relaying the same footpaths every few years and acting surprised?

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 5 days ago

Sarjapur Road prices make zero sense right now and nobody's talking about it

Looked at 6 projects on Sarjapur Road last quarter. Base price starting at ₹8,500 per sqft. For an area that still floods every monsoon and has one functional road in and out.

Not bashing the location. But ₹8,500 psf is Whitefield pricing from two years ago. And at least Whitefield had the metro conversation going for it.

Sarjapur has NICE Road. That's it. Outer Ring Road connectivity is a pain. The proposed peripheral ring road has been "coming soon" since 2019. And builders are selling you appreciation potential on infrastructure that doesn't exist yet.

Talked to a few buyers who closed there in 2022 at ₹6,200-6,500 psf. Good entry. Makes sense. But the guys buying at ₹9,000+ today? I genuinely don't understand the thesis.

Meanwhile North Bangalore near Hebbal and Yelahanka still has room. Airport connectivity is real, not proposed. Aerospace SEZ is actually moving. You're getting better fundamentals at similar or lower pricing.

Maybe I'm missing something with Sarjapur. Genuine question - if you've bought there recently, what's your logic? Is it purely the IT corridor proximity? Because that alone can't justify a 35-40% jump in 18 months.

Happy to be wrong here. But the numbers aren't adding up for me.

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 6 days ago

Bangalore's infrastructure problem is coming for Hyderabad

Spent the last 5 years watching property development across Bangalore and Hyderabad. The infrastructure gap is getting worse, not better.

Bangalore added like 2 million people between 2010-2020. Metro was supposed to handle it. Didn't. Roads were supposed to handle it. Didn't. You still sit 90 minutes in traffic to go 15km during peak hours. It's insane.

Now Hyderabad is on the exact same path. Growth numbers are actually higher. But the metro's still 5 years out. IT corridor expansion is ongoing. Same infrastructure squeeze we saw in Bangalore, just compressed into a tighter timeline.

I was looking at a project in Whitefield last month. The builder's been sitting on approvals for 18 months because Bangalore can't clear sewage lines fast enough. Meanwhile Hyderabad's approving new layouts before water supply is even planned.

This isn't about whether cities are "good" or "bad." It's that we build at Year 10 scale when we're at Year 3 of actual growth. Then spend a decade fixing it.

The only exception I've seen is Goa, because they basically capped density. Mumbai just went up instead of out.

What's it like where you are? Are your cities actually planning ahead or is it just reactive chaos like everywhere else?

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 6 days ago

Indian cities aren't designed for people anymore. theyre designed for parking. Parking for cars that dont even move

Walk through any Indian city residential area and youll notice something: the roads are narrower than they should be. footpaths are gone. there's no space to stand. and everywhere you look theres parked cars. literally everywhere.

This isn't accidental. Cities are becoming storage yards for vehicles not living spaces for people.

The numbers are wild. commuters spend 15-30 minutes daily just searching for a parking spot. not driving to work. just looking for where to park. thats time wasted. fuel wasted. emissions added. all for a problem cities created themselves.

vehicle ownership in india is 300+ million right now. 70% two-wheelers. 17.8% cars. And the projection is that car ownership will triple to 90 million by 2050. which means parking demand will explode.

But here's the thing: cities arent building parking. theyre just letting it happen on streets. so residential colonies that were designed 20 years ago with minor parking now have cars parked on both sides of the road. lanes are narrower. footpaths are gone. kids cant play. cycles cant exist.

Meanwhile, 30-40% of parking garage space is wasted just on circulation ramps and driving aisles. so even when cities do build parking, half of it is just movement not actual parking.

And nobody talks about what this means for public transit. buses compete for the same road space as parked cars. so buses get slower. which makes buses less attractive. so more people buy cars. which means more parking needed. which means narrower roads. which means buses get slower again.

Its a self-reinforcing trap. the car wins. the city loses.

The weird part: most cities have parking policies now (Delhi, Mumbai, Bangalore, Pune). But they arent enforced. parking remains free or underpriced. So theres no incentive to not park.

And nobody mentions the real cost. that space on the road? it could be a cycle lane. or wider footpath. or a green median. or actual bus lane. instead its where someones car sits doing nothing for 8 hours.

Sources: IIMB parking study 2017, Ministry of Road Transport data, urban planning research on vehicle-centric cities, parking policy assessments Delhi/Mumbai/Bangalore 2023-26

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 11 days ago

Most people buying for rent in Bangalore are picking the wrong areas. rental yields tell a different story

Just noticed something interesting while tracking Bangalore's rental market. everyone assumes buying in Whitefield or Sarjapur = guaranteed rental income. But the numbers say something different.

Whitefield and Sarjapur average 3-4.5% rental yield. which is fine but not amazing. but HSR Layout, Hennur Gardens, Dodda Nekkundi are hitting 6-7.3% yields. Same Bangalore. completely different returns.

The rental market here is worth ₹60,000-70,000 crore annually right now. 1.8-2 million rental households. average rent across IT corridors is ₹28,000. so theres genuine demand.

But here's where people mess up: they buy in the "hot" areas (everyone's talking about them). Not the areas with actual rental demand. Whitefield is famous. But HSR Layout actually delivers higher yields because it's established and dense.

North Bangalore is growing but most people buying there are betting on appreciation not rentals. Sarjapur has rental demand but entry price is high now. So yield gets compressed.

The supply picture matters too. Inventory is at record highs (12% increase Q1 2026). Which means landlords cant just charge whatever they want. Yields are stabilizing. which is good for long-term stability but bad for quick returns.

Smart investors right now seem to be looking at gated communities specifically. because tenants are willing to pay more for security and amenities. So a gated apartment in HSR Layout or KR Puram could actually outperform a cheaper open layout apartment somewhere.

Also hybrid work changed things. people want 3BHKs now not 2BHKs. families want home offices. which means larger units rent for more. bigger yield potential.

So before buying for rental income in Bangalore, check actual yield data for the micro-market not just the corridor reputation. difference between 3% and 7% yield is literally lakhs per year.

Sources: Bangalore rental market analysis 2026, micro-market yield data June 2026, IT corridor rental demand studies, gated community rental performance analysis

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 11 days ago

Delhi is sinking. Bangalore is sinking. Nobody's talking about it. same reason as Joshimath

So turns out major Indian cities are literally sinking and most people have no idea it's happening.

Delhi. Mumbai. Bangalore. Chennai. Kolkata. All experiencing land subsidence. In Delhi, some areas are sinking 11 cm per year. Faridabad is sinking 3 cm per year. That's not slow. That's acceleration.

The cause is straightforward: groundwater depletion. Cities pump groundwater faster than it can recharge. The land collapses. Buildings crack. Infrastructure fails. Just like Joshimath.

The thing is, groundwater is invisible. You can't see it dropping. You can't see your neighbor pumping it. You can't see the aquifer weakening. So cities keep treating it as infinite. Apartments install borewells. Commercial buildings pump endlessly. Groundwater supplies 48% of urban water. Yet it's not planned for. It's just... extracted.

Meanwhile cities lose 30-50% of water to leaks and theft in the distribution network. So instead of fixing pipes, we just drill deeper borewells. Into depleting aquifers.

The result: 80 million residents and 13 million buildings are now at risk. That's 5 major cities sinking while we build more apartments on top of them.

And here's the thing nobody mentions: cities cleared wetlands and lakes for construction. Those were natural recharge zones. So rainfall no longer soaks into the ground. It just runs off into drains. Which means we need even more groundwater extraction. Which accelerates subsidence.

It's a self-reinforcing trap. Urban expansion destroys recharge. Recharge loss forces deeper extraction. Extraction causes subsidence. Subsidence cracks infrastructure. Which requires more water for repairs. Which requires more extraction.

Same pattern as Joshimath. We knew it was happening. Data was available. But because it's invisible and slow, it became a "natural disaster" instead of an urban planning failure.

Sources: Nature Sustainability study 2025, CGWB groundwater data, Delhi satellite imagery analysis 2014-2020, World Bank water depletion studies

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 14 days ago

Honest question: how many emis do you actually have going on right now

Just scrolling through this sub and realized everyone's juggling multiple EMIs. A phone ₹2,400, a bike ₹4,000, credit card dues ₹6,500. That's already ₹12,900 before your home loan even hits.

And by the time the salary comes in, 30-50% is gone. just like that.

The thing is, nobody talks about how this actually feels. The financial anxiety, the sleepless nights calculating due dates. It's become so normal that nobody even mentions it anymore. We just accept that this is how life is now.

Data shows 69% of Indian households are in financial insecurity. 58% struggle to balance expenses month to month. And 11% are already defaulting.

So is it just me or has EMI culture become the biggest financial trap for the middle class. worse than inflation or taxes or anything else.

What's your situation right now. How many active EMIs do you have. And more importantly, when does it actually end. At what point do you have breathing room.

Because the earn-borrow-repay-repeat cycle feels like it has no exit.

​

Sources: RBI household debt data March 2025, Financial Security Index 2026, credit card debt analysis

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 16 days ago

Real talk: are you guys buying ready or under-construction in 2026. seems like everyones torn on this

Anyone else completely confused about whether to go ready or under-construction right now. everyone has a different take. some people swear by under-construction (lower price, better appreciation). Others say ready-to-move (no delays, rental income immediately).

The numbers seem to favor both depending on what you want: under-construction is 10-20% cheaper entry. but construction delays are a massive risk. youre paying for something that might not come for 2-3 years.

Ready properties cost more upfront but you get keys in 3 months. rental yield is better. zero construction risk.

Heres my confusion: if youre buying for yourself, ready makes sense obviously. but if youre investing, do you actually wait 2-3 years betting on appreciation while paying pre-emi. or do you just buy ready at premium and get rental income immediately.

Also doesnt builder reputation matter way more than project status. Like buying under-construction from a shady builder seems riskier than paying more for a known developer.

2026 supposedly offers 10-14% annual returns either way (rent + appreciation). so maybe it comes down to your risk appetite and how long youre willing to wait.

What are you guys actually doing. Anyone here actually got burned by under-construction delays. Or anyone regretting paying premium for ready properties.

​

Genuine question because the market seems split on this.

​

Sources: Real estate market analysis 2026, RERA data on construction delays, rental yield and appreciation studies on Indian properties

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 16 days ago

Indian cities are killing off street culture in the name of modernization. nobody talks about this

Every indian city is redesigning its streets. and theyre all doing the exact same thing: making them for cars.

which means theyre literally killing the thing that made indian streets special—the social life. the vendors. people hanging out. chai stalls. kids playing. old people sitting. this is where actual community happens.

but now streets get wider lanes. more traffic signals. hostile design that says "keep moving." street vendors get removed. gathering spaces disappear. sidewalks shrink or get converted to parking.

its being done in the name of "modernization" and "smart cities." but were just copying global planning playbooks that dont understand that streets are where life happens in india.

in bangalore, gandhi bazar used to be where you haggled with vendors, ate at darshinis, got your tyre fixed on the street, drank chai. that WAS the urban experience. now theyre "upgrading" streets to smooth out traffic flow and that life is gone.

the irony: as public spaces disappear, people retreat into gated communities and malls. which fragments the city more. so cities become less vibrant not more.

public spaces in indian cities are already shrinking. parks gone. water bodies depleting. encroachment everywhere. and then we design the streets we have left as if theyre highways.

were not creating better cities. were just creating faster traffic with no life.

Sources: MIT urban planning research on Indian streets, NIUA public space transformation data, urban design studies on street culture in Bangalore

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 17 days ago

Which bangalore micro-market should you actually invest in right now. honest take

I have been looking at projects across bangalore for a while and the market is weirdly bifurcated right now.

east bangalore (whitefield, sarjapur) is the "safe" choice. prices ₹11-13k per sq ft. established. rental yield 3.37%. people actually live there. so you know youll fill the apartment with tenants. but appreciation is moderate. 6-8% annual. youre paying premium for stability not growth.

north bangalore (airport corridor, devanahalli) is the opposite. cheaper entry. underdeveloped infrastructure right now. but airport-driven boom means higher returns later. the problem: its a gamble. infrastructure takes time. rental market still building. you might get stuck with a vacant apartment for months.

sarjapur road / chikka tirupathi corridor is the sweet spot imo. its the hottest micro-market right now. near-possession properties appreciated 16% recently. infrastructure (outer ring road, SWIFT City coming) is actually happening not promised. rental demand there because its between IT parks and city. but its already got 12%+ appreciation so youre paying for growth that's already happened.

the thing nobody talks about: the areas everyone recommends are already expensive. youre paying ₹12-13k per sq ft for the privilege of being safe.

the areas that actually appreciated the most (sarjapur, north bangalore) are the ones people were unsure about 2 years ago.

so the real question is: are you buying for safety or returns. because theyre opposite right now.

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 17 days ago

Got my home loan rejected. heres what i missed that cost me the deal

Finally found my house. negotiated. paid the advance. got all excited. then the bank said no.

and the worst part? they didnt really explain why. rejection letter just said "application denied."

took me weeks to figure out what went wrong.

turns out it wasnt about my salary. it was about my CIBIL score. i had a missed credit card payment from 2 years ago that i honestly forgot about. one payment. happened in 2024. and apparently that one missed payment reduced my eligibility by like 8 lakhs.

the bank's internal scoring isn't just your overall score. they look at recent payment behavior. missed a single payment recently? theyre not touching your loan.

the other thing nobody told me: each time i applied for a loan rejection just added to my problem. every new application = another hard inquiry on my CIBIL. each one drops my score 5-10 points. so by the time i figured out the problem i'd already made it worse by reapplying.

also apparently my EMI-to-income ratio was already at 48%. the new home loan would've pushed it to 53%. banks max out at 50%. so even if my credit score was perfect i still wouldve gotten rejected.

nobody tells you this stuff before you apply. theres no checklist. you just find out after paying the processing fee and getting a rejection letter.

20-25% of all home loan applications get rejected in india. and most people don't know why until way too late.

if youre thinking about applying: check your CIBIL score first. seriously. one old missed payment can cost you everything. and calculate your total EMI ratio including any other loans. banks wont tell you youre ineligible till after theyve already said no.

Sources: Industry data on 20-25% rejection rates, RBI lending guidelines, CIBIL scoring analysis 2026, banking eligibility criteria reports

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 17 days ago

Builders have a playbook and theyre not even trying to hide it anymore

I have noticed every single property ad follows the exact same script now:

"only one unit left" - okay but like... it was the only unit left 3 months ago too when i first saw this ad

"another buyer is interested" - cool. let me know when they actually commit lol

"limited time offer valid only today" - seen this offer every week for 6 months

"no emi till possession" - oh nice. so i pay 50k rent + the down payment while waiting 3 years. amazing deal

the classic one is still "token amount now, verification later" which translates to "give us money first trust us later" which has never backfired ever

40% of under-construction projects got delayed last year but sure lets act shocked when yours is late too

then theres the fake testimonials. "i bought this property and my kids got better grades" okay mate i think thats just parenting not the apartment

honestly the builders dont even believe their own marketing anymore. theres a subvention scam where they literally advertise "no emi" then charge you interest disguised as "maintenance advance"

people lost 15000 crore last year. but sure lets sign without a lawyer reviewing the fine print

the funniest part? theyre all doing this and we all know theyre doing this but we still fall for it because where else are we gonna buy right

​

Sources: Anarock 2025 project delay data, Ministry of Housing data on buyer losses, RERA complaint reports 2026, real estate fraud studies on subvention schemes.

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 18 days ago

My friend is confused between new vs resale. everyone tells him different things

My friend is looking to buy his first home and hes completely lost lol. torn between a new apartment (2025 launch, under construction) or a resale flat (5 years old, ready to move).

new one is 78 lakhs, resale is 68 lakhs. same size same area basically.

his family keeps fighting about it. parents say resale. coworkers say new. reddit says both are bad lol.

hes heard:

​

new = better appreciation but 2-5 year wait

resale = move in immediately but older

something about GST thats confusing

loan stuff he doesnt understand

​

he currently pays 50k rent and just wants to stop bleeding money tbh. doesnt seem like hes betting on appreciation. he just wants a place to live.

​

i think resale makes sense because he gets keys in 3 months. but then hes worried about missing out on appreciation when new construction finishes.

​

what am i missing here. is the appreciation difference actually worth waiting 2+ years while still paying 50k rent?

also people keep hinting at weird stuff about resale properties. what should he actually be worried about. its 5 years old not 30 right.

​

just trying to help him make the right call. hes stressed about this decision.

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 18 days ago

India's "slum-free cities" promise. Then demolishes 100,000 homes and acts shocked when the poor don't vanish.

so every year indian cities declare war on slums. bulldozers roll. families lose homes. government announces theyre "building a slum-free india."

but heres the thing nobody admits. the poor people dont disappear. they just move to the next slum. then that one gets demolished too.

in delhi alone 100,000 people get displaced annually. in ahmedabad 150,000 people lost homes in ramapir no tekro last year. all promised "in situ rehabilitation." most got apartments in the middle of nowhere with no access to jobs.

the logic is backwards. poor people live in slums because affordable housing doesnt exist. demolishing slums doesnt create affordable housing. it just removes shelter and leaves people homeless. they rebuild elsewhere.

the real problem? 49% of indias urban population still lives in slums. its been stuck there for decades. why? because 80% of urban poor work informal jobs near city centers. if you demolish their slum you displace them from work too. they lose income. then they rebuild in another slum.

the government demolishes before elections, before g20 summits, before international delegations arrive. its about image not solutions.

real solution: secure land tenure for slum dwellers. invest in water, sanitation, electricity where they actually are. integrate slums into cities not erase them.

but thats hard. bulldozers are easy. thats why they keep doing it.

​

​

Sources: World Bank urban data 2020, Ahmedabad redevelopment reports 2025-26, Delhi demolition studies, research on informal settlements in Indian cities

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 19 days ago

Distress sales are quietly happening. People selling at 10-20% loss just to stop bleeding money.

I have been seeing more posts lately about people offloading investment properties. not because theyre excited to sell. because they cant afford the emis anymore.

heres whats actually going on. sales dropped 14% last year. inventory piled up 4%. supply exceeds demand. people who bought 5-10 years ago as investments now realize the rent doesnt cover their costs.

you buy a place for 1 crore. emi is 60k. rent is 40k. youre bleeding 20k every month. job lost. salary not increasing. can't keep it going.

so theyre selling. taking 10-15% loss just to get out. its not that the property crashed. its that the owner broke.

the ones getting desperate are posting on reddit and property sites looking for quick sales. "willing to negotiate", "urgent sale", "below market rate".

rents are actually falling in some areas because so many investors are desperate to fill vacancies. which makes the situation worse. you bought thinking rent would go up. instead its going down.

this isnt a market crash yet. but its distress at the individual level. and thats how crashes start.

buyers with cash are probably getting good deals right now if theyre paying attention.

reddit.com
u/AmitTheAnalyst — 19 days ago