[32M] Going back to monogamy because NM feels more limiting and unfair for straight men
Hi all!
This is mostly going to be a rant, but I’m curious if anyone else has experienced something similar.
I’m 32M and have been NM for 12 years. I’ve had several primary and secondary partners. My last relationship was poly and lasted 8 years, during which I had a primary and up to 3 secondaries.
I’ve always struggled to find partners, both casual and serious, whenever I was open about being NM. For years, I assumed it was because I wasn’t attractive or interesting enough. Since I felt like I didn’t have many options, I often settled.
Meanwhile, my partners seemed to have the opposite experience. They could hook up with whoever they wanted, whenever they wanted. At one point, my last primary had only me, then went back on dating apps 7 years into our relationship and had more experiences in one month than I’d had in the previous 7 years.
Another example is my current secondary. She recently broke up with both of her other partners, so she went back on Tinder. We were on vacation together and her notifications were absolutely wild. Within 1 day, she already had 3 dates lined up and a threesome with some random couple.
I’ve also had a few slightly toxic secondary relationships where I was basically told that they could replace me or go fuck whoever they wanted if I didn’t accept certain conditions, while they clearly knew I couldn't use the same card.
Over the last 6 months, I broke up with my primary and 2 secondaries. I also stopped mentioning that I was NM when dating.
And suddenly, I have choices.
In 6 months, I’ve had more first dates than I had in the previous 8 years. I’ve even turned down beautiful women because I didn’t think we were compatible enough, didn’t like the sex enough, or couldn’t see myself building a life with them.
It’s honestly been a very weird experience. For years, I thought I was the problem, and now I’m wondering how much of it was simply the NM label. That label meant freedom to me, but I've now realized it was the opposite.
Obviously, I know I still don’t have anywhere near as many options as most NM women do. But apparently that difference bothers me a lot more than I ever realized. It’s gotten to the point where, even if I could have exactly the same dating options I have now while being NM, I’m not sure I’d choose NM anymore.
And I think that’s the weirdest part of all of this. I spent 13 years thinking NM was what I wanted, and now that I’ve finally experienced what dating feels like when I actually have options, I’m seriously considering going back to monogamy.