Counterpoint: What if this is the birth, not death knell, for tribal SWU?

Counterpoint: What if this is the birth, not death knell, for tribal SWU?

I've been thinking a lot about yet another thoughtful post u/Dashakh made a few weeks ago, where he and other lamented that once again we've got close-but-not-quite tribal play patterns.

While I obviously have no idea what's to come, I'm actually incredibly hopeful that, based on a comment (I think it was) Jack Danny made in the State of the SWUnion video, that the devs are well aware of the need to continue to support certain archetypes, and will continue to do so more over time now, there may be hope for those of us who loved playing goblin and elven decks as kids and now want our own kiddos dreams of Kylo commanding a fiercesome First Order, or Poggle at the head of a pack of beasts, to come true!

It was one comment in particular that got me thinking we may have just entered this nirvanna:

>I’m super baffled by there being 10 Force legendaries but not a single legendary of one of the four species. Makes absolutely no sense. It makes me wonder if they realized halfway through making the set that the theme wasn’t marketable or something and hard pivoted to include other things.

But... what if you've been waiting four sets for your Qui Gon to finally be viable, or you want one last hurrah with Talzin, and Mae and the MT unit are just the tools you were looking for?

Or take pilots. I know a lot of folks are tired of Vader menacing the skies, and did he really need Victor Squadron?

Well, my Wedge, who I've loved since he was the very first leader I opened last fall, is certainly happy to finally be viable, too, thanks to the support he got from Yellow Aces Bomber and one or two pieces of spice that just came out this set. I even take most of my Vader matches.

So yes, maybe Homeworlds wasn't the set for ewoks or wookies to totally dominate — yet. And I know with FFG's past track record of totally ignoring First Order, or having only three new bounty hunters since Baby Boba was released, might give us pause. But you know what made that Baby Boba deck better? Cards like Trask Walker, or ramping into a Victor Squadron on turn four.

So maybe Homeworlds was the set for kicking off the fuzzy tribal era — AND the set for letting Force and Pilot decks have one last hurrah. Maybe we can get some credit boosts and hate in Icons to keep that corner of the meta viable and interesting for the year ahead.

We've seen plenty of wookies across sets, and we got two ewoks in Ashes. Maybe I'm a fool, maybe I'm a sucker, but I've got my fingers crossed we'll see one or two really fun Twileks for the next few sets, maybe not every one, but enough that by this time next year, we're seeing a few Kalikori-themed decks top 8'ing sectors. And I hope you're hopeful, too.

Edit to add links to OG post, for the curious, and the SotSWUnion video.

u/MC_NYC — 11 days ago

This is how you concede with honor...

Cheers to you, Internet stranger, for going out in cinder-charred style!!

u/MC_NYC — 1 month ago

Finally enough support for Kannan Critter Deck?

Thinking B/G splash for the Sarlacc on 5 or 6 to get one last shield off? Maybe not terrible with all the Spectres, too, plus Vernestra??? Total jank, but could be fun...

u/MC_NYC — 1 month ago

Should my hub just come apart like this?

Was giving my 3T Strada a thorough clean over the weekend, removed the wheels for some real deep scrubbing, and don't remember if/how much I pulled on the cassette while doing, but it just slid halfway out of the hub, with the metal rod attached. I then pulled out the whole assembly to see what was up, and there were just these two black plugs holding the silver rod, one labeled E16, the other E19. One of which was still sitting in the non-drive side even once the rod was out, I think held in place just with grease and muck.

Looking closely, there's Revo bearings in there, and the construction of the hub (3T branded) looks a lot like this setup, except without any kind of axle to unbolt, because it's a thru-axle design.

Is this a common design? It seems like things should be more secure, they seem to be on the front wheel. Then again, when I got everything back together, it seems to all work and fit, and maybe with the thru axle, it's not an issue, or even preferred, as that will hold everything in place, and not having any parts screwed down lets everything spin more freely, right?

Or did something break or go missing out I'm missing how to actually tighten things somehow? The two caps have no grooves or threading that I can see that would allow for that.

Thanks so much for the info! When I looked for similar hubs, it seemed like everything has at least some amount of fastening to hold things in place. Like, if I'm out in the wild changing a flat, do I really want some of those pieces sliding off and away? Or that just doesn't happen in practice?

u/MC_NYC — 1 month ago

Best G/Y heroic answers to Condemn?

Working on a Wedge-Yellow brew, it gets there most of the time, including outracing and outpacing a lot of control tricks by going tall and kinda wide... I can even play around Condemns, but they're definitely one of the bigger issues*. I've thought about Constables, and even funky moves like Jump to Lightspeed or even splashing There Is No Conflict, but those last two require waiting for the opponent to tap out and at best removing the Condemn for a turn. Reforge would be great if it worked with pilots... Any other clever ideas?

The other obvious one is HSD, but Chewie is decent here, and I run three Jam Comms in the side.

reddit.com
u/MC_NYC — 1 month ago
▲ 0 r/sram

13sp cassette with Rival D1 XPLR?

Pretty sure I know the answer, but these aren't compatible, right? I stupidly bought the cassette and E1 derailleur to upgrade my 3T Strada, which I thought was UDH compatible... Turns out it's not, so I'm stuck with the old derailleur. Would love to eek out that little bit of advantage (moving the parts onto a gravel frame I just picked up), but I fear all is for naught, or is it not?

Thanks!

reddit.com
u/MC_NYC — 1 month ago

Draft for four?

We may only get four folks out for locals this week, as it's the end of summer. I was wondering if anyone has tried this, and what the experience and modifications have been

I was looking at four-player draft formats, and I see that MTG does a pick-two format with 40 card decks. I've also seen it suggested that a forth pack, with pick one or pick two, is maybe now viable.

I just wasn't sure with the mechanics of SWU what works best here. With the leaders and heroic and villainy impacting could choices a lot more, would a standard three packs, with pick one or pick two work or not?

Thanks for the advice!

reddit.com
u/MC_NYC — 2 months ago

What about banning Cad for PQs but not upcoming sectors?

I thought the argument on the latest Colorado Cantina pod was pretty persuasive, that it may be too late to ban Cad because of the upcoming Sectors... But especially for those who are casually competitive, going to store showdowns and a PQ or two a season— I'm not looking to always play a meta deck or spend for all the top-end blue villainy. Would love a fighting chance at an upcoming PQ or showdown, and also could start to give us a taste for the next meta. Otherwise, are people just going to skip out PQs as more come?

I realize this is probably too confusing and unrealistic, and you risk some people showing up with a banned deck. Just thought it might be a good halfway point to still keep the season interesting.

reddit.com
u/MC_NYC — 2 months ago

How's this for a very rough facsimile of the UCI Road Race?

Visiting, looking to get out for a long ride while visiting for the week, thought it would be fun to fake some portion of the UCI road race. I looked at sticking more to the actual route, but some of those seem like busier or less pleasant roads, and who wouldn't want to follow the main bike paths and waterways more?! Just curious if there's options I'm missing, what people think of the course, and any other good advice, like must-try bakeries or cafes?

Thanks in advance. Route is here: https://ridewithgps.com/routes/56486962

And this is a maybe somewhat more stick-to-the-course one, too: https://www.strava.com/routes/3519551092651038884

u/MC_NYC — 2 months ago
▲ 5 r/CyclingFashion+1 crossposts

Cool LBS, especially for kit

Will be in town for a week, always love checking out the local cycling culture, curious about some good roadie shops, especially with fun shop kit/caps/bidon/etc. the kinda place the Cycling Fashion Pod boys might hang out y'know? Thanks.

reddit.com
u/MC_NYC — 2 months ago

No more pleading traffic tickets online?

Am I just misremembering, and you always had to call to plead not guilty to a ticket and get a court date, or did they somehow make the system less digital and user-friendly? Or am I just not seeing it/getting old?

reddit.com
u/MC_NYC — 3 months ago

Ivory Silk Japanese Lilac with bare spots

The city planted one of these in front of our house, we were thrilled but the push for more street trees, and we really looked forward to it's blooms in the late spring. It's about three or four years in.

This year, however, many of the branches seem to have died, with very few blossoms and limited foliage.

We live in Northern New Jersey, where it's been very dry the past two years, and we also had that very long freeze this winter. Wondering what the causes might be, anything we can do to address the issue, and if the tree is slowly dying or can it be saved?

u/MC_NYC — 3 months ago

Making room for saddle bag?

Dumb question maybe probably: I have this saddle bag, I really like it and don't want to get a new one to go with my saddle (or a new saddle, though this one was stock with the bike, so I'm less attached to it).

Issue is, the bag has a fidlock closure, which doesn't fit through the narrow plastic gap. Anyone know if there's metal under there for the rail, and could I carve out a little of the plastic on the inside? Or is it probably all plastic and structural and designed just with metal base rails to save weight?

Pretty sure it's this saddle, I guess I could try and just replace, given the steep discount now...

u/MC_NYC — 3 months ago

So much for Baby Boba...

I know people have talked about how good Lil Fett'll be, he just needs a lil more support. Well, this is definitely "a little"...

u/MC_NYC — 4 months ago

So (how) should the leakees be punished?

Feels like a one-time suspension from Galactics would put a stop to this? I'm definitely in the bummed camp, not only for all the hard work lost by so many, but also I thought it would be cool to see what the "pros" came up with on short notice.

We don't have all the details, so maybe it was a legit mistake of some kind, like a misdirected email... But it also seems like, from the way it's been handled, really does seem like people were actively studying and sharing cards. Whereas if they'd do the honest thing, and just immediately notified FFG, we probably wouldn't be in this place.

There's always the risk they could tell them they didn't see the cards when they actually saved a copy and started studying them, but, well, I guess you'd just hope people were better.

Then again, we're living in the 2026 timeline, so I guess not??

reddit.com
u/MC_NYC — 4 months ago

Math Skillz! (Or, don't forget Revan's lightsabers have Grit...)

Thought I'd turned things around when I dropped my Lawbringer on 6 and was ready with the Turbolaser. He still had a 2/2 Assassin and 2/1 Tyranus. Deploys Maul, sabers him up... and passes. No idea what he's thinking, I shoot my shot... and turn Maul into a one-shot devil.

Kudos to my opponent for the flex. I've forgotten about that grit a few times, but not again. Not that there was a lot I coulda done anyway, I think.

u/MC_NYC — 5 months ago
▲ 14 r/Karoo

K3 backs more fragile, or just me??

This is my second one, after the first was replaced with the exact same issue. No contact, I want to say they're just snapping when twisting them out somehow, though this time I didn't even notice any cracks, just that it was gone. Happened only within a few hundred miles of use, too. Had my K2 for years with zero issues, too... Whole reason I got the new one was I like them so much, I wanted better battery and screen

u/MC_NYC — 5 months ago

Edit: Typo in title, "stay" should be "seat."

I feel like I kick myself every time when I finally get it on, but from watching Calvin's videos and others, it seems like both beads should be in the center channel. But I've been wrestling with this for over an hour, and wondering if I need to get the other side seated first.

Pirelli 30 TLR Race RS... The 32 wasn't nearly this bad, but I guess that makes sense given the little bit of extra circumstance? (Have to run a little skinnier in back.)

u/MC_NYC — 6 months ago