

Banhoff Case: has street photography become irreconcilable with today’s culture of consent and increasing political correctness?
The photographer Ray Banhoff is at the center of controversy over photos taken of thousands of women on the streets of Milan. His series "Fie," created in 2015, consists of three thousand shots of women unaware they were being photographed. While the project went unnoticed at the time of its publication, things are very different today. An investigation by AesteticaSovietica invited the women involved to come forward, bringing to the center of public discussion the tension between the artistic practice of street photography and the culture of consent.
Street photography, which aims to capture subjects in real, spontaneous situations in public spaces in order to highlight aspects of everyday society, often borders on outright voyeurism, verging on stalking. A famous example is Sophie Calle's "Suite Vénitienne" from 1983. For months, the photographer followed and photographed a man from Paris to Venice. Her investigation is both methodical, calling every hotel, visiting the police station, and arbitrary, following another stranger hoping someone might lead her to him.
Banhoff and Calle represent two ways of inhabiting the same gray zone between artistic gaze and invasion of privacy, one that today's culture of consent pushes us to question with eyes very different from those of ten, or forty, years ago.