Some updated Bard stuff after a lot more testing. Follow up to a guide I posted a while ago.
I made a post a while ago about general bard stuff, you can check it out here. Now that it's not beta and I've had more time to play on live and max out more stuff there are a few changes I have to my recommended Symphonic Aura if you are a melee focused damage combo and a few other things. I'm Clr/Mnk/Brd for reference so most of my damage is coming from melee + the dot melody.
First the actual SA lineup I've been using. Chant of Battle, Verses of Victory, One of the AoE slows (your choice, dot one for more damage less slow, or more slow no dot), Psalm of Mystic Shielding (or Shield of Songs, or Niv's Melody), Amplification.
I used to always use Katta's, the dex song, the biggest thing is that the dex boost from Katta's is not worth it at all on bosses. After doing a ton of d3/d4 runs on all the bosses their resistances are so high that at 150 dex or 350+ dex you are still only landing maybe 3 procs the entire fight. The dex debuff proc on it is fine on the few encounters that proc (like EoV if you can get it to land) but in general it's just not worth it unless they make changes to procs/dex. Katta's is fine against less resistant non boss mobs if you want to proc more. But generally it doesnt seem worth it unless there are changes made to procs in general. This is also dependent on your procs, it could be better in certain situations like if you are using the cleric mana regen proc mace or something not focused on damage / resist checks. Personally I think this is something the devs need to take a look at and rebalance (procs in general + their effectiveness on high level raid targets).
Why Verses of Victory over Jonathans Provocation?
With end game gear you don't need the extra haste, and Verses will stack with Chant of Battle like Jonathan's Whistling Warsong did while leveling. If you are melee the Str and AC is worth more than pretty much any other song you can stack with the haste songs.
Why Chant of Battle?
I think some people miss out on using this later because its such a low level song and they dont realize it scales so much at 50 with AA's and instruments. If you are melee focused it's a huge str and ac boost and it stacks with Verses of Victory.
Why Amplification?
You don't have to use it if melee is your focus (you absolutely should if you are doing DDD aoe clearing though), Verses and Mystic shielding will both get a boost from it. With Amp+Mystic Shielding I'm sitting at around 290 spell resist with my gear (still get hit a lot though lmao, so is it worth it? idk). I've generally found most alternatives to be sub par, such as...
Why no Regen?
This is gonna be subjective, the amounts you get with regen songs out of combat are great because they are effectively doubled. In combat it's really going to depend more on your gear and DPS and how long you are actually in combat for. If you are running out of mana you are probably better off taking Cassindra's Elegy over mana regen, esp if you have a wis caster with bard. The overall mana pool boost is very large, and you would have to be in combat a very long time to get the equivalent amount of mana through regen. If upgrading regen songs actually boosted their regen they would totally be worth using all the time. In general I feel like an upgraded cat necklace is a better choice.
What other stuff is good in SA? What's not good?
Song of Shields can be really good in more melee focused fights, same with the various damage shields. Psalm of Warmth / Cooling can be nice on the dragons instead of Mystic Shielding. Cassindra's Elegy is awesome if you want a bigger mana pool. Again I don't think regen in combat is worth it but that's going to be more dependent on your combo and what you are fighting. It's pretty easy to calculate how much benefit per tick you are going to get, get the timing of your fights through a parser, and then see what the benefit actually is. Again this is going to be a bit combo dependent, since I have cleric in my combo health regen is pointless, and I almost never come close to running out of mana even on d3/d4 bosses with my gear so Elegy is pointless too. Rizlona's Embers is a good choice if you have a combo that actually has some DD to choose from, mine doesn't so I just ignore it.
What's worth upgrading?
Slows, Dots, DDD (it gets a damage boost but no mana cost reduction), Charm. None of the buffs are really worth upgrading from my testing.
SA enable / disable macros?
So its possible to set up a macro to disable SA and melody songs that normally would be in SA to essentially twist more than 5 SA compatible songs. This has nothing to do with melodying dots/slow, this is basically if you want to bypass the 5 SA song limit. So is it worth it? No not really imo, there aren't enough extra SA compatible songs that actually stack to make the hassle worth it. If you are going to do it then I guess Amplification is a good one to do it with since it lasts longer than other SA songs even without upgrades, but again it feels like more hassle than its worth. It's not like you can use this to stack multiple damage shields, or even most of your resist buffs. You can get in an extra dot or slow or a regen, but this takes even more space on your bar. In my combo I only have 2 cleric spells on my bar, everything else is bard, and I just dont think anything is worth swapping out to do this. It will be even worse if you have other casters in your combo. You can try it out but I think it doesnt work well enough and makes playing the class more annoying.
Any other stuff?
It's unfortunate Ervaj doesn't bypass the global haste cap, it really should because it's essentially pointless in EQL, which is kinda terrible for a level 50 song (devs, take a look at this!). I probably forgot some other stuff.
Check out my previous post if you are a new bard. If you aren't a new bard post about your combo with bard here, what you are using, what seems to work and what doesnt. I know lots of people are very committed to using regen in combat, so I'd love to hear why it works for you vs some of the other stuff i mentioned.
Happy singing :)