u/SpongeGuy11

Being that the late 2000s were a transitional time for the Nicktoons as they started to get more short-lived post-2006 (likely due to Cyma Zarghami coming in at that time) in favor of more SpongeBob (not an insult to that show, only saying others shouldn't have been sacrificed for the sponge), what are your thoughts on the late 2000s era for the Nicktoons?

I threw in TUFF Puppy and Planet Sheen also since they were technically the last Nicktoons greenlit before the logo change (both greenlit in June 2009, before the logo change in September of that year).

Notably, this era is where the Nicktoons got screwed over faster and more frequently (compared to before where it'd usually take longer for shows to be screwed over), with TUFF Puppy and The Penguins of Madagascar being the only shows in this batch to get more than 2 seasons (but TUFF Puppy also got the most episodes burnt off there with 28 out of 60 half hours on Nicktoons Network) and Rugrats Pre-School Daze being the only one not sent to Nicktoons Network to die at any point (though getting burnt off at 6 AM unadvertised isn't exactly better). Reception for the shows in this batch back in the day also ranged from mixed to outright negative, but time's passed since then.

It's no secret that my first attempt at this didn't work out so well, not helped with not having enough history on Reddit to gain the momentum and the posts getting taken down by the mods on this subreddit, forcing me to use the less known r/cartoons with less traffic. However, it's been 10 months and I feel I can try again this time and see if this works.

Inspired by u/No-Shoulder3918 's community tier list for Nicktoons, thought I'd take a shot with Cartoon Network originals, especially in light of what's been going on recently for the channel.

Rules:

1. Most upvoted comment decides the show's spot on the list. Please think carefully and fairly before you comment. Try not to let nostalgia or recency bias cloud your judgement.
2. Each tier goes as follows: S= Amazing, A= Great, B= Good, C= Okay/Meh, D= Mediocre, E= Bad and F= Terrible.
3. Only originals recognized by this wiki are counted. Meaning no Canadian imports like Total Drama and Johnny Test or WBA shows like Teen Titans Go, Tom & Jerry, Scooby Doo, and Looney Tunes will be in this.

Considering they are immortal and how long they were together (for about a decade by the time of Fionna & Cake), do you all think Bubblegum and Marceline ever thought of getting married?

We know in the Dark Danny timeline, Vlad did genuinely reform and feel remorseful for his antagonistic actions. But did that start happening before or after Dark Danny's birth?

Notably with Jack and Maddie being dead in the timeline, Vlad's motivations are pretty much rendered pointless (the man he's tried to get rid of his dead and the woman he's in love with his dead) so it isn't as if he had much of an antagonistic goal to have after Jack and Maddie died so it is up there if he genuinely did feel sympathy for even Jack dying for real in that timeline before Dark Danny was formed.

Being considered a pretty weak tenth anniversary special, the worst received of the animated TV movies, and one of the episodes that signaling how bad the decline was getting, how would you all have improved this tenth anniversary special?

Inspired by one post on the pre-SpongeBob Nicktoons here: https://www.reddit.com/r/nickelodeon/comments/1sh1s1h/comment/ojyy39w/?context=3

Given how 1000th Chopper Flight Party did have Mordecai and Margaret finally being able to hang out as friends without romantic drama anymore and CJ being cool with Margaret at the start of the episode because of the events of I See Turtles, what would've happened if CJ hadn't shown up to the party or hadn't snapped so harshly at seeing Mordecai and Margaret hanging out and assuming Margaret was trying to steal Mordecai from her?

Notably it is because of that Margaret ended up lying about having a boyfriend, leading into the events of Not So Great Double Date where things get more awkward after CJ finds out Margaret lied about that and still has feelings for Mordecai and then in turn leading them to be in more awkward terms by Dumped at the Altar, which does push Mordecai into the infamous speech at the wedding that led him to get dumped by CJ (not defending what Mordecai did, just bringing up the build up that led to Mordecai getting to that point at all even if doing it at Muscle Man's wedding was pretty bad).

But if CJ hadn't shown up to the party or at least had been a lot more calm instead of attacking Mordecai and Margaret in the episode, would things be better between CJ and Mordecai & Margaret? Would CJ and Mordecai have never broken up or would something else have happened?