Stuck between the girl I like and the girl who likes me (and we’re all in the same friend group)
I’m 18, female, and in college. A lot of people from my high school ended up at the same university, so I still see people who graduated before me pretty often.
There are three people involved in this situation. First, Anna. She’s one year older than me, and we didn’t really know each other in high school. We might have said hi a few times, but that’s it. Now we have a class together, and she’s actually the one who introduced me to her friend group. I currently have a crush on her. Then there’s Emma, who is also one year older and in my major. We played soccer together for a few years, and we’ve gotten closer recently. Lastly, there’s Messi, who is my childhood friend. Our families are close, although we don’t see each other much anymore since she studies outside Puerto Rico. My cousin is still very close to her and is the one who tells me things.
For context, everyone involved is into girls. I’m bisexual, Emma is probably bisexual, Anna says she doesn’t like labels but is attracted to girls, and Messi is a lesbian.
Here’s where things get complicated. Apparently, back in high school, Messi and Emma were secretly together on and off the whole time. During that same period, Messi had a crush on me but never acted on it because she didn’t like that she felt that way. Also, Emma initially didn’t like me, but that eventually turned into a crush. Nothing ever happened, though, because of her situation with Messi. I had no idea about any of this at the time.
Now in college, I joined Anna’s friend group, since she introduced me. As I got closer to her, I started developing feelings and even thought about confessing. I asked my cousin to subtly find out through Messi if Anna might like me. Instead, I found out that Anna’s feelings are unclear—she “doesn’t know.” But on the same day, Emma had apparently told Messi that she likes me, although she doesn’t want to make things awkward.
Now I feel really confused. I’ve liked Anna for a while. She’s more shy, but we’ve had moments like studying one-on-one, sitting really close, even touching legs sometimes, and she’s asked me about my past relationships. I feel like there might be something there, but I’m not sure if I’m just reading into it. On the other hand, Emma and I have always been more naturally comfortable and touchy, and I used to have a crush on her before. Now that I know she likes me, I feel like my feelings for her might be coming back, or getting stronger.
So I don’t know what to do. I don’t know if I should go for Anna, who I’ve liked for longer but might not like me back, or Emma, who I know likes me, but I’m not sure how strong my feelings actually are.
What would you do?