I (24M) think I’m in love with someone I don’t even like (22F)
Tl:dr: My ex broke up with me and came back. Now I still have feelings for her but we’re not very compatible. I need to chose between her and another girl with whom I’m very compatible, but who I do not love yet
My ex broke up with me about a year and a half ago. We had been together for two years and were very much in love. Obviously, I dated casually after the breakup and recently became FWBs with a new girl. The new girl is smart, pretty, fun to talk to, shares my interests, and the physical connection is incredible.
Until recently though, she was clear that she didn’t want it to be anything exclusive, so when my ex reached out to say that she missed me, I started talking to her again. (In fact, they both know about each other, so I’m not betraying either one’s trust). All of a sudden, everything that ever bothered me about my ex hit me all at once. She’s gorgeous and she’s kind, but she doesn’t share my interests, can’t solve her own problems, is passively self centered, the physical connection is nil, and is just generally a little air-headed.
This should make my choice simple, but here’s the problem. The new girl, has decided that she wants to be exclusive with me if I decide not to get back with my ex. I have so much fun with her and I like her a lot, but I don’t miss her when she’s gone and I don’t feel my heart race when I see her. The old girl annoys the hell out of me but I still get excited when she calls and I think it’s entirely possible I might still love her.
Both of them realize that they’ve put me in a difficult position, so they’re willing to wait and let me figure it out, but obviously I don’t want to prolong it. I just find myself oscillating from one to the other on a near daily basis. What do I do?