AITA for quitting or should I have been more patient because I loved him?
To this day, I still feel guilty. My whole life I’ve been told that I’m too harsh with people, too impatient, and that I expect someone who’s perfect, with no past. Because of that, I keep wondering if I was cruel. I really liked him, and sometimes I wonder if I should have been more patient, stayed by his side, and helped him deal with what seemed like an emotional dependency on his ex instead of simply leaving and cutting off contact.
Late last year, I (B, 32M, gay) met M (35M) on Tinder. His profile said he was looking for a serious relationship and described himself as a loyal person. Things started off really well: we spent hours gaming together, watching shows online, and after a few weeks we decided to meet in person (we lived in nearby cities).
From our very first date, one thing caught my attention: his best friend was his ex-boyfriend, J.
He told me their relationship had been dysfunctional, that they had never actually had sex because they were both into the same sexual role, and that he had been the one to end things more than five years earlier. At first, I tried to overlook it. But little by little, I realized J came up in almost every conversation. 🚩 If I brought up any topic, somehow J became part of the story. Things around the house, shared accounts, memories, gifts… everything seemed connected to him. Even the conditioner I borrowed was “J’s conditioner.” The volleyball belonged to both of them. One of his streaming accounts depended on J’s password. There was an entire room full of J’s belongings. 🚩
Despite all of that, M treated me incredibly well. He cooked for me, welcomed me into his home with my dog, was affectionate and attentive, always asked for my opinion, made plans for us, even bought me my own shampoo so I’d have one at his house. He invited me to spend Christmas and New Year’s with his family, and our relationship also became physical. At one point, he even lay on the floor of my apartment and told me he’d never felt this way about anyone before.
I kept wondering whether this was simply an unusually close friendship or whether my own past experiences were making me overly suspicious.
Around Christmas, after about two months together, I decided to talk to him. I told him I didn’t believe they were still romantically involved, but that J occupied an enormous space in his life. I said that if that space was already filled, I couldn’t understand what my place was supposed to be.
M agreed. He admitted I was right, told me other people had walked away for the exact same reason 🚩, and asked me for a few days to make some changes.
A few days later, I asked why a card from J was still prominently displayed in his bedroom. He replied that if I was going to get upset every time J’s name came up, things would never work, and added that if he’d been drinking, he didn’t know how he’d react to my complaints. 🚩 I answered that if I got upset every time J became the topic of conversation, I’d spend all day upset because he talked about him constantly.
He also told me he didn’t know how J would react to seeing me because J couldn’t handle watching him move on with someone else and tended to compete whenever another guy showed interest in him. 🚩
We kept trying.
A few days later, while he was showing me something on his phone, I noticed Grindr was still installed, even though he’d told me he’d stopped using it after meeting me. He immediately offered to open the app in front of me. I decided to trust him and said it wasn’t necessary.
Then, in the early hours of January 1st, what felt like the final straw happened.
While we were still in bed, during an intimate moment, J called to discuss buying a laptop. M answered the call without hesitation and, during the conversation, even called his former mother-in-law because she was involved in the purchase.
I knew M already knew what the call was about because before we had sex he’d shown me something on his phone, and I’d seen a notification from J about the laptop. (For the record, I never went through his phone and never knew his password.)
That was the moment I realized the situation was much bigger than I’d thought.
We barely spoke afterward. He insisted they were just friends. I replied that I’d never seen a friendship like that in my life.
The next morning, he went to Pilates as if nothing had happened. While he was gone, I quietly started packing my things. His sister-in-law noticed and came to talk to me. I explained that I wasn’t even his boyfriend yet, but I also knew I never would be because I couldn’t accept that dynamic.
That’s when she told me the entire family disliked J, that the relationship had isolated M from friends and relatives, and that even five years after the breakup, I was the first person they’d seen him genuinely trying to build a future with.
When M came back, he logged into work as if nothing had happened. Later he came into the bedroom and started crying, but he couldn’t say anything. He was completely unable to have a conversation. I tried talking to him, but at that exact moment J called again.
M didn’t answer because I was visibly furious, but he defended J anyway. He told me I needed to understand that they were friends and that J already knew we’d argued and was panicking because he was afraid of losing their friendship. Controlling, don’t you think?
I called an Uber to another city because there were no buses available, grabbed my dog, and left. He didn’t try to stop me.
Before I walked out, he admitted he felt guilty whenever he got involved with someone else because J couldn’t accept him moving on, even after five years.
I thought that was the end of the story.
But his sister-in-law kept messaging me, and honestly, that only confused me. I probably shouldn’t have listened.
She said the whole family agreed with me, that M had started throwing away J’s belongings, returning his things, and finally setting boundaries.
A few days later, though, everything changed. According to her, J contacted him again, they became close once more, and M went right back to being confused. She also said he now believed I was the controlling one.
The few conversations M and I had afterward were strange. Instead of talking about us, he only talked about J. He said I’d never understand how important J was because he’d been there during his illness, throughout the pandemic, and during one of the loneliest periods of his life. He admitted he probably needed to change that relationship, but not because he personally believed it was unhealthy—only because everyone else kept telling him so.
When I told him I was falling in love with him, he replied that he couldn’t say he was in love with me.
He did say he missed me.
That was when I realized there was no point in continuing.
He later reached out saying he first needed to rebuild his own life, make new friends, and figure out what he actually wanted. I suggested therapy. I told him it seemed like both his relationship with J and his relationship with me were driven by fear of loss rather than genuine choice, and that since he wasn’t in love with me, it would be easier for both of us to end things there.
He didn’t reply for hours.
I deleted his contact.
A few minutes after noticing my profile picture had disappeared, he sent me a voice message saying I’d misunderstood everything, that he just needed a few weeks to sort out his head, and that afterward maybe he’d want to try again—or maybe we’d just be friends. He said he felt pressured.
I never replied.
I blocked him everywhere.
The very next day, one of my friends saw him back on Grindr and Tinder.
That was months ago.
I don’t want him back, and I have no intention of contacting him again. But almost every day, I still think about this story and wonder why.
My whole life I’ve been told that I’m too harsh with people, that I lack patience, and that I expect someone with no baggage. That makes me question my own judgment and leaves me feeling insecure about the decisions I make.
What would you have done in my situation?
Please, I genuinely want to hear different opinions. I’ve tried my best not to tell this story in an overly biased way.