Is it worth moving to a job with higher layoff risk if it means better career growth?
I’m looking to transition to a new team within my company. The pay is better and it would be a title promotion so already it’s a no brainer to move teams. However I suspect my manager is trying to make a case for my promotion and increased pay behind to scenes to keep me on my current team. If I receive a counter offer, I’m a little torn on what to do.
I am a well respected designer in my current sector of the business. I have a lot of great rapport. I’m in a situation where I can mostly do whatever I want because I’ve built this respect. I also work on a fairly stable product with minimal layoff risk. It’s a niche and well established product in the market. Also a HUGE money maker. But the product itself has horrible UX, which theoretically should mean I have a lot of exciting work, but the reason for the horrible UX is primarily related to the framework the product is built on. This has been the biggest challenge for our sector for the business and it’s become increasingly frustrating as I’m asked to work on projects that I know are terrible UX because the technical constraints do not support the vision we are being asked to execute.
Additionally, over the past 5 years I’ve only worked on 1 project that’s been released to customers. And the part of the project that I worked on has not been used, at all. Nobody likes it. When doing usability testing we constantly get bad feedback and discover bugs. This isn’t a design issue, it’s an engineering problem with the framework. I can only do so much with the constraints we have, and every time I raise a flag about the constraints I’m told we don’t have the engineering hours to improve it. To provide an example of limitations, we can’t even build a “select all” checkbox. The framework is not dynamic or interactive. It was not originally created to support UI and now it’s the direction the company is asking us to go. I’m ashamed that this is the only released product my name is attached to. I’ve worked on a lot of other projects that are on a slightly better framework in the system and have very positive feedback during testing, but their slated release is the end of 2027 with delays highly likely. Others are on versions for 2028+. And these were projects I did 2+ years ago.. The slow release cycle makes it difficult to know how to iterate and make improvements to my designs. I feel blind with every new feature.
The new team I’d be transition to works on a different product built with a MUCH better framework. But they definitely have higher layoff risk. They act quick and have made some mistakes that led to failed products and laid off teams to start with a fresh perspective. That said, the work actually gets released. In general, the quicker release cycle would help me grow as a designer because I’d be able to track the success of a designed feature and make iterations. The work also would be able to be presented in a portfolio because it’s actually released. In the event that I did get laid off, I feel like I’d be a much stronger candidate for new roles.
I’m just torn about leaving my current team. The increased pay is worth the layoff risk, but if my team gives me a counter offer to stay I’m just not sure if it’s the right move. I know the job market is horrible right now. So being laid off in a year or two would be terrible. But I worry my current team is not providing me growth as a designer and if things do go downhill then I’d be in a worse situation by staying.
For those who’ve been in similar situations, would you take the stable but stagnant job? Or go for a risk that would produce more tangible work and offer more growth?