![Image 1 — [Review] My take on these two sunscreens.](https://preview.redd.it/ynbz4dbwutah1.jpg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=729ad89dc895edcdfaf6bddf3ab05b3e2440dbc0)
![Image 2 — [Review] My take on these two sunscreens.](https://preview.redd.it/gkm8zs0xutah1.jpg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=71427e3b34872bedb706e22004af38f2f21e3041)
![Image 3 — [Review] My take on these two sunscreens.](https://preview.redd.it/xltczgoxutah1.jpg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=be249194fe0a3eaca9062c9148a6a6258026209f)
![Image 4 — [Review] My take on these two sunscreens.](https://preview.redd.it/n76cijcyutah1.jpg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b70749856e4c5c413092340c0297903a00a2316a)
![Image 5 — [Review] My take on these two sunscreens.](https://preview.redd.it/lcppitzyutah1.jpg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=440892cde1f10ef415189e95738c2c53ce41a667)
[Review] My take on these two sunscreens.
Hi all, so I initially posted this on r/EuroSkincare as both sunscreens I am reviewing are French brands but I thought this would also be worth sharing here as well!
I will preface that this won't be the most exciting or praiseful (if that's even a word) review of the sunscreens, but it is quite honest.
Disclaimer❗️ This review is based solely on my personal experiences with these products. Everyone's skin is different, has different preferences, and reacts differently to each product. Please keep this in mind ❤️ Either way, I would love to hear your opinions on these products, especially if you have tried them before.
Anyways, here we go. About my skin.
Sisley: Super Soin Solaire SPF 50+
TLDR: Felt sticky and heavy, didn’t absorb well. Did fine in terms of sun protection and didn’t leave any white casts. Overall, I don’t recommend it, especially if you have combination / oily skin, or will sweat a lot.
Pros: Did its job at sun protection, didn’t irritate skin, and didn’t leave a white cast.
Cons: Texture was really heavy and sticky. Felt oily, even in the winter. In the summer, it felt way too oily and didn’t allow my skin to breathe well. Sat on my skin (rather than absorbed). Difficult to cleanse off.
Recommended? Based on my experiences, no.
Comments:
- I felt like this sunscreen was really heavy and it sat on my skin rather than getting absorbed by it. This came to me as a surprise, since it was marketed as non-comedogenic, so I expected more lightweightness and absorbency. I have been an avid Sisley user and have always invested into their pricey products – I absolutely love the cleanser and serum from the Tropical Resins line, which worked brilliantly on my combination skin and felt really lightweight. However, this sunscreen was a bit of a let down with its sticky feeling… and definitely felt like a waste of money. Because it felt so heavy and sticky, it also felt impossible to wash off, even with a micellar water double-cleanse. You probably need an oil double cleanse as this product felt oil-heavy (I just couldn’t do that as I had a lash lift).
- In terms of protection, it did pretty well. I used it after getting laser treatment for pigmentation on my face, and I didn’t develop new sun spots or anything. It kept me well protected. It did not leave a white cast. It also didn’t directly cause break outs or irritation, it just felt awful on my skin texture-wise… which is still a big deal for me as sunscreen texture is what makes me want to keep using or stop using sunscreen!
- To make myself feel less bad about not wasting money (and not throwing the product out, even if I want to) I ended up “using up” the rest of the sunscreen tube on my body instead. Even on my legs, it felt really heavy and sticky, and I felt like I had to wash my legs down with soap twice to get it off! I understand it is water-resistant, but I think this might be a step too far for me.
- I get it if sunscreens want to be "moisturizing," but the moisture didn’t even get down into my skin. It kinda just sat on top of it, which is why I felt like this sunscreen was a bit of a texture torture. It already felt this way when I used it in cold, dry winters, and it felt even worse in summer weather – so heavy that I had to stop using it on my face, as when I got sweaty… yeah, no. I don’t wear make up, but I can imagine that this won’t benefit people who wear make up or sweat a lot. Which kind of defies the point of using sunscreen in the hot and sweaty summer weather…
- I can’t speak for people with dry skin, but with the way that it “sits” on skin instead of getting into it (at least in my experience) I don’t know if I can recommend it for those with dry skin either. I would be interested to hear from others about their opinions on this sunscreen if they’ve used it before!
Caudalie: Very High Protection Lightweight Cream SPF 50+
TLDR: It does feel lightweight, but it leaves my skin oily and shiny for the rest of the day.
Pros: Did its job at sun protection, didn’t irritate skin, and didn’t leave a white cast. Feels lightweight upon application.
Cons: Makes skin oily!
Recommended? Based on my experience, not for oily or combination skin. Maybe those with other skin types have more of a shot with this one?
Comments:
- With this product, I initially felt more hopeful, especially upon initial application. I tested it out at the mall where I bought it, and it felt lightweight and easy to spread. That also was the case when I bought it and used it on my face: it felt lightweight and easy to spread. However, there’s a caveat: lightweight products don’t mean they can’t get oily!
- This sunscreen, in my experience, got my face and t-zone really oily really fast! I would find myself using oil blotting papers many times a day, and my face would go back to being shiny again. I don’t know what is causing this, as it didn’t feel as heavy as the Sisley product. It didn’t feel as bad as the Sisley one, though, especially when I sweat – thanks to its lightweightness. But it didn’t stop the oil or shine on my t-zone, and only made it worse. I actually read up other reviews online, and others with combination skin also shared similar experiences. I guess I’m not alone with my experience with this product. I can’t imagine myself wearing makeup over this sunscreen as I’d be scared that it would melt off from the oiliness it has caused!
- Would be interested to hear from others who have tried this product (and your skin type)!
Note
For those who wonder about the product ingredients, I won't post it here as products can vary regionally. I suggest you look it up for your region. I bought the Sisley sunscreen at the airport duty free store in Hong Kong, while I bought the Caudalie sunscreen in the EU -- if you are curious about the ingredients in the products that I used.
Secondly, Caudalie does produce a *body* sunscreen spray that I like. That one has been fine for me, granted, I never used it on my face. I’m still on the hunt for a good face sunscreen!
P.S. Sorry for the edit yall, the markdown thing didn't go through the first time.