Mario vs Mickey? NTDOY vs DIS
Disney is trading at a forward P/E of roughly 16x. Historically, Disney has commanded a multiple north of 20x. It is deeply undervalued relative to its historical power because the market is still discounting its legacy linear TV decline and demanding proof that its streaming business (Disney+) can scale its profitability consistently.
Nintendo trades around a 19x P/E. On paper, it looks a bit pricier than Disney, but its balance sheet is legendary. Nintendo carries zero debt and an absolute mountain of cash (over $13 billion). If you strip out that net cash, its enterprise value makes the actual business core look remarkably cheap.
Strictly looking at the stock prices, NTDOY feels like a bargain 50 % cheaper today than just a year ago while DIS is “only” 20 % off in the same timeline.
As for Disney, parks remain a cash machine. Streaming has improved materially. ESPN's direct-to-consumer strategy could unlock value. However, Disney still faces execution risk across streaming, linear TV, and its more leveraged balance sheet.
The Nintendo stock has corrected significantly despite strong early Switch 2 demand, making valuation compelling according to several recent analyses. Nintendo has one of the strongest balance sheets in gaming, with a large cash position and no meaningful long-term debt. Revenue opportunities extend beyond hardware through software, digital sales, movies, and theme-park licensing. But we all know how expensive DRAM, NAND are and recently Nintendo had to hike the prices for Switch 2.
DIS seems to fluctuate between $90-$110 but earnings in May were pretty great hence the historically low P/E.
NTDOY was 100 % higher just a year ago but who knows if it will trade flat for years now. Disney stock did after it crashed five years ago as the boost from Disney+ wore off.
Mickey or Mario? Which stock would you buy for a swing trade and which would you buy for a long term investment?