The witness..
Doesn’t it make more sense from a narrative standpoint that Athan is the witness? Won’t the story hit harder if Athan still becomes the witness despite season 3?
Also the explanation given for Olivia having always been the witness is just not very compelling to me; I’m not sold on the idea that Olivia is meant to be the witness and she becomes the witness only because of the creation of Athan. If she is meant to be the witness, why would Athan even be involved in her story? And all those setups about how special Athan is because he was born out of time and isn’t supposed to have existed are just for nothing after it’s revealed that Athan has never been the witness.
And Olivia isn’t even primary and somehow just gains abilities(I forgot how, I am rewatching and haven’t finished the series) so that she can be the witness. She makes for a good villain but being the big boss just doesn’t seem like her.