Football hasn't taken off in the Philippines because clubs don't play into identity politics
Clubs all over the world play into identity politics: Real Madrid are the rich Castillans, Barca are the club for Catalan nationalists, Liverpool are for the Scouse working class, River Plate are for the rich, Boca Juniors for the poor, Lazio for the fascists, Celtic for Catholics, etc etc. Even clubs in neighboring countries are rooted solely in some type of identity, with regionalism manifesting in Indonesian football: people from Jakarta belong to Persija, while people from Bandung and other West Javanese regions belong to Persib. The people of Surabaya own Persebaya, and the people of Jogja own PSIM.
What's the difference between Manila Digger, Kaya FC, One Taguig, etc? Fucking nothing. Not really. Sure, they have different cities in their names but what have they actually done to endear themselves to their local communities?
This is the real reason why football isn't taking off in this country. You think the average normie watches football because they're looking for crosses, corner kicks, possession? They dgaf about that and if you want football to take off in this country you need to be honest about it.
People watch El Clasico because it's good football, yes, but there's also the layer of it being basically a mini Spanish Civil War everytime they're on the pitch. Atletico Madrid vs Real Madrid is an unspoken class war too.
Honestly I think local clubs should deprioritize technical quality and up community engagement. Get some local boys to play, I'm sure you don't even have to pay them that much, but make sure you're tying it hard to some sort of community.
Imagine a Tsinoy FC. An all-Muslim Bangsamoro football club. A Real Iglesia ni Cristo Starting 11 vs Roman Catholic FC. Then imagine the sparks a Tagalog FC vs Bisaya FC match could ignite. Then the next day the league championship goes down the wire between Tondo FC vs Dasmarinas FC aka all-out class war.
I don't believe any of the other explanations about why football isn't taking off in this country. Boring, low scoring? As if Brazilians or whatever other nationalities have better attention spans. Pang mayaman? I guess Africa and South America don't exist.
The lack of idpol is why.