r/AskIsrael

Is Israel gonna rule the west bank?

I'm Palestinian living in the west bank and I'm really wondering if the current situation and the stuff going on with Israeli police joining the idf in the west bank is leading to Israel ruling this area as well? Wondering where the Oslo people are rn😃

reddit.com
u/Relative_Animal_6946 — 2 hours ago

What are Israelis reactions to the IDFs announcements of the results of criminal probes?

“The incidents being investigated by the Military Police included the killing of 6-year-old Hind Rajab along with six of her family members and two medics in Gaza City in January 2024; and the killing of 15 rescue workers in a convoy of ambulances and emergency vehicles in Rafah in March 2025.

Meanwhile, the cases being closed included a deadly strike on a group of aid workers with the World Central Kitchen organization in the central Gaza Strip in April 2024; a strike on a building used by aid group Doctors Without Borders (MSF) in Khan Younis that killed two members in February 2024; and the deaths of another two MSF employees who were driving in a convoy in Gaza City in November 2023.”

These are all high-profile incidents involving the deaths of Palestinian civilians, aid workers, and others, that have attracted condemnation from Israel’s western allies.

How has this news been received in Israel? Do IDF investigations hold credibility either way (ie, do you feel that a closed case indicates the innocence of Israelis involved, or that an open case indicates a genuine possibility of IDF officers culpability)?

As a secondary question, how is Hind Rajab portrayed in Israeli media? Here in the U.S., it’s difficult to argue that her situation is anything other than tragic and horrifying, and that justice for her death so far remains elusive (although the responsible party is obvious, according to U.S. coverage).

timesofisrael.com
u/Call_Me_Clark — 6 hours ago

Why didn’t all Holocaust survivors immediately move to Mandatory Palestine/Israel when Israel was becoming independent state?

I was anti Israel not that long ago. When I was, I was forcing myself into the mental gymnastics that the Jewish state is somehow a second coming of Nazi Germany, just to fit in ideologically.

Besides it being extremely offensive to Jews as a whole, because it’s Holocaust inversion and it being gross over-exaggeration (and minimizing the uniqueness of the Holocaust). It’s also just absurd in its face, because its a state co-founded by Holocaust survivors and many of its first inhabitants were Holocaust survivors themselves.

Anti-Zionists act like antisemitism is not a thing and actually sounds dumb when they talk about Israel, sounding as if the Holocaust is somehow not important to the people of Israel or its supporters abroad or as if the world without Israel would be fine and dandy for Jews.

But I just did a quick googling and according to Google AI, apparently, only 200,000 of Holocaust survivors moved to Israel in the first few years of its existence (and coups hundreds of thousands more in the upcoming decades). Before the Holocaust, there were about 9,5 million Jews living in Europe. Minus 6 million, that’s ~3 million.

That would mean that once Israel was finally re-established, which Jews waited for since 70 CE (iirc), only about 7% of the Holocaust survivors immediately moved there.

Also, there’s only about 1,5 million Jews living in Europe now. Within 80 years, 1,5 million people could easily be made out of about 500 thousand people or fewer. So my guess is that after the Holocaust, overwhelming majority of survivors must have moved somewhere. Why not all to Israel? I realize that many survivors took refuge in many different countries, but it’s my understanding that these countries didn’t accept that many refugees and they could have moved to Israel afterwards.

I’m asking, because the fact that not that many immediately moved to Israel can serve the anti Zionist narrative, that Israel is actually not that important and that the 200 thousand Jews who moved there could have easily been Jewish supremacists who wanted to create Israel to have their own apartheid ethnostate.

Why didn’t Israel start out with larger population, so to speak? Is there a book about it? Or even a book about Zionism and what was going on in the region during the Holocaust and in the few years surrounding Israeli independence?

reddit.com
u/Proud3GenAthst — 8 hours ago
▲ 788 r/AskIsrael+1 crossposts

Israel confirms it opened fire on vehicle carrying five-year-old Hind Rajab in Gaza. The Israeli military has confirmed for the first time that it opened fire on a vehicle carrying five-year-old Hind Rajab and six members of her family in Gaza City during the war in Gaza

u/ExactlySorta — 12 hours ago

Life in Jerusalem

Is living in Jerusalem desirable among Israelis ?

As I've heared Jerusalem is too crowded too underdeveloped and too poor. And if it wasn't for the religious stuff no one would live there

Is it right ?

reddit.com
u/Ready_Fuel_2739 — 10 hours ago

Can someone explain to me the settler situation? Or just a link that does a good job of it?

You can look at my past comment and post history and know I support Israel as an American.

That said, I don't understand the Israeli settler issue that seems to generate quite a bit of strife and vitriol. It also provides ammunition for people claiming Israel is invading neighboring land such as Gaza and Lebanon for land grabs.

What is the common Israeli perspective on this issue in general? What are the settlers doing, why are they doing it, and how is it viewed in Israel?

Thanks. 🇺🇲🇮🇱🍻

reddit.com

How are interfaith couples perceived in Israel?

I am a Polish-American non practicing guy and my partner was born in Tel Aviv and moved to the US when she was 4 (she's a Reform Jew). We recently just moved in together and our relationship has gotten serious.

When it comes to faith, as I mentioned I'm not super religious at all and my girlfriend is more culturally Jewish (her background especially Israeli background is important to her). The holidays were celebrate is the Jewish holidays (christmas and easter is just another day for both of us) and whenever we spoke about marriage and kids (something we both want) my girlfriend said she would want her kids to be raised Jewish and I said it would be an obligation (and she smiled at that).

We're planning to visit Israel this September (my first time) and I'm curious how to interfaith couples view in Israel? I know my girlfriend's family are very friendly towards me and likes that I stand/support them but generally speaking how are interfaith couples perceived in Israel?

Thank you all for your attention and I wish you all the best, happiness and safety!

עם ישראל חי

reddit.com
u/wedreaminsideadream — 1 day ago

הצעות לבתי כנסת בירושלים?

אני עתיד לבקר בירושלים בקרוב בשבת עם בתי (בת 16), ואני מחפש בית כנסת שבו נוכל לשבת יחד במהלך התפילות.

אשמח לקבל הצעות למקומות הנמצאים במרחק הליכה (~20 דקות) מקמפוס האוניברסיטה בגבעת רם.

תודה רבה!

reddit.com
u/playthegamebwah — 22 hours ago

Could you briefly explain the status of the Russian language in the cities I will list below?

Tel Aviv, Netanya, Eilat, Rishon LeZion, Rehovot, Jerusalem, and Beersheba. Could you divide these cities into several categories (for example, many Russian speakers, a moderate number of Russian speakers, and few Russian speakers) and assign each city from the list to one of them? You don’t have to explain your answer—you can literally answer in just a few words.

reddit.com
u/SNENES442 — 22 hours ago

Raise of Nazism and antisemitism?

I've come across too many comments on Facebook (since I don't have the conventional social media) like "the austrian saw something we didn't" (I saw this comment on various videos) on a video about something Israel-related. Or a video featuring an actual WW2 Nazi conviction, manny comments "thank you for your service", "hero", "legend", "he did a great job". I also saw videos of the hand gesture in front of jewish institutions. Every single comment like that received hundreds of likes.

Alongside the vast support for nazism, I've seen antisemitic things. Kicking out jewish/Israeli people out of places or attacking them. Literally gathering around them and performing verbal and/or physical lynches. Too many attacks abroad lately. Or online humiliations in omegle. It's only legitimate when they're jews.

I feel paralyzed with fear. That those things are now legitimate. Nazism is idolized. Antisemitism is legitimate. And those people can just do it. Mostly europeans and some Arabs.

After that, anti-zionists say "why don't you have empathy for the Palestinians". I wanna see a single palestinian condemns those things first. How do you expect to let those people live among us? No denying that they suffered from the war, but after instigating so much hatred towards - not the government or the IDF - but the unrelated everyday Israeli people - no one can physically feel empathy for them, this emotional capacity is gone. They did everything possible for "it's us or them mentality". And they refused to stop the war (return the hostages), then calling it "a genicide" when Israel tried desperately to release the raped women and defend itself? Gaza shot more rockets at Israel, is it ok because they barely succeeded?

reddit.com
u/Compensate1995 — 1 day ago

If someone wanted to understand Israeli/jewish culture through comedy, where would you tell them to start?

Stand-up, sketches, comedians, old classics, newer stuff, just anything where the humor tells you something about everyday Israeli life.
Bonus if it works for someone whose Hebrew isn’t perfect.

reddit.com

Who is dressed better, Arabs or Israelis?

Male arabs are dressed shick. Jeans, T shirts with nice designs, metal watches. Sneakers or sports shoes. These clothes are fitted well to their body and designed nicely. It's so efforrless and elegant.

The Israelis dress the way they think is "sophisticated" - shirts open at the front like a deep cleavage, button-ups, polos, baggy dress pants, etc. Which doesn't look good. They try to look "european" and "dressy". The look of the half-open shirt and baggy dressed pants that is popular when going out or at events is so off-putting.

What do you think?

Please upvote, so it will drive the algorithm.

reddit.com
u/Compensate1995 — 1 day ago

why should i as a christian syrian living in syria support israel? already a supporter, just wanna learn more🙏🏻🤍.

reddit.com
u/Cainanz — 2 days ago

Israel finally halts all defense exports to Qatar. Why do you think it took so long? To me they seem like lock step with the Muslim Brotherhood, one of the biggest enemies of Israel.

timesofisrael.com
u/Background_Bee_713 — 2 days ago

For Israelis: What do you guys think of the Lior Schleien videos with high school students from around the country ?

reddit.com
u/kgas36 — 2 days ago
▲ 474 r/AskIsrael+1 crossposts

r/Israel Debates Whether Netanhayu Calling the UK The "Islamic republic" is Wrong

"All things considered, he’s a decent leader. I doubt you would do a better job."

A country being upset for being dumped on - imagine that. btw, as a Polish-American I do acknowledge Poland's role during WWII and I believe folks in Poland need to own up. AND as someone who lives in New York City - we have a bigoted mayor (which I didn't vote for) who is a complete disaster and puts my Jewish neighbors at risk. P.S. I stand by Israel! Next month will be my first visit to Israel - I'll be with my gf who has family there and I can't wait to come over! :)

Does England prefer a different name? Like englandistan or something? What’s not offensive?

people literally call it Londonistan now

I mean... Is it rude? Sure Is it heading that way? Absolutely UK would do well to deal less with manners and more with the growing hostile Islamic population

Ohhhh STFU!! I am so tired of their f’ing pearl clutching when someone gives them the raw truth….but yet a Jew wearing a Magen David walking past a crowd of pro-pally homegrown terrorist sympathizers and wannabes report the guy for simply walking past them as harassment when THEY are the actual bullies and the guy wearing the Magen David is the one that ACTUALLY gets arrested! The UK gov can F right off!

Why? Bibi told the truth. UK today and UK 30 years ago are two diffrent things

Why is the PM in the UK mad? Is it an insult to be called Muslim? I want to hear the UK PM say that being called Muslim is an insult. Do it. He can't have it both ways. He can't be proud of his Muslim community and run cover for them and lock people up for being opposed to Islam and then turn around and pretend he thinks Islam is bad. He locks up his own people who think Islam is bad. Embrace it because it's true now.

Multicultural is the politically correct term. Anything else is bigoted.

Bibi has gone full trump. No respect, no class, no grace.

Israel has 18% Muslim compared to 8% in UK

Full disclaimer, I do not support Bibi. At all. Full stop. That said, I genuinely fear for the safety of Jewish people in the UK, and most of Europe for that matter. After seeing Starmer getting ousted for “not being hard enough on Israel” (even though his government recognized Palestine as a state), I fully expect the leaders in the UK to start leaning into the antisemitic sentiment. One example of this is how a UK tribunal said that some forms of “anti-Zionism” are protected speech. The reason I put that in quotes is because one of those forms they declared protected is that “Jews do not face discrimination”. Seriously, they somehow believe that is not antisemitic. I sincerely hope the Jewish people in the UK find a way out before it’s too late.

Muslims are 6% of the UK population. If your statement is true (I couldn't find a reputable source for that) it means that 2% of the UK population are making it a "Islamic Republic".

They’re more upset about this than the Gilders Green stabbing. Deeply unserious leadership.

I’m confused - is it unacceptable or untrue?

If I'm not mistaken, Muhammed is by far the most common boy's name in the UK. Has been for over a decade.

But it’s absolutely true. They need to fully come to terms with that.

Feels casually antisemitic here too, tbh. Though never quite as bad as it seems when out in the wild ✌️

I mean it's not a republic.

Wow, it sure is offensive to have your country falsely accused of something, innit, gov'na?

reddit.com
u/Beekeeper0477 — 4 days ago

Does this article give an accurate presentation of what Israeli women are like?

https://www.jpost.com/j-spot/article-735440

I don’t know if the Jerusalem Post have a good reputation when it comes to studies like this one.

In particular, the following caught my attention:

> Almost half of the Israeli women in today's society believe that they need to play "hard to get" at the beginning, with the number increasing among women around 40-51 years old.

> "Although most women report that they hate playing games and even more so when men play games, they still feel they have to do it," Dr. Margalit said. "This means that often, women feel that they are not allowed to communicate their desires directly.

> Many women (60%), are afraid of making the first move due to their fears of presenting themselves as desperate. And when it comes to their personal values or opinions, 23% of women are afraid that the other person would judge them harshly and think they are overly opinionated or direct.

I always heard it’s the opposite in Israel. I heard that it’s not uncommon for Israeli women to approach their crushes first, and that hiding one’s feeling is a non-existent phenomenon in Israeli culture.

The article also admits that the AI was used:

> Dr. Margalit conducted the research by using a panel supported by artificial intelligence (AI) to collect data on responses from over 500 Israeli women about their experiences, focusing on relationships between men and women.

u/True-Medium-5928 — 2 days ago