r/AskModerators

Are there enforceable guidelines to prevent bad moderation practices?

Are there enforceable guidelines to prevent bad moderation practices?

I recently had an unfortunate exchange with a moderator and it raised some questions, namely: are mods free to curate subreddits as they see fit, irrespective of the subreddit's rules? Is there any meaningful and approved method to raise concerns about moderators who users believe are using moderation powers maliciously?

I have censored the subreddit and the title which contained the OP's username, which was apparently (wrongly) assumed to be my alt. I am not seeking any action to be taken on my behalf. I am trying to understand if Reddit condones this manner of responding to genuine respectful inquiries, and if not, how can users flag bad practices within the platform's rules?

Censored interaction - no subreddit or mod info

u/d3ath222 — 6 hours ago

Do mods have tools to link multiple accounts to a person?

Do reddit mods have tools they use to link multiple reddit accounts to a person, or how are they able to link someone who has multiple accounts?

reddit.com
u/gryponyx — 21 hours ago

What's with this notification about a survey of experiences as a mod?

it's signed "Reddit Research Team" and includes a link, supposedly to the survey. Maybe I'm overly cautious, but it seems a bit suspect. Is it legit?

reddit.com
u/NoCard753 — 1 day ago

How do I remove a comment from queue if it was removed by Reddit itself?

So in a subreddit that I co-mod in, sometimes I would see in the queue ‘comment been removed by Reddit’. But I can’t manually remove it from the queue like normal post.

What should I do? Also, I am on mobile.

reddit.com
u/NoPianist7807 — 21 hours ago

Why do My posts get removed for being "AI" when everything is typed by myself?

I hope I'm not alone in this, because this happens 50% of the time i post on other subs

reddit.com
u/Unfair-Plane-1406 — 1 day ago

Why does Reddit allow mods to abuse power?

A subreddit has no rule against posting outside information. I had posted info gathered from the FLA Dept of Agriculture as proof, the reason that systemic pesticidess are used, and how to safely use them, and BOOM, lifetime ban...no warning...no 3 day ban, but for life...on my 3rd post.

The Mod also quoted "Reddit Admin team":

"Reminder from the Reddit Admin team: If you use another account to circumvent this community ban, that will be considered a violation of the Reddit Rules and may result in your account being banned from the platform as a whole."

When there is no rule in the Reddit Rules about this. I reported it as impersonation.

But hey, abusing the Reddit Moderator Code of Conduct is lax. There are no rules against what I did, it was directly related to the topic, and when I asked why, the Mod gave me an obtuse answer that was a non answer.

Why is this type of abuse allowed on Reddit?

There are no rules against what I did; it was directly related to the topic, and when I asked why, the Mod gave me an obtuse answer that was a non-answer.

Mod CoC: Rule 2

  • Creating rules that explicitly outline your expectations for members of your community.

Is this a joke or? The post was not deleted; it is still up.

reddit.com
u/pwrslm — 1 day ago

As a moderator, what bot do you wish was available on devvit for your community?

It could be anything , I am looking to build one, it could be also be that you want to use a bot that does not exist on devvit but only on PRAW and I could migrate it to devvit.

This is for a hackathon btw and all suggestions are appreciated

reddit.com
u/Single_Pension_7027 — 2 days ago

Why Can Blocked Moderator Accounts Still DM People?

I blocked several Mod accounts from a sub and still received DMs from them. Why is this possible?

I was not banned. In fact, I muted their sub.

Edit: We criticize the Mods enough that if it is us, we should admit it. This one was on me. Sorry guys. I'm the AH here.

reddit.com
u/Maximum_Vegetable_MV — 2 days ago

There's a subreddit which has a mod who's been banned on multiple accounts for CSAM and nonconsensual nudes. The mods openly mod his new accounts. Can nothing be done about this?

There's a reddit with a mod who's been banned at least three times on three different accounts. First was two instances of CSAM of a 16 year old, and most recently was nonconsensual nudes. They don't even try and hide that it's the same person, first it was him making the accounts with the same name but different numbers, and the most recent one they put his account banned for CSAM as his flair. I've tried to submit reports to reddit multiple times but they've always gone ignored. Is there nothing that can be done about this?

reddit.com
u/YouVisual2425 — 3 days ago

Are there a definitive list of all default reddit report reasons?

I'm building a devvit app to remove posts that are repeatedly reported, and I want to prepopulate it with every default reddit report reason. The report reason is different from what is presented in the report UI, so "Harassment-> someone else" becomes "It's targeted harassment at someone else".

Does anyone have a definitive list of all the report reasons? I tried to pull this from subreddit insights but it wont go back more than 7 days.

reddit.com
u/stuartbman — 2 days ago

How can I make a post flair that people can only comment in if they have a user flair?

Desktop user here. It's for a sports subreddit. I know in one sports subreddit I was in, there was a message that would be displayed if someone didn't use a user flair. We're trying to get more representation of teams, so we wanted to make a post flair for people to comment on if they have a user flair because, for some reason, a lot of our members don't wear one.

reddit.com
u/fanime34 — 2 days ago

How to be unflagged as a bot?

I’m so frustrated. I’m a real person attempting to use Reddit for the first time. At first, I couldn’t post anywhere because I don’t have enough karma/my account’s too new. Cool, I found subreddits that are accommodating.

It still seems like I can’t post on most subreddits without being flagged as a bot by bots. It’s absolutely infuriating. I got a message saying to “message bot bouncer to appeal your account being flagged as a bot” but I don’t know how to do that. Do I post in that community?? Curious if I’ll even be able to post this without it being flagged and removed.

I wish there was some sort of verification because I’m not a bot lmao

reddit.com
u/onlyelisexoxo — 3 days ago

Why is it the mods can say whatever they like with no repercussions? Yet ask for grace and respect?

I feel like a lot of mods are too child like. Especially in the subreddits regarding going through past traumas etc. My concern is that there may be many people who feel suicidal and that one mod could push them over the edge that day. Some people’s social lives and support networks only exist online these days. Could it be taken into consideration not just keeping Reddit safe but having decorum and “grace” towards people as a mod? They always ask for grace and respect as they’re only human but find it impossible to extend that towards others.

reddit.com
u/atinyviolin — 3 days ago

Any mods have had people report mod removal comments as harassment?

Maybe it's common and I've just never seen it before but I recently joined a moderator team and today someone apparently reported the moderator comment about why a comment was removed as harassment against them.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

reddit.com
u/Immediate_Loan_1414 — 4 days ago

Commenter goes “ deleted “ after leaving a comment. Does anyone know why?

Hello mods,
There’s something I’ve noticed happening frequently in the subreddit I moderate. A user will leave a comment — sometimes even a constructive contribution to the discussion — and then shortly afterward their profile suddenly appears as deleted.

I find it strange because I don’t fully understand why someone would actively participate in the community only to delete their account right after. It makes me feel like there may be something else going on behind the scenes.

I’ve also noticed one specific user whose account appears to be banned by Reddit itself, yet they are still able to leave comments in the subreddit. The comments are not visible publicly, but moderators can still see them in threads.

Because of this, I’ll sometimes review a thread for rule violations only to encounter deleted profiles, while this particular banned account continues posting comments visible only to moderators.
I was wondering if anyone else has experienced this or has insight into what may be causing it.

reddit.com
u/Eric20255 — 3 days ago

Is it wrong for me to request data removal from a site that keeps reddit info?

Many weeks ago, I had someone I was talking to on reddit become really creepy and he basically sent me the title of a picture post I deleted many months ago. I asked him how he knew that and he sends me a link to this website where u can see past posts or something. I got really freaked out by this, so on that website it says u can request removal of ur info and I did, I got an email saying it was accepted and they removed it.

Now a mod tells me this is a red flag and nobody does this. He says its a mod tool, which I had no idea it was... Otherwise I would not have removed it if it means causing problems or being seen as a scammer.

Is this wrong?

reddit.com
u/sandxse — 3 days ago

Should Mods be required to follow the rules of their own community?

Everyone knows mods are basically their own little rulers of a sub. They can write the rules how they want, ban you, completely change the content of the sub. It's part of making one. My question, is should mods be required to follow the rules they add to the sub?

reddit.com
u/Either-Medicine9217 — 4 days ago

Permanently muted, no going back?

Hi guys! First of all, I do not try to appeal from a ban here and I won't say which sub is that, this is not a post about being banned, this is asking about being permanently muted after banned! Hopefully I do not break rule 7 with this question, if I do then I am terribly sorry and feel free to remove this post! I have been permanently banned from a sub for supposedly breaking a rule. When I got my permaban a mod said that I broke a specific rule (that actually I didn't break). Every couple of months I messaged the mods that permabanning me for that post was a honest mistake, and at the same time I always acknowledged that years before that I made a mistake and got muted justifiably, so I did have a past mistake but always acknowledged it. They always muted me for a month then I was able to write.

Yesterday I got a message that I have been permanently muted. My question is: so, this is it? I will literally never be able to appeal again, now it is impossible for me to appeal/write the mods of that specific sub in any way, forever? I really liked that sub, this is the only reason that I did not gave up fighting for my justice :(

reddit.com
u/anygal — 4 days ago