Lawnmower stolen from garage - who's responsible?
Hello! I help out a family member who currently lives abroad and is renting out their single-family home (Minnesota, US) in the meantime.
The lease includes an addendum that states that the lawn care tools stored in the garage belong to the owners but are available for use by the tenants, including the lawnmower. The tenants receive a $150 credit applied towards their rent each month because they have agreed to mow the lawn (during the summer) and shovel the sidewalks (during the winter).
At some point recently, the lawnmower was stolen out of the garage. As my family's property manager, I'm looking for advice and resources about who is responsible and reasonable next steps.
The owners are considering buying a new lawnmower (either a nice one they plan to keep long-term when they return to the US or a cheap temporary one in case it's stolen again). If they do, should the tenants be responsible for any or all of the cost? What about the cost of fixing up an old mower the family has stored away?
Another option they've considered is asking the tenants to choose between buying their own mower OR giving up their $150/mo credit for maintaining the lawn. This would solve the immediate issue but doesn't address whether the tenants are responsible (or not) for the value of the stolen mower.
Other factors that may or may not be important to consider as part of the conversation:
The original mower cost $350 and was an electric mower that required very little maintenance.
The owners have an old gas mower that we think could be fixed up for less than $150 and shared with the tenants. However a gas mower requires more maintenance that we're not sure we trust the tenants to be responsible for.
The original mower is named in the lease as being available for use by the tenants.
As previously mentioned, the lease includes a provision about the owners storing their tools in the garage. We have had previous conversations with the tenants about keeping the garage doors closed and locked when not in use so as to reduce the risk of theft.