u/DarthTrooper7705

The Clone Wars Multimedia Project vs The 3D series The Clone Wars and its other derivative works.

In my opinion, the multimedia project does a better job than the 3D series. I don't mean to say that the 3D series is bad, on the contrary it does a good job, but the multimedia project does it better. How its characters, for example, makes a better development and evolution in Anakin, seeing a very coherent and organic transition from Ep 2 to Ep 3. Also with others like the Jedi Quinlan Vos (a character that even George Lucas himself liked), General Grievous, Master Windu, Boba Fett, the clon trooper Alpha-17 and Obi-Wan. The various conflicts and battles presented to us are very interesting and even have a lot of tension about how they will end (several of which were even adapted into the 3D series) but in which we could see both the good side and the bad side win. But something that really stands out is how well it fits in with the films, because, as I already mentioned with Anakin, the multimedia project does a great job of being coherent and continuous with the Prequels, given that there are not many contradictions and that it even adds elements that we will see in the Original Trilogy.

That's why, for me, the Clone Wars Multimedia Project is better.

NOTE: Although at one time both the multimedia project and the 3D series belonged to the same canon, they have several contradictions that make it impossible for them to belong to the same continuity. Because of this event, it is decided that the 3D series and its other derivative works belong to the current Disney canon rather than the EU canon. (I mention this in case anyone comments that the 3D series and the Multimedia Project belonged to the same canon).

First Image: Natalie Portman and Carrie Fisher in 2002, during the Premiere Magazine's event "The New Power".

Second Image: Hayden Christensen and Mark Hamill in 2017, during the Star Wars Celebration.

Third Image: Natalie Portman and Mark Hamill in 2024, during the Golden Globes.

Red (Pokémon Special) vs Red (Main Games) vs Ash (Main Anime)

Representing the complete saga, no more, no less.

The truth is that the Rebuilds had everything to have an ending with this couple or perhaps something similar to Sadamoto's manga (which would probably have made us all cry) but the ending with 3.0+1.0 was truly disappointing, in my opinion (and not only because of this detail, I should be clarified).

I have this question because Takeshi Shudo was the main writer for the anime during the Original Season (Kanto-Johto), and he also wrote the screenplays for movies 1-3, if I remember correctly. Therefore, he played a very important role in the development and construction of the anime's story.

And in this novel, which he wrote, several details about various characters and the world itself are expanded upon and revealed. For example, here where we learn more about Ash's father and his grandfather; and it's where it's stated that people reach adulthood at the age of 10.

So, I'd like to know if this novel is still considered part of the anime canon or if it has been decanonized.

Todos lo estaban haciendo y yo también quería compartir mi opinión :)

PD: Todavía no he visto “The Mandalorian & Grogu”.

From manga “Neon Genesis Evangelion: Ikari Shinji Raising Project”, chapter 16.

From Red to Scarlet.