HOKA: Maybe not good for people with balance issues?
I have never worn HOKAs or any of the modern thick soled shoes. Have an older family member who has both balance issues and walking heel to toe. Google says HOKA are good for promoting rolling the foot forward smoothly and PT suggested them for the same reason. That's solving one of the two problems. But I'm concerned that the thick sole may work to make it harder to keep one's balance. Like, I would not want to wear platform shoes if I had balance problems. I'd want to wear a very minimalist shoe. Also, I'm wondering if the system of "unique rocker geometries" that HOKA uses might also work against balance. (I'm saying this in relation to the elderly, not runners/walkers who are young, strong, stable on their feet.)
We have a running store nearby so it's easy to have the relative try them on but I'm more concerned that 5 minutes wearing them won't be enough of an experience to conclude if they are appropriate or not. And falling down later isn't a good way to find out they aren't. Therefore, I'm open to thoughts on the pros and cons of HOKA shoes for someone with these two problems. I just want to do my best to help this person walk better while not falling down. I'll call the company, too, but of course they will likely say their shoes are good for everything, even if they aren't.
Thanks very much for your thoughts.