Comparing a 3-year MYGA with a 3-year Fixed index annuity. Which is the better choice?
I’ve been weighing a 3 year MYGA against a 3 year fixed index annuity and I keep going back and forth, so I wanted to hear how other people think through this. The MYGA is a bit easy to understand. You get a guaranteed rate for the full three years, you know the exact number upfront, and there’s no guessing. The FIA is more interesting to me though because your return is tied to an index, so there’s a floor that protects you in a down year but also more upside if the market does well. The tradeoff is that the upside gets capped, and comparing those caps across products is where I start to get confused. For anyone who’s compared these two, what ended up tipping your decision? Is a 3-year window even long enough for an FIA to be worth it over the simpler guaranteed route? And where do you go for honest reviews of specific products or providers, since most of what I find is often a sales page?