
Overkill to ask to make this better?
Took my car in to have the hood, roof, and bumpers re-sprayed. The bumpers were replacements, and the hood is original, but it needed new paint because E46s are notorious for the clear failing on the hood and roof.
All the panels on the car were original paint color. The shop suggested they blend the fenders to match the hood repaint, and this is the result.
So before all of these were factory matching (A pillar, door, fender), but in order to match the hood, they blended the fender into this. Not a professional, but I would guess the fender and door being different shade/tint would be more noticeable than if the hood and fender were different shade/tint.
The only panels not repainted now on the car are the 4 doors and the quarter panels.