Audiences unsure of where to react

Noticed this in a couple segments last night, and unsure of whether it’s the writing, the subject matter or the delivery.

But Bill will deliver a line, the crowd sits silent and he glares out at them trying to provoke his desired reaction… but the audience isn’t entirely 100% sure what that is.

Has anyone else noticed this?

reddit.com
u/JamiePlynth — 5 days ago

S5E8: “Gunpowder” one of the top episodes

Everything was so artfully done, with the parallels with gran’s antiquated TV, Guy Fawkes and the rebels, the whole sneaking in to do the interview, the way Bashir was portrayed as snaky with the vaguest hint of nobility. Then there was the power struggle at the BBC. I swear they could have made it two hours and I would have been riveted.

I also looked it up and yes the interview aired the night of the variety show, and yes- One Night Only was performed. I mean, you’ve truly lucked out when reality provides you with such perfect details across the board.

u/JamiePlynth — 8 days ago

Not enough is being said about Heated Rivalry as a production game changer

As we hear about them shooting 12 episodes this time around, arguably two seasons back to back, and the way they only shot for 36-37 days last time around; I find myself really paying attention to how they’re producing such high quality material. But I feel like apart from Valentina Vee and that podcast episode with Kara Swisher, their production isn’t getting enough attention.

A lot of attention has been paid to films like Obsession, Backrooms and Iron Lung, which shot for anywhere between 20-39 days, and on meager budgets, but while HR hasn’t done 382x their initial budget like Obsession (yes I know one is a movie and one a show but still), I really do feel like their budget and success really woke some people up to Jacob Tierny and Canadian production methods.

Dude pulled together some masterful stuff while using a bunch of tech -that didn’t blow the budget- including the volume, which a lot of viewers grew to call out as cheap looking. But Jacob etc did it really well.

Disney Marvel made Secret Invasion’s 6ep for $211m, which became a turning point for streamers to halt and second guess their content approach. Meanwhile Jacob and crew pulled things off for about $14m usd.

And I think that sent a lot of eyeballs looking north for a game changer in their own pipelines. Food for thought.

reddit.com
u/JamiePlynth — 13 days ago

Sylvie in The Crown: S5E3

It’s the “Mou Mou” episode, and I’m not sure why I didn’t catch that before. Wish she was in a different, larger role that interacted with the main cast.

u/JamiePlynth — 14 days ago

S5e4: Annus Horribilis, a new light

I actually made me look up the timing, but it was still kinda cringey to see Andrew go to ‘mommy’ to discuss his marital problems and seem light hearted, while ultimately frustrated with the monarchy.

Andrew & Fergie Marry: 1986
Separation: 1992
Divorce Finalized: 1996
Ghislaine intro to Epstein: 1999

u/JamiePlynth — 14 days ago

Moishe’s regret

At the end of S2 we see Moishe have a heart to heart with Joel, talking about how he took his bar mitzvah money, grandmas money, college money, birthday money, etc- then he gives Joel a cheque and fires him.

I was watching this scene and trying to imagine what Moishe was thinking, I mean beyond what he said.

I want to go back and rewatch their conversations at Steiner, because I wonder if Moishe was thinking about if he contributed to Joel’s marital failure.

I figure that maybe he felt guilty about depriving Joel of stuff, and pushing him into that job for his uncle in plastics. How he stressed stability and fear, and not enough about joy. He implored him towards wanderlust with a bankroll ($60k then = $700k in 2026 dollars)

u/JamiePlynth — 16 days ago

Bill The Saddest Man

Reported net worth $140mil. $20mil estate, $1mil condo in Catalina. No longer doing standup, quit the Hawaii New Years shows. $10mil salary from HBO, co-owns a pot shop. Watches old movies in the bathtub, has a podcast just to socialize with people “outside of work”, constantly telling us how smart he is while constantly bemoaning how much of a “loser who couldn’t get laid” he was as a teenager.

Dude has arguably won at life- but never got over being disliked growing up, so he’s just perpetually being miserable on main with his dwindling years left.

I have to imagine he’s never seen a shrink, or taken it seriously - because the shrink’s goal is to finally have him content and happy with himself, and his whole existence has relied on him being unhappy and contrarian. Can’t give that up.

Likely can’t maintain a long term partner because they’d have to navigate his moodiness and argumentative nature. If you’ve ever watched a handful of Club random episodes you’ll see how he even argues with people when they agree with him, not just because they have to agree with him in just the right way, but because they have to credit him with being correct in the first place.

At 70yo, he’s on the downside and counting his blessings, but it’s never been enough for him, and it’s far too late for him to change. He’s just going to be screaming how everyone else changed, and became unreasonable right to his grave. Hopefully the last of the broken boomers.

Can you imagine a life where the high point of your week is yelling at Paul Begala about TikTok genocide while fending off the advances of a drunk Donna Brazile? Or trying to rehabilitate Kevin Spacey and Arnie Hammer as your side hustle? Thinking you really did something with your time?

reddit.com
u/JamiePlynth — 17 days ago

Do you think Benjamin kept the Declan Howell?

When you think about how hurt he was when Rose came to talk to him at the hospital. They were so close to getting engaged. And in the house he bought for them, is an art collection made up of pieces he bought out of spite and competition - and a prized Declan Howell that Midge got him under mysterious circumstances.

Does. Benjamin. Keep. It?

It must be torture for him to look at something like that every day, a piece of beauty he can never fully understand or truly have.

u/JamiePlynth — 20 days ago

How would 2026 change the nature of the show?

With all the time that’s passed since the show debuted, we’ve gotten all these wearables -including the glasses- , consumer level AI with people loading up their entire existences, more insane tech moguls, door bell cameras, Flock, etc etc.

So I’m wondering, does anyone think the show would have changed dramatically with all these new trackable toys, or would it have just been par for the course?

I could see there being zero dead zones in NYC, and a more national grasp for Samaritan, but also a lot more independent players launching their own agents against one another, and perhaps Samaritan jumping the fence to clone itself and go rogue.

reddit.com
u/JamiePlynth — 20 days ago

Does everyone in the Royal Family just get less likeable as the show goes on?

Returned to a rewatch halfway through season four, just put on S5E1 with a brand new cast and while yeah, some downward trajectories -Charles- are obvious, I’m finding that they’re all way out of touch and tougher to cheer for. Was this always as obvious to everyone else or am I off base now?

reddit.com
u/JamiePlynth — 20 days ago

In another dimension…

John goes around busting heads, solving problems and saving people’s lives while his car H.A.R.O.L.D. feeds him all the Intel.

Can you imagine Joss with ‘80s hair and fashion looking a bombshell, and Lionel… wait…why does Lionel feel like he’d be unchanged getting dropped into this version?

(Root would be the car technician in a racing jumpsuit and Shaw would be perpetually trying to steal the car after having previously driven the competing S.A.M.A.R.I.T.A.N.)

u/JamiePlynth — 24 days ago

A thought about season 2

They will not have ANY issues filling the stands with extras, never mind extras wearing Montreal/Boston gear they already own.

Would you be an arena extra? Would they cap the number of extras they’d use? I think they could actually charge a small fee to raise money for charity, and I think people would pay.

They’ll never have to worry about running the same five background extras in a loop again.

u/JamiePlynth — 26 days ago

Changing Lanes

I’m just going to throw this idea out there in hopes it finds the right people and grows wings one day-

But I’d love to read a graphic novel where the character of Lane Kim is written, expanded, re-imagined, or given a completely alternate storyline by talented Asian-American women who grew up watching the show. Just like a big book of different authors and artists and their own takes on Lane’s life.

Like everyone else, I love Lane Kim and Keiko but will forever believe she was done dirty by the show. Seeing how ASP had improved her writing for (parts of) Mrs Maisel, I couldn’t help but wonder what Lane could have been if written by someone who shared some of Lane’s background, who was committed to a much richer story.

I don’t delve into fan-fic, so maybe stuff is already out there, but if not…man, make this and take my money.

u/JamiePlynth — 29 days ago

There’s too much love in this scene

From the moment she grabbed his hand the night before, to his steps up the fire escape (why DID he go up?), I could see why she loved him, I could see how he loved her, I could see why they were perfect for one another. I could see the mutual comfort and care with one another before they assumed the terribly constricting societal roles that ultimately broke them apart,

u/JamiePlynth — 1 month ago

Hersh guest spot!

Have been enjoying this show on AppleTV for the last couple months, when I’m not filling my time wrapping up my POI rewatch. So I was clapping on my couch when Boris McGiver showed up for a guest spot on the finale last night. Always love seeing Boris in stuff, he was great in House Of Cards too.

But man, POI ran for five seasons but their bench of great actors ran deeeeep, didn’t it? I was catching all the names and faces on my recent rewatch of folks who came out with great stuff later on. Might not have had the longevity of a Law & Order, but it certainly had amazing casting.

u/JamiePlynth — 1 month ago
▲ 32 r/TheBear

People forget, The Bear is a WHOLE show.

I’ve been heartened to see a lot of folks give love to the final season and come out into the open by saying “it was always great, every season”, because that’s the same way I felt, through the whole thing. Every time a full season dropped and I binged it I felt so lucky to get another taste and some more time the these people.

But I kinda want to go back and blame HBO a bit, not a lot- just the teensiest tad. Because it gave us the one of the greats with the Sopranos, at a time where a 13 episode run (seen as short back then) would become a huge cultural movement and appointment, water cooler TV. This carried on with Mad Men and Breaking Bad etc.

At which point every flailing cabler was looking for their weekly “moment” TV show (man, Halt & Catch Fire eventually grew on me but…)

So streamers like Disney+ came along, with their must see weekly drops of MCU TV that spawned a million reaction channels and deep online analysis, where EVERY DAMNED EPISODE had to reach some poignant climax and cliffhanger or else the mobs would revolt. Then Stranger Things first season blew up, and folks were acting like each season had to be brilliant or else-

Honestly, The Bear S1 was my least favorite but I was still into it to get into the masterfully perfect S2 and onward. But like I said in the title- it’s a WHOLE SHOW. It has a five season arc. It’s not 20 seasons of a procedural on network with 22eps a season. It’s a contained compact story. In some ways it’s almost a godsend they did full season drops, because if I had to listen to people pick apart each episode of S3 as if human existence depended on each minute being “perfect”…ugh.

It’s a whole damned show. I wish people treated it as such. Hacks ended as its creators wanted to, and when they wanted to- without padding it out for time or listening to “sweeps week” type network suggestions (what if Deborah went to space with a precocious child?!)

I love Frasier and Cheers and Superstore and Gilmore Girls, and will talk about them all like a fan- but while there are just as many low lights as highlights for them- I love the whole show. I didn't think Gilmore Girls was washed and done with when Chris came to Stars Hollow, I just suffered through those bits and kept watching.

I feel like the people who complained about John Cena doing a cameo and said they jumped the shark- those people never had to watch Married With Children or Growing Pains toss in a cute kid for actual ratings, and I’m sure the folks whining about Claire never had to sit through all those episodes with Dawson and Joey when we all knew Pacey was endgame.

Filming for streaming now means you do a whole season and put it out into the world as a set. Maybe there’s some tweaks between seasons, but these creators (maybe not the Duffers) know how it’s gonna end -and god willing they keep getting renewed- are gonna chart their course.

So hopefully people in time, people will appreciate the show as a whole, and not continue to pick away at its parts. Let the chef cook. Finish the meal. And perhaps remember that the next time we get a great show come our way.

reddit.com
u/JamiePlynth — 1 month ago

Spin-off the series but with a twist

Without knowing how it ends, but hoping Emily and the chef ride off into the sunset together (for the sake of my idea).

I want Sylvie and Luc to carry on the agency as an hour long drama, with Nicolas struggling to take control of JVMA after his “controversial” father’s passing.

No more light hearted fare, just cunning, strategy, intrigue and passion in the streets of Paris. Think Devil Wears Prada meet Succession meet Industry.

Hell, even bring back Camille to see how well she fares away from the goofy relationship stuff and with a dramatic role where her socialite connections has her join the agency as head of PR/damage control- a role that Sylvie sees as necessary but morally challenging.

Keep it rooted in Paris, show me every Arrondisement, give me grit and the romance of the ordinary.

u/JamiePlynth — 2 months ago

Special Request for Apple

I want the option to change the voice of Siri to that of Amy Acker. Because reasons.

u/JamiePlynth — 2 months ago