u/Mysterious_Fall_4578

So I’m halfway through Rhythm of War. Urithiru has fallen, the Radiants have been immobilized, The Sibling is shielded (for now I think), and Lirin is trashing on Kaladin still for not becoming a surgeon.

Listen, I get where Lirin is coming from. Better to save lives by literally saving them rather than killing people. It makes sense. It’s the right thing. But it’s so unrealistic in this world. It’s hard for me to agree with Lirin when he says stuff like things are going to be the same regardless of who’s in control.

Now I understand Kaladin is going through it right now, that boy has some serious PTSD. Fighting, especially solo, probably isn’t the best thing for him. But for Lirin to come at him like “I told you so” just doesn’t sit well with me.

I’m interested to see where this occupation leads! Also shout out to the soldiers and their commander Teofil. What an epic last stand, broke my heart to see them die.

What are some of your favorite character comparisons across different fantasy worlds? Why do these characters compare?

For me I see a comparison between Sylphrena (Sly) from the Storm Light Archives and Ari from the King Killer Chronicles.

Both Syl and Ari share an innocent wonder that never feels naive, just genuine. They’re drawn to understanding things deeply rather than simply observing, and both have a sharp wit underneath that curiosity, pushing back and teasing rather than just being wide-eyed.

They also form intense bonds with their protagonists (Kvothe and Kaladin). The interesting contrast is that Syl’s curiosity is tied to her becoming, as an honorspren growing into consciousness in the physical realm alongside Kaladin, her wonder is almost existential. Whereas Ari’s feels like a core personality trait baked in from the start, just who she is, world be damned.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

Thoughts?

So I’m a little over 100 pages into Rhythm of War and I love this honor amongst warriors. The idea that the Windrunners and the Heavenly Ones have this unspoken code of one on one combat is so cool.

I really enjoy how Kaladin and Leshwi are contesting rather than fighting to the death. This mutual respect is really cool. Maybe I’m missing something but I didn’t expect it, I really like it.

I’m excited to keep reading and see where this leads!

Also, Kaladin… are you okay? lol