
What's the hierchy of aversive tools? Least to most aversive?
Hello all! Posting for some input on tool choices..
I've recently started layering some correction over my training with my dog. He is a four year old Miniature American Shepherd. He used to be a major wreck of a dog behaviorally, but I've got him to the point that im kind of just finishing up a few behaviors with him. 99% of his training is done through R+ methods so far.
The issues I'm cleaning up are dog reactivity/seeking conflict with dogs. He reacts because he enjoys the conflict and the "fun" of barking/lunging at another dog. He's good in most scenarios, he can go to dog shows and sporting events and work near other dogs no problem most of the time. It just seems like sometimes he wants to react out of habit or for the fun of it, and i need something to help break him out of his focus.
I've been overlaying a slip collar/leash for the past few weeks. So far he's shown improvement with it. Though, today, when I took him outside of a dog park to train, he ended up lunging once on the slip and freaking out because of the feeling of the slip. He does wonderfully on it ✨️except✨️ for when he's lunging, to which it made him very sad and "melty." 😅
So onto the main question of my post. How would you all rank aversive tools from least to most aversive? It is quite a thin slip so I wonder if a thicker one would help? I've also heard that a prong disperses pressure better than a slip, but i'm not certain if that's true.
Thank you in advance, and please be kind 😭😅