Picking between NJ, Palo Alto or NYC
We’re trying to decide where to settle down. For context, I grew up in NJ, my family all now lives in NYC. I lived in NYC for 8 years before moving to the Bay Area.
My husband and I live in Palo Alto now and we had our first baby recently. We are hoping to have 3-4 kids. Thinking about long term where we can settle down and would love input.
Option 1: move back to NYC. I love this option, I loved living in New York and I found it amazing for both of our careers. It’s a magical place. However, I lived there in my 20s, never with a baby and I’m not sure how life is like there with a child. We want to have several children so I’m worried NYC will be just a short stint if we feel like we need more space eventually. I don’t feel like that now but I might. I also love the community and closeness to family which is important.
Option 2: NJ suburbs close to NYC. I enjoyed growing up in NJ, but my parents both worked super close to home. There aren’t a ton of jobs in NJ so my husband and I would have to commute into the city several times a week which feels a bit overwhelming + with children. I’m also worried about building community and feeling super isolated. But I love 4 seasons and the culture of NJ and I’m sure I’ll eventually appreciate the space?
Option 3: Palo Alto. We’ve lived here the last 3 years. It’s beautiful, but it feels a little isolating. The pros are that it’s close to a lot of jobs in the peninsula and easy to get to SF. Great weather and nice downtown. Education is good. Houses are small and super expensive and I don’t love the culture or community.
What would you do?