[Spoilers C4E20] The answer to the riddle posed?
- Hal
- Murray/Paint
- Thimble
It all crystalized for me after watching Murray sit in the theatre and what she witnessed. I haven't finished the episode, or the arc, but I'd be shocked if THIS is revealed yet.
Conjuration and Necromancy.
A doorway to death.
In Brennans own words, the separation of magic is almost arbitrary and the lines blur. Everybody BUT Hal, including myself, thought this was a summoning circle to some eldritch abonimation but then Hal said doorway. And then I thought abut Hal's role in all this and where Thiazi chose to place this spell. In a theatre. On a mural. A mural of all of those who have passed before him to now. A place where stories are told.
I recognized a hidden component to this answer, and it was laced in Brennan's positioning of who Thiazi is to Murray. The man who wielded the Liar's blade and the one who held all the hope to the end that the sun would one day shine again on the world.
The question posed:
Was Thiazi a good man?
And he asks it for a reason.
A doorway to death. Generations of people.
Is Thiazi a good man?
I believe Hal has the right of it. This is a doorway. A doorway to death. But if Thiazi is a good man then I don't think it's for an eldritch abonimation but rather for the people who have died and had nowhere to go since the fall of the gods.
If Thiazi is a good man then this mural is a resurrection spell that will undo ALL the death that was caused by the Shapers' war with men. It is the falcon's cry. A herald to the dead.
All the hope in the world that things could be better.
Perhaps this wasn't mere faith.
I wonder if Thiazi is among those of the dead and he let himself die as the near final component. A condition to the activation of the spell, as some great spells are want to do, effectively making it a failsafe for him and his wishes.
Because would any wise man or good leader let it all rest on his own head?
Final piece.
Thimble.
His most trusted companion. His right hand man. His sworn sword. The one who carried all his dreams with him, dutifully, seemingly without question. The one who would do anything for him.
Perhaps the one he trusted the most to activate it, if not for her sheer loyalty. She could almost do it without question.
I think Thimble is the key. The question now is how to turn it.