Best Eighth Doctor companion?

One for the Big Finish (edit: or EDA novels, or the comics!) fans - which of the Eighth Doctor's seemingly many, many companions is your fave?

I'm still pretty early on in my Eighth Doctor listening, so I've only really encountered Charley, but I love her being an Edwardian adventurer - it's so refreshing after 20+ years of NuWho mostly giving us "girl from 21st century London" (with only "group from 21st century Sheffield" really mixing it up!).

Who do you rate as Eight's premier companion, and why?

reddit.com
u/PhantomQuest — 20 days ago
▲ 167 r/doctorwho

Which Doctor/Companion pairings DIDN'T work?

Basically header. Some Doctor/Companions work incredibly well together, leaving their marks as a definitive combo. Others never seem to gel properly, or become as memorable a pairing. For example, I'd say Seven and Ace are iconic; Seven and Mel, less so.

Which pairings do you think didn't work as well as they could have?

reddit.com
u/PhantomQuest — 24 days ago

Did Justice League/JLU ruin John Stewart?

Whoa there, hold on a second and read before downvoting!

The Justice League animated series, and DCAU as a whole, is widely - and I think fairly - credited with catapulting John Stewart into mainstream recognition as "the" Green Lantern to a generation. It's a fantastic show in its own right. But did it also ruin John as character in the process of elevating his profile?

JL/JLU is where John's marine backstory came from, which has since come to dominate almost everything about the character. Him being a stoic, taciturn, military man with a preternatural skill at sniping has completely overshadowed his original socially conscious, free spirited, jazz-loving personality, in comics and on screen. Now, in Lanterns, that aspect has been ramped up even further, with him trained from birth for near-total obedience and militaristic servitude.

So, is the same show responsible for making John as popular as he is, in the mainstream at least, also responsible for scrubbing everything unique, individual, or dare I say it complicated from the character? And do you think there's any chance of seeing John return to his original personality, on the page or on the screen, or is "Marine John" far too entrenched now?

Edit: LOOOOTTA people lacking reading comprehension. The point isn't about how John is presented currently on Lanterns. It's whether Justice League/Unlimited wholesale changing him to be a stoic military guy - which has become his "default state" in ALL other media including bleeding back into the original comics medium - has erased what made him so interesting in the first place, even though that showcase elevated his profile.

(Image: screen shot from Justice League animated series)

u/PhantomQuest — 1 month ago

Chris gets no respect…! [Circuit Breaker]

The credits on the back of the newly released Circuit Breaker Blu-ray mis-credits Christopher Eccleston as "Ecclestone". It's not like he's the actor who launched modern Who or anything! 🤦🏻‍♂️

u/PhantomQuest — 1 month ago
▲ 790 r/doctorwho

David Tennant open to returning as the 14th Doctor: "It’s hard to imagine that’s where it would end"

I meaaaaan… Dave, we love you, but please only return if it ties the loop on bigeneration. The show needs a shot of something brand new.

radiotimes.com
u/PhantomQuest — 2 months ago
▲ 870 r/xmen

"Marvel's Feige Teases 'Sagas Upon Sagas' of X-Men Movies" - they're gonna keep that cast until they're 90

'Til they're ninetyyyyy…!

You wait years for a new X-Men movie, and then potentially 100s come along at once!

ign.com
u/PhantomQuest — 2 months ago
▲ 416 r/doctorwho

Dean Devlin (Independence Day) expresses interest in Doctor Who; wants Tennant back

Make of this what you will, and take it as a "somewhat sourced rumour" for now, but I think trying to drag Tennant back again would actually kill the show, not revive it. It would be an admission the show can't move on, that it's repeating it's glory days, and has nothing new to offer viewers.

cultbox.co.uk
u/PhantomQuest — 2 months ago
▲ 2 r/antiai

Google's AI-infested newsfeed messes up links

This may be familiar to Android users, but entries on the Google newsfeed are now increasingly AI-generated blends of multiple news stories, rather than bespoke links to discrete stories.

Just noticed it's generated a headline of "Ted Lasso returns for season 4", but drawn a link and header image from the upcoming "Lanterns" show.

What POSSIBLE use is this? It's proliferating mistakes directly into people's feeds, mixing sources, and presenting completely incorrect information. A feed of singular stories, even if algorithmically driven, has SOME use, but this is a complete mess. Worse, if it's happening with inconsequential stuff like TV series updates, how bad is it getting for "real", important news?

How can we trust ANYTHING we see or read online at this point?

u/PhantomQuest — 2 months ago

Breath of Fire IV - GOG, Steam, or neither?

I still have my PS copy of BOF4, but for ease/laziness I was thinking of grabbing the digital version for PC. The reviews on the Steam release are pretty iffy though, while the ones on GOG are pretty good, which surprised me - I'd have thought it was the same package on both platforms, with the same problems.

Does anyone know if there's any actual difference in the digital release on each platform that makes the GOG version better (beyond being DRM-free), or is it going to have the same problems the Steam reviews complain about?

reddit.com
u/PhantomQuest — 2 months ago
▲ 0 r/ebayuk

GSP/International buyer filed bogus return because he "changed my mind" - am I covered?

I (UK seller) sold a bit of video gaming kit last week to a buyer in (Republic of) Ireland for just over £100. I'm a private seller, not a business, and all my listings are set to "no returns accepted".

This morning, I get a return request, with the only reason given being "changed my mind". I've declined the return request and repeated what I put above - private seller, no returns, etc. So far, I've had no further contact (but it's only been a couple of hours as I type this).

FIRST QUESTION: Does anyone know if I'm covered by the recent changes to international sales, where eBay sorts it out and I don't lose the sale value, or could this guy cause trouble?

I suspect the guy is trying to do a scam, and send back either an empty box or a broken version of the item sold (which was in immaculate condition, tested, and fully working days before it sold). I took photos for myself of the item's serial number just in case, but not sure if that would be enough to protect me if it does progress further.

SECOND QUESTION: Is eBay basically cooked now, when it comes to selling any bit of tech, or anything above, I dunno, £30? It seems as though every buyer is a scam artist trying to claim bogus refunds, lost items, or "not as described", and eBay does little to nothing to protect individual sellers. 🤬

reddit.com
u/PhantomQuest — 2 months ago

‘Booster Gold’ DC Series Not Moving Forward at HBO

Original Showrunner/writer off, supposedly still moving forward with new team.

Until it actually gets off the ground though, there's always the back issues to re-read…

(Deleted original post as story updated while I was typing!)

hollywoodreporter.com
u/PhantomQuest — 3 months ago
▲ 6 r/blackpanther+1 crossposts

Black Panther - when/how did Shuri's powers change?

I'm waaaaaay behind on "core" Black Panther runs - still at the start of Coates' run - but I just read Black Panther: Intergalactic, the Imperial spinoff, and it seems Shuri has>! animal shapeshifting powers now, transforming into a murder of crows amongst other forms.!<

When and how did this change come about, and if I'm reading from the start of Coates, how far off am I from reading it?

Personally, I don't mind spoilers, but please tag for others who do!

reddit.com
u/PhantomQuest — 3 months ago

Marvel is rethinking variant covers; Midnight "limited" to… 10 per issue 🙃

Oh, wait, actually 11 covers. Per issue. On every single Midnight book.

From Popverse:

"Marvel says it plans to limit the Marvel Midnight books to 10 variant covers and a main cover. Any additional variants would be store-exclusives."

"Marvel says they want to make sure they're 'fun' and 'additive' and not merely gaming collectors."

Y'know what really helps with not gaming whales collectors? Not doing one shy of a dozen covers on every single issue of a new imprint.

I'm extremely skeptical that these Midnight books will connect with audiences anyway - they just seem grimdark for the sake of grimdarkness - but flooding the market with 33 covers each month (plus extra store variants! 🙃) across the three titles and then claiming that that's actually showing restraint feels like an especially low move from Marvel.

thepopverse.com
u/PhantomQuest — 3 months ago

Another subtle Doctor Who/Star Trek "crossover"!

In the season four premiere episode of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, "Valles Marineris", there's a fun little Doctor Who Easter egg. At the start of a command crew meeting, there's this exchange:

Pike: This is an unusual mission. We are to face a category ten interstellar squall, something we rarely see in the Alpha Quadrant.

Pelia: I-I've seen one once, a long time ago, but not from this close. I think I was in a phone box at the time…

Given how many times the Doctor has shown companions some awe-inspiring cosmic spectacle from the doors of the TARDIS, and how there's already been a TARDIS cameo in Star Trek, this is certainly a deliberate nod. And Pelia has previously mentioned hanging out with a time-travelling Doctor! I love these little cross-fandom hat tips! 😂

reddit.com
u/PhantomQuest — 3 months ago
▲ 341 r/doctorwho

The War Between the Land and the Sea FINALLY coming to Disney+… in 2027 🤦🏻‍♂️

Russell Tovey has told Radio Times that The War Between the Land and the Sea is FINALLY going to appear on Disney+ for international viewers, but not until 2027.

Two things here: one, that still might not be official, given he's an actor and not production side, but it's the first positive update on the show on months. And two, if it DOES stream on Disney+ next year, that could release any blocks on main Doctor Who production that may still be in effect as a result of the co-production deal (an unconfirmed but long-suspected situation), as Disney would have fulfilled its contractual obligations by finally airing everything produced as part of the deal. Fingers crossed, on both fronts!

radiotimes.com
u/PhantomQuest — 3 months ago
▲ 215 r/jonkent+1 crossposts

If Tomorrow Man sticks as an identity, does he already need a new costume?

With Tomorrow Man established as>!Jon Kent's new identity!<, do you think this will last, or only as long as Slott is on the title?

The ID itself, I don't mind - it's a perfectly serviceable superhero name - but I think if it does stay, the costume needs an almost complete overhaul. The colour scheme scans as Superfamily, but the logo - while probably meant to evoke the Kryptonian Flamebird and Nightwing - reads more as Batfamily, and the tiger stripes are just a weird bit of distracting, needless detail. The blotchy/shifting gloves don't work either - too inconsistent a detail to work long term or between different artists.

I'm glad to see the October 2026 solicits at least have the full face mask receded to a domino/cowl combo, but it's not enough of an update to make it fully work, IMO. I'd at least add S-shields to the shoulders as a clear visual link.

u/PhantomQuest — 3 months ago

Awkward that Kyle, John, Guy, and Carol were invited but Hal wasn't... 😂

Hal's invite got, uh, lost in the mail...?

✨READ THE FRICKIN' POST!✨

This is the cover to the NEW Anniversary Special celebrating 30 (real world) years since Lois and Clark got married. It's a PRESENT-DAY story, hence the crowd all being in their costumes as of 2026, and with plenty of characters who didn't even appear until years after the wedding. It is being published in October 2026, with many of the original creators returning, but telling a BRAND NEW story. It is NOT the original wedding story. It is NOT set during the time Hal was Parallax and/or dead. (He just didn't get an invite. 😅)

I swear to god, the replies to this thread have made me question the basic literacy of half the people commenting… 🤦🏻‍♂️

(Cover art from the upcoming Superman: The Wedding Album - 30th Anniversary Special, by Dan Jurgens and JErry Ordway)

u/PhantomQuest — 3 months ago

Got all three Yasmine Putri variants of Green Lantern 35-37!

Managed to grab all three Yasmine Putri variants on the last few issues of Green Lantern!

They make such a gorgeous triptych, I'm thinking of getting them framed as a set.

u/PhantomQuest — 3 months ago